Log in

View Full Version : How about an MPGShrink?


usg
11th February 2005, 14:27
With the growing popularity of HDTV and HD captures, it would be useful to modify the DVDShrink to work with TS and non-DVD standard mpegs to shrink to a manageable size. For example, the TS capture for a typical HBO movie capture is more than 2 DVDRs. If we can shrink the data to 2 DVDRs(or 1 D/L) w/o sacrificing much on quality, most people would not need to re-encode it to DVD/Divx/XVid etc for storage.

It should not be a big/complicated undertaking since the underlying transcoder engine(from DVDShrink) may be used w/o DVD standard restrictions.

Any thoughts?

2COOL
11th February 2005, 19:08
Originally posted by usg
it would be useful to modify the DVDShrink to work with TS and non-DVD standard mpegs to shrink to a manageable size.DVD Shrink has CEASED development and the author WON'T make it open source. So, it's just eternal wishful thinking. :(

iantri
11th February 2005, 23:02
ReJig (http://www.videohelp.com/tools?tool=449) does the same sort of thing, but on MPEG files.

I think you'll find, though, that you can't requantize the video as much as you want to (~9.4GB to ~4.7GB is 50%, much more than that may not be possible), and it will look bad.

E-Male
11th February 2005, 23:23
you can enter values down to 0.0001% or something like that
but (of course) it can't go that far
it can go further with cleaner sources than with noisy ones
of course from a certain level on (downwards) the loss will be visible
but it is the best (only) free&open-source transcoder i know
you should try it out
also: test the results on the tv you'll use (classic tv's are much more forgiving to artefacts than monitors, and you also sit further away)

usg
12th February 2005, 01:41
Thanks for pointing towards Rejig. Has some one tested it by transcoding HD (1280x720 or 1920x1080) files? Anyway, I will give it a try. Can it work directly with a TS or a MPG/M2V is necessary? Thanks.

E-Male
12th February 2005, 02:46
you'll have to try