Awkward Source: 60p -> 24p

[cools]

So, I've come across a source which was originally 24 fps, and I believe converted to 30 fps by repeating frames followed by a bob (iThink) to 60 fps - which creates some judder that is imperceptible at 60fps - however, when slowed down or decimated it immediately becomes apparent and when freeze-framed aliasing-like lines show up. I've tried a couple of things - to varying degrees of success - but haven't been able to truly fix the issue.

TestClips

Example of Aliasing Like lines (around the book):


Fixed!:


Simply applying TDecimate(cycleR=3) doesn't work as the file ends up bobbing up and down - especially noticable in slow moving scenes (not so much in fast motion).

So one of the ways I came about trying to fix it was by merging the odd and even frames together

MPEG2Source("full-movie.d2v")
v1 = SelectEven()
v2 = SelectOdd()
Merge(v1,v2)

#and the decimation back to 24p while dealing with annoying pop-ups...
saved = last
CropBottom(150)
Tdecimate(clip2=saved)

While this works in slow moving scenes (like the image above - it also works well for whiskers...) - it usually creates some wicked ghosting in faster moving scenes.




I then also tried using dup() with blending to much greater success - it works quite well in most scenes, but in slow scenes it can end up not being effective as the judder is more apparent and the threshold would have to be jacked up for it to work correctly.

MPEG2Source("full-movie.d2v")
dup(threshold=2,blend=true) #thresh set to 2 based on other parts of the film
saved = last
CropBottom(150)
TDecimate(cycleR=3, clip2=saved)

I suppose something like this:

MPEG2Source("full-movie.d2v")
saved = last
CropBottom(150)
TDecimate(cycleR=3, blend=true, clip2=saved)

would work - if it was a thing! So any ideas on the best way to fix this issue?