dvd2one VBR vs dvdshrinkHQ

[FarCry]

i want to transcode a movie and i dont know which of these 2 is the best. anyone knows please share his opinion with me:)

dvdshrinkHQ equals to deep analysis along with adaptive error compensation. just to clarify

[Trahald]

please, please .. no what is best threads.. please review the forum rules. Search should yield you some results to work with.

[jwo62]

it all depends. what movie are we talking about? do you already own dvd2one?

I would use dvd2one over dvdshrink for most movies unless there are two aspect ratios or a lot of extras on the disc,then i would use dvd95copy or dvdshrink in reauthor mode.

if you are really concerned about using the best program,you should use both,burn to dvd-rw and judge for your self what is best. there are too many variable factors as well as your personal preference to consider,no one can tell you what is best or what you will like.

[FarCry]

Originally posted by Trahald
please, please .. no what is best threads.. please review the forum rules. Search should yield you some results to work with.

i have used the search function but i didnt come up to something valid about this particular comparison. thats why i took this course of action and made a post.

jwo62

yes i own a copy of dvd2one. you dont have to doubt. i have tried both but i cannot see any actual difference between the results of those 2. maybe someone has used a wide screen like a home cinema and has spotted the differences or has used special programms to do so. i am not aware of any evalution methods to conclude which is the best

[Fishman0919]

If you, the one who is going to be watching the movie can't see any differences between the two.... does is really matter.

I could tell you to use InstantCopy 8 or DVD-RB w/CCE or the BIG 3 and swear it the best thing in the world but if you can't see the difference, then it's really point less.



RRRRRRRRRrrrrrrrrrraaaaaaa, why did I start in on this.... what is the best.... what works for you.

[jwo62]

Originally posted by FarCry


yes i own a copy of dvd2one. you dont have to doubt. i have tried both but i cannot see any actual difference between the results of those 2. maybe someone has used a wide screen like a home cinema and has spotted the differences or has used special programms to do so. i am not aware of any evalution methods to conclude which is the best


the best place to test video quality is on your pc's monitor.

I only asked if you already own dvd2one because if you were planning on purchasing it,i would have recomended another program.

[FarCry]

Originally posted by Fishman0919
If you, the one who is going to be watching the movie can't see any differences between the two.... does is really matter.

I could tell you to use InstantCopy 8 or DVD-RB w/CCE or the BIG 3 and swear it the best thing in the world but if you can't see the difference, then it's really point less.



RRRRRRRRRrrrrrrrrrraaaaaaa, why did I start in on this.... what is the best.... what works for you.

this happens to my 17 nch TFT screen. if i use a 30 incd TV display using a DVD video theni might see the difference. i aonl asked because i wanted to know which is the best of this 2 not only for my screen but in general. you have to be open-minded.

i found out another program called dvd2dvd-r which is like dvfshrink freeware. this is better? thanks

[RaistlinMajere]

always makes me laugh when people ask about the quality differences between these transcoders. If quality is that important use something like cce or tmpgenc lol

[FarCry]

i had a problem with a movie that the DVD-RB couldnt finish the prepare stage. thats why i asked about these 2 programs. i turned out to be that is was corrupted the original dvd-video and it was not a problem of DVD-RB