Log in

View Full Version : How can I get 1-line Subtitle to display at bottom of Screen?


Alcacia
14th September 2004, 19:11
I'm using this program to convert AVI to DVD with external SRT file.

Some of the subs are 2-line, and some 1-line.

The 2-line subs show up perfectly, but the 1-line subs show up not all the way at the bottom of the screen...they should be shifted one line down.

I don't understand why DVD2SVCD subtitle preference, Y-pos, refers to the position of the first line of text, and not the bottom of the last line of text.

It seems to me that subtitles should be as unobtrusive as possible, and when there is only 1 line of text, that should be pushed as far down as possible.

I also notice that when changing font size, style, etc...that the Y-pos needs to be adjusted...leading to time-consuming trial and error...if only we could specify the *bottom* of the last/bottom line of text, then Y-pos would only need to be set once. DVD2SVCD could easily calculate the positioning based on font type/size and the number of lines...for *each* subtitle.

The only workaround I have found for the 1-line problem is to go through the SRT file, and insert a line containing only the character "-" before each 1-line subtitle. I tried to find some kind of function like this in Subtitle Workshop, but couldn't. It appears that this has to be done completely manually.

Manngo
20th September 2004, 11:31
Hi!

The problem is coming from the history of DVD2SVCD. It was started as an anything to svcd program. SVCD cannot be anamorphic, so all the WS movies became letterboxed. The subs were placed in the bottom black line, and thats why it is allaigned upwards. The aim was to place the subs the closest to the picture area, becouse it is more convinent to watch. The method does not it's best for anamorphic results.

Inserting a blank line is a good idea.
If I were you I would simply do it with Excel. In the past, I succeeded to work with subtitles in MicroDVD (.sub) format.

Manngo
3rd October 2004, 02:04
OK, I wrote a small program, to modify the scenarist scipt to allaign the subtitles down.
Download here (http://manngo.fw.hu/ssm)

How to use:
Run DVD2SVCD as usal. Allaign the subtitles as usal, that the most lines containing subtitles reach the bottom of the screen. After D2S starts Scenarist you can shut down both. Copy my prog to the project dir and run. After you have to run scenarist manually.

I wish you very nice widescreen movies!

cheers
Manngo