Log in

View Full Version : MP3 players to be taxed in the Netherlands?


Arachnotron
22nd April 2005, 17:02
There seems to be a proposal by the "Stichting de Thuiskopie" (http://www.cedar.nl/thuiskopie/info-gebruikers.html#tarieven) (which has a mandate from the Dutch government to collect the copy-tax on blanc DVD's and such) to also charge MP3 players for €3.28 per gigabyte storage capacity. Which adds €132 to the price of a 40 Gb apple iPod.

I could not find any links in English, so here is a Dutch link (http://www.tweakers.net/nieuws/37030?).

As with the blanc DVD charge, the idea is that you have the right to make one copy of TV shows and such for personal use, but that you have to pay for that. And to safe you from the hassle of contacting the licence holders personally, those nice people over at Stichting Thuiskopie have already taxed all blanc DVD's for you. And they are more than willing to do the same for your MP3 player. What is next? Taxing flashcards? Harddisks? Memory? :(

Interesting aside: if you go to the homepage of this Stichting and type "mp3" in their search engine, the first hit you get is from a site that offers unlimited downloads for €0.99 per month to p2p users... :D

Doom9
22nd April 2005, 19:16
well.. if it were to buy you a free pass for any kind of audio and video copyright infringement then I'd be inclined to fully support it... but that would mean getting rid of the EU-DMCA and that's not gonna happen. As usual, the industry wants to have their cake and eat it.

Arachnotron
22nd April 2005, 19:56
I think the end result here is going to be that mp3 players are simply sold separately from the flashcards. No memory, no added costs. And flashcards/memorysticks/whatever are not taxed (yet)

Arachnotron
22nd April 2005, 20:06
You are not going to believe this. I just downloaded a document from their site listing (http://www.cedar.nl/thuiskopie/Lijst%20uitgesloten%20dragers%20februari%202004.doc) professional storage formats which are exempt from charge. At the end it states:Dragers waarover onderhandeld wordt of welke ter discussie staan (op dit moment nog geen Thuiskopievergoeding over verschuldigd)

- Memory/Geheugen
Compact Flash, MM Card, Memory Stick, Secure Data Card, Smart Media, USB Stick/USB Storage Device

- MP3 Spelers/ Harde schijvenRoughly translated: Storage devices which are still undernegotiation or are being discussed (over which no homecopying charge is owned at the moment)

So, in fact, ANY portable storage device is going to be charged...:eek: