tjhart85
6th September 2007, 04:04
If we're not judging by peoples perceptions, how can we judge which is better?
Perception IS reality. If 99/100 people say video clip A is better than B, clip A is better. Unless your test group had 99 blind people in it.
CCE was pretty much across the board the best choice (with the exception of TitanAE), therefore, CCE (well, DVD Rebuilder in general) is the way to go!
Just because a computer says that video B should look better does not make it so.
Fisherman did this test while at work, he didn't hunt people down. If 50 people don't wanna volunteer their time, it doesn't matter, its still a good real world test.
Its also an objective test, which is important (well as objective as you can get working in a A/V store & testing the customers).
If you wanna conduct your own study, go for it, but all that really matters when it comes down to it is perception, so you can't cut that out.
---------------------
Also a good test to conduct would be showing people 3 identical clips from the original DVD and ask them to pick which one is better. :-) I am curious how that one would turn out.
Perception IS reality. If 99/100 people say video clip A is better than B, clip A is better. Unless your test group had 99 blind people in it.
CCE was pretty much across the board the best choice (with the exception of TitanAE), therefore, CCE (well, DVD Rebuilder in general) is the way to go!
Just because a computer says that video B should look better does not make it so.
Fisherman did this test while at work, he didn't hunt people down. If 50 people don't wanna volunteer their time, it doesn't matter, its still a good real world test.
Its also an objective test, which is important (well as objective as you can get working in a A/V store & testing the customers).
If you wanna conduct your own study, go for it, but all that really matters when it comes down to it is perception, so you can't cut that out.
---------------------
Also a good test to conduct would be showing people 3 identical clips from the original DVD and ask them to pick which one is better. :-) I am curious how that one would turn out.