Log in

View Full Version : The Runtime Error 9 thread - reply with yours


Pages : 1 [2] 3 4

SvensK
11th May 2004, 11:09
Getting Run-time error '9': Subscript out of range,
when trying to 5pass CCE encode my Die Hard R2 (PAL).

Using DVDRB 0.47

Edit: It happens as soon as I press Prepare.

Second edit: Weird, this was fixed by using drive M: as source which has NTFS instead of drive E: which has FAT32.
You might wanna look into that.

biggy7
6th June 2004, 00:07
Originally posted by SvensK
Getting Run-time error '9': Subscript out of range,

Second edit: Weird, this was fixed by using drive M: as source which has NTFS instead of drive E: which has FAT32.
You might wanna look into that.

cheers mate!

was also getting runtime 9 when i was pressing the prepare button, and my source was indeed on a Fat32 hard drive, so i put the source on a ntfs hard drive and it started to prepare,

using 0.49 at the moment as it seems to work well on my pc, the rest just start to encode files very quickly, CCE just opens and closes very fast untill it says encoding complete.

jcclow
7th July 2004, 05:17
Titantic (it's for the wife)

I used DVD Remake Pro 2.2.1 to get rid of the junk I didn't want (FBI warnings).

Created .d2v and scripts fine. Encoded fine (225 min. 7,420mb).

Used idct=5 on all my scripts (thanks wmansir!)

Get runtime error 9 while trying to rebuild...
-Updating NAVPACKS for VOBID:3
-Rebuilding segment 3 VOBID:4 CELLID:1

3.0 P4 HT, 1gb Dual Channel DDR400, 3 HD's (total 180gb), ATI AIW 9600XT, Plex DVD-R, Lite-On CD-R, Plex SCSI CD-ROM, Adaptec 2940 SCSI Adapter, 600w Coolermaster PS, XP Pro

Used DVD-RB 0.55b.

jdobbs, this software is amazing! I will donate to your cause!

incidentally, all of my drives are NTFS.

JadedMan
2nd August 2004, 23:06
I got runtime error 9 on 2 DVDs so far: Star Wars I & AI
Ripped with DVD Decrypter 3.2.3.0
Used DVD Shrink 3.2 to rip main movie
- I cannot use original rip because of multiple angles
Using CCE 2.67.00.09, EclCCE 1.81 & DVDRB 0.56
Each DVD originally had RCE Protection before being ripped.
I get error on rebuild when 99% complete

Using Athlon XP 3200, 1GB Dual Channel RAM, 2 - 120GB Hard Drives (NTFS).

I have successfully backed up other DVDs.

Just adding to the database :)

Otherwise, this software is wonderful - thank you jdobbs :)

I'll keep posting if I continue to have issues.

kenkong
17th August 2004, 18:39
I get it everytime I try and use rebuilder. Right when I start the rebuild phase.

Rasta
25th August 2004, 22:47
I've gotten Run-time Error 9 on two different backups. I rip the titles I want using DVD-Shrink w/no compression. I get this problem from The Sopranos Second Season Disc 1 and "28 Days Later." I am using DVDRB 0.56. This always happens in the rebuild phase. This happens over and over. If anyone could help I would really appreciate it.
*Rasta

Rasta
26th August 2004, 19:53
Bump. This is not just for me, I know there are some other people with this problem but have yet to find a solution. From what I have seen, the common denominator seems to be that people have get Runtime Error 9 with DVDRB are using DVD Shrink but I saw post somewhere else where some use DVD Decryptor so I don't know. I'm specifically using DVD Shrink 3.2 and for "28 Days Later;" I rip just the main title and the 5.1 audio stream with no compression. DVDRB seems to be the best for backup solution for very large movies or episodic discs and I have had a couple successful (Queer As Folk Season One Discs 1 and 2, also Vanilla Sky, and Helter Skelter have worked) but I'd like to figure out how to resolve the Error 9, maybe this would help others too. I should have mentioned that this only happens when it is rebuilding and doing the NAV Packs, specifically:

"-Rebuilding segment 34 VOBID:16 CELLID:1"

Well again, any help would be greatly appreciated

Van the man
26th August 2004, 20:24
getting the runtime 9 error when clicking on "prepare"
my source is on a ntfs drive.

