Log in

View Full Version : DVD to Divx Encoding in Two Steps...Am I Doing Something Wrong?


carlosglz
11th March 2005, 04:29
I have read dozens of articles & tutorials here, on divx.com and other sites about converting Dvd movies to high-quality Divx video with an embedded Ac3 5.1 channel audio stream.

All of them make reference to virtualdub and usually have 4 or more steps. The procedure I have been using is only two steps, but since everyone else seems to be doing this differently I want to know why my method is wrong...or not so right...in terms of quality loss/compatibility/time spent encoding/etc.

Here is my Procedure:
1. Rip DVD movie using SmartRipper into one big vob file with the correct audio stream (usually English Ac3 5.1) embedded in the file.

2. Fire up Dr. Divx and convert the movie to a Home Theater Quality Divx file (I never change any of the settings). Note: My system uses the WinDVD 5 codec with a registry fix that doesn't allow it to drop frames.

Dr. Divx does its two passes and two to three hours later I have myself a great-looking Divx movie, usually 750mb - 1.5 gb in size. It plays beautifully on my computer and home theater pc using only ffdshow as the Divx/Ac3 decoder.

If there is something technically wrong with doing it this way, I am really curious to know what it is...any comments, however brief, are appreciated.

Thanks in advance.

obieobieobie
11th March 2005, 08:08
No, it looks technically OK. :)

If you want to try other solutions, you can download AutoGK and see if you get a different result.

ChronoCross
13th March 2005, 17:10
Well technically it would look finebut I think that you might be able to get higher quality if you used filters to enhance the movie. that's done through avisynth and requires more steps. which is what you see in all the other guides.

DigitAl56K
13th March 2005, 18:56
I don't think Dr DivX ever uses the WinDVD codec for video decoding..