Log in

View Full Version : To film in a cinema costs three years of jail


guada
28th June 2004, 20:49
Hello everyone, :)

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Senate passed two bills on Friday that would carve out a larger role for law enforcers in the entertainment industry's struggle to limit unauthorized copying of its movies and music.

People who secretly videotape movies when they are shown in theaters could face jail time, while hackers and industry insiders who distribute copyrighted works before their official release date would also face stiffened penalties under one bill.

A separate measure would allow prosecutors to file civil suits in copyright cases, rather than criminal suits which require a higher standard of proof.

Copies of hit movies frequently show up on the Internet while they're still in theaters, thanks to pirates who sneak camcorders into movie theaters to tape films directly off the screen or industry insiders who leak copies to tech-savvy hackers.

Under a bill sponsored by Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas and Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California, those found guilty of such behavior would face up to three years in prison for a first offense, or five years if it was done for profit. Repeat offenders could spend 10 years behind bars.

Movie studios and other copyright holders would be able to sue for damages.

A similar bill was approved by a House of Representatives subcommittee in March.

Another bill sponsored by Democratic Sen. Patrick Leahy of Vermont would allow the Justice Department to use the same legal tactics as the recording industry, which has sued more than 3,000 people for distributing its music online.

In criminal cases, prosecutors must prove that defendants knew they were breaking the law, while civil cases only require proof that the act took place.

The Justice Department would get an extra $5 million per year through 2009 under the first bill, while the second would provide an additional $2 million next year to teach U.S. officials how to handle civil copyright suits.

"We are now one step closer to making thefts far more difficult, prosecution of criminals much easier, and the protection of consumers and artists much stronger," Cornyn said.

The Recording Industry Association of America said both bills would allow more options to help enforce copyrights.

An official with a trade group for "peer to peer" networks like Blubster and eDonkey was less enthusiastic.

"They're using federal prosecutors as a civil law firm for Hollywood," said Adam Eisgrau, executive director of P2P United.

niamh
28th June 2004, 21:31
Under a bill sponsored by Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas and Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California, those found guilty of such behavior would face up to three years in prison for a first offense, or five years if it was done for profit. Repeat offenders could spend 10 years behind bars.

That's it!!! I'm thinking of dealing hard drugs to make it into the world, it sounds far safer :D

Seriously, I wonder who the hell they are going to blame for non- existent slumps in sales in the future, if this works.......Will they start shooting actors who perform badly? Or invade and "civilize" Hong-Kong? Scary. And the movies will still come out anyway, this is a big world...And I still won't watch them, but that's me,
I've never been a fan of black&gloom image coupled with a wax-engraved type mono audio track ;)
I am pretty sure that something like Lord Of The Rings was pirated over and through, and before and after and went all over the world like a flash....how many hundred of millions $ did they make anyway? But surely it has nothing to do with it being a quality product? Of course it was a big blow to the popcorn & soda sellers in the theatres, it surely is worth 3 years :p

unmei
29th June 2004, 18:56
To film in a military area can make you some lifetime friends in the darker offices of your governments :p
Sorry, i agree this is a bit harsh, but on the other hand you can't tell me you don't know what you do if you film there.. If you don't think about how it is looked at when you take out your camera in a cinema you must be so extraordinary stupid that it actually is a little wonder if you know how to turn this device on.

fccHandler
1st July 2004, 19:52
Just saw this:

Teen Caught with Camcorder at "Spider-Man 2"
http://movies.yahoo.com/news/va/20040630/108865224500.html

EDIT: adding Slashdot's version:
http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=04/07/01/0314239&mode=nested&tid=123&tid=188&tid=97&tid=99

Joe Fenton
2nd July 2004, 03:12
And while they were taking away that one boy, nine others filmed the rest of the movie. :D

What a waste! They'll catch a couple morons and celebrate, but the "problem" will continue unabated. Look at the debut of Harry Potter - WB spent millions making sure every usher at every theater had NVG, they caught no one, but bootlegs were on the net within hours. Wow... that worked great!

Arkay
2nd July 2004, 03:37
Personally I think they should put 'em in jail for 10 years, just for the rubbish quality they release :) Who the hell wants to see a cam rip of a new film with the guy in front standing up or stretching. Camera wobbling, hardly hear it for the guy next door sneezing....

Cheers,
Arkay.