Im using cce 2.50 with eclcce.
Dvd-RB 0.56

Im not using the half D1 and half space thing.

Do someone know whats wrong?

I had the dvd on my computer and then I made a img of it all,but when it was done I found out it had one .srm file in it.
Do ya'll think it has something to do with the error?
the dvd also was missing some .vob files but I replaced them with "dummy" files. Maybe it doesnt work then?

thanks for all the replys on this one

jdobbs
27th August 2004, 01:55
If you are going to rip... use a ripper -- DVD Decrypter. It's free and is the best ripper on the planet -- I don't understand why anyone want to use DVD Shrink as a ripper? It's like using a screwdriver to drive nails.

If you are using Shrink to strip the movie before running it through DVD-RB you are only asking for trouble. If you absolutely have to modify it (which I really don't recommend) -- use DVDRemake.

Rasta
27th August 2004, 06:53
Thanks Jdobbs. I'll try Decryptor, I use DVD Shrink to rip because it allows you to preview each title and I don't want menus or anything like extras, just the movie with the audio and english sub picture, and its easy to figure out what's what with Shrink. Anyway, DVDRB is great, I suppose Shrink is doing something to the IFO's or something, I don't know.
*Rasta

DrChair
27th August 2004, 12:43
I also have a dvd now, that gives a runtime 9 error, during the prepare stage, just after scanning the last vts.
After this, rebuilder.inf only contains some info about the sizes of the first 4 vtses, but nothing about the last vts.

This error happens every time with 0.56 and 0.55b. I tried it on a mounted ISO and on the files decrypted with dvddecrypter.

However DVD-RB 0.50b doesn't give the error, so it seems you might have reintroduced a bug...

Anyways as a workaround, I'll do the preparing for this disc with 0.50b and the encoding+rebuilding with 0.56

Greetz DrChair

Rasta
27th August 2004, 18:14
err ....

Ok, I just used DVD Decryptor to rip the main movie of The Truth about Charlie. I didn't do anything weird, just selected "Main movie + ifo" and ... Bam, Runtime Error 9 while doing the Rebuild, this happened at 99 or 100% .. I'm using DVDRB .56. Is there any way to know why this happens or what is going on? This is what it says:

"- Rebuilding segment 21 VOBID: 2 CELLID: 1"

That is the line it failed at: the previous line was:

"Updating NAVPACKS for VOBID_01"


Admittedly, I know very little about this but I checked the source directory I was using and it is like this and the only files I have are:

VTS_01_0.IFO
VTS_01_1.VOB - VTS_01_5.VOB (so I have 5 VOBs)

Is the rebuilding portion of DVDRB blowing up because it expects "VOBID: 2" to be there and I only have one VTS titleset? Or do I just have no clue and should wait til someone who knows what their doing offers some help? =)

Well again, any help would be really appreciated. But if that is the case, how do I prevent this, again all my runtime error 9's are in the Rebuild portion and usually are either finished or nearly finished. If this is the case does that mean DVDRB is using the IFO information from the original source, which maybe mentions other VOBIDs? ... well I don't know, hopefully fixing my issue will help other people too.
*Rasta

Rasta
27th August 2004, 18:36
Correction to last post, when using DVD Decryptor I did not select "Main Movie + IFOs," I selected "Main Movie" which gave me only one IFO file. I don't know why this would be necessary or if there is a workaround to get away from including those files or what ...
*Rasta

robot1
27th August 2004, 19:33
DVD-RB is a tool for a full backup, not for a movie only backup.
You can't rip main movie only. You have to rip all files (in file mode) or, even better, make an iso (mode->iso->read) and mount it with daemon-tools or another similar tool.

