Numenu stops at Vobsub

[Yayita]

I am doing a PAL -> NTSC Menu conversion, with Numenu4u. After decrypting, Numenu continues with the vobsubing and there it stops with this message:


Searching vobs...
Found C:\CDROM\D_VIDEO_TS\SUBTITLES\VTS_01_0.vob
Indexing...
Counting timestamps from 0ms (v01c01)
Indexing mode: File
v01 c01 lba00000000, total=0ms, off=0ms, corr=0ms, discont.:1, cell=0ms
Encrypted sector found, searching key...
ERROR: Key not found, can't decrypt!


I do not know how to proceed, because I have never seen this error.
The original DVD is completely unprotected, so I have no clue why it is seeing protected sectors. I copied it with DVD decrypter and there's no bad sector... :confused:

Ideas welcomed
Y

PS
Vobsub version: D3s7 custom build. I guess the one that comes with Scenaid 1.5 .

[Zeul]

I assume you made an iso first with dvddecrypter?

[Yayita]

No I am reading from the DVD. But I followed your line of thought. I reburnt a DVD image with nero (using the DVD files), to make sure it is DVD compiant, but I get the same errors .

:confused:

[Zeul]

As a test can you create an iso image and mount with daemon tools and retry.

[Yayita]

That's exactly what I did, and I still get the same error. Some people report this problem with vsrip:

http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=47180

But gabest does not provide a solution.

I wonder is it bad authoring? How can you remove the encrypted flag from the data??

[D3s7]

well gabbest has pretty much dumped the project... I'll take a look at the code and see if I can isolate the solution

[Yayita]

:thanks: for your effort D3s7

[D3s7]

what are you using to decrypt?

i looked at the code and see what's going on at least however I really don't understand why you'd be getting this from a mounted .iso unless your making an iso w/ a utility that doesn't decrypt

[Yayita]

I am using DVD Decrypter, automatically through Numenu. However the content is unencrypted, so I do not understand.

NuMenu calls DVDdecrypter to decrypt (actually copies only since its unencrypted) to HD.

Then vsrip, as called by Numenu reads the menu VTS_01_0.vob from the HD and thinks its encrypted.

??

[D3s7]

what makes you think it's unencrypted?

what disk is this?

LightUK, maybe you have a theory on this (if you read this)

[jarthel]

Originally posted by D3s7
what makes you think it's unencrypted?

Doesn't DVD decrypter automatically removes region encoding and macrovision when files are copied to the HDD?

[Trahald]

well.. i guess we are wondering what is being used to create this 'unencrypted' source..
Anyways, If you would be so kind, please as a test use dvd decrypter to make an iso from your unencrypted source dvd and then run numenu from that.. it may result with the same error but may help trouble shooting. would be appreciated (if you do decide to do it, pleeaasee do as i asked above, not what you may feel is equivelant). again.. many thanx..

btw.. how big is the file.. it may come down to needing it to really trouble shoot it.

[Yayita]

Guys.
Thanks a lot for your help, I really appreciate your effort in knowing what is going on.

@Trahald as I said, I DID decrypt it into an iso (with latest DVDDecrypter) and mount it with daemon tools then used Numenu as said in previous post.

The DVD is a home made DVD with Pink Floyd footage. That is why I know it is unencrypted. But regardless it is treated as encrypted by Numenu when it copies the files to the HD either directly from the DVD or from the mounted iso image.

I have the intuition that the problem may be the authoring...

If someone knows where I can post the smallest menu (16mb) if anybody wants to inspect it.

[Zeul]

NuMenu just points vsrip to a special vob file that is created by dvddecrypter. I presume you are using one of the more recent builds of dvddecrypter? In the SUBTITLE folder there should be a vob file named VTS_01_0.VOB and an IFO file. If you send me this file ,the VTS_01_0.IFO, and the param file (zip them first) then i can analyse it.