Log in

View Full Version : Comptest with nero recode ?


hubereevez
13th December 2004, 12:34
Hi,

I did like this compressibility test under Gknot and xvid,divx.

Is it possible with h264 ?

Thanks

hubert

Selur
13th December 2004, 22:25
I doubt that something like a comp test would give any usefull data if one wants to use CABAC (Context Adaptive Binary Arithmetic Coder),..

babayaga
13th December 2004, 23:21
Originally posted by hubereevez
I did like this compressibility test under Gknot and xvid,divx.

Is it possible with h264 ?


There is nothing that prevents it except we did not provide any tool to do it :(

It's fairly easy to do with all statistics from the encoder ... It's like many usefull tools (muxer/demuxer, cutter/joiner etc.) maybe in a new version if there is a strong demand for it.

hubereevez
13th December 2004, 23:38
Thanks babayaga

CABAC (Context Adaptive

Mhmm i did though about that. It's the same thing when you try to test compressibility, with tools like mvtools or masktools in your avisynth script, isn't it ?

Thanks anyway

:)

Hubert

akupenguin
14th December 2004, 00:13
CABAC has nothing to do with the feasability of a compression test.
While some filters can produce unpredictable changes in compressability, CABAC is very consistent at 10(+-3)% improvement.
And if you decide that the uncertaintly is too great, you don't have to disable CABAC in the test; it's only a small fraction of the encoding time.