:readguid:

Rasta
27th August 2004, 19:57
I see, I was starting to see that, though with all due respect the After Dawn and the Doom9 guides do not explicitly say that, in fact the Doom9 guide refers to the DVD Decryptor guide which says to rip the main movie. Nevertheless, ok, when I use IfoEdit on the VIDEO_TS folders of the problematic DVD's (whether I choose the "ripped output" or the DVDRB output) and I open up an .ifo and click "get sectors" it does say something about correcting a problem in VMGI_MAT, what that means I don't know but the backups that work fine don't report this, so I'm suspecting the problem lies in the ifo or something ...

Anyway, ok if DVDRB is intended only to backup the full dvd, what does one do to backup the main movie, or just episodes in the case of an episodic DVD, and encode those with CCE to make them fit while retaining quality? It would seem that DVDRB would be great for this, and I guess mysteriously it does work fine on my Queer As Folk box set so far. To me it seems a lot of quality is lost in attempting to retain all those extras even if you "steal space," etc. Does anyone else only want to retain the main movie or in the case of an Episodic discs, the main episodes and make a simple menu for it? I guess I'm stubborn, I want to use DVDRB because it works so well at preserving quality, and it seems there should be some way to do this ... Oh well, if someone knows a workaround or a different way (not DVD2ONE or DVD Shrink) then please let me know, preferably using DVDRB.
*Rasta

Faust2
27th August 2004, 23:00
I succeeded with DVDShrink in Reauthor mode. In this case Shrink generates a new DVD-Structure, containing only the main movie, and this "DVD" you can use as source for RB. BUT keep the structure simple. No menus, just one plain titleset.
It works like this (with Shrink 3.1): Rip the source with Decrypter as described in the varios guides, use ISO-mode, and mount the image with daemontools; OR use file mode BUT be sure you get all files. Then start shrink, select "reauthor" (not backup), browse to your source, select the title(set) you're interested in, "add" it to the left part of the window by right-clicking it, mark it and then check "no compression" at "compression settings". Then hit "Backup!". After you're done, use shrink's output directory as source for RB.
I never had any problems, but this procedure isn't "officially" supported by DVD-RB, so if you get errors, it's propably not RB's fault.

Rasta
28th August 2004, 00:06
Faust, ya I do that, I use the latest version of Shrink but that's what I have done. Its worked on a couple and doesn't work on others but it seems to rarely work now. I don't use Decryptor then Shrink though, it seems redundant, but I will try it though I suspect the same problems will arise. There's got to be a way that works to accomplish what I'm trying to do, its really not that extravagant. I know, I could conceivably rip the DVD, like with Shrink, and use DVD Lab to re-author and make completely new IFO files, with no menu or anything, and then use DVDRB on that. I think, hypothetically, that should work with no issue but that is a LOT of what I think is needless work and very non-standard, if it wouldn't enter more problems into the mix.
*Rasta


- I must add that when I use VOBRator to analyze the VIDEO_TS folders, the last VOB on the DVDRB input always results in "failed to render graph" when you attempt to preview the VOBID that DVDRB fails on but if you preview the VOBID right before that one it is perfectly fine and it is actually the end of the credits. This happens on all the ones that fail, and if I preview the last VOBID of the DVDRB output it outputs fine, which contains the end of the movie (credits) just as the input. I played both DVD Decryptor output and the DVDRB output in WinDVD and it all plays fine except somehow the Chapters are screwed up in the DVDRB Output (there are 5 less chapters but the only difference appears to be where and how many chapter markers, the movie is still the same length), maybe this has to do with difference in frame positions. So I don't know what all this means, it just makes me think that this Error 9 can't be a huge problem and there must be some workaround or something. Btw, the DVDRB output *looked* great as always.

Faust2
28th August 2004, 11:00
like Jdobbs said:


If you are going to rip... use a ripper -- DVD Decrypter. It's free and is the best ripper on the planet -- I don't understand why anyone want to use DVD Shrink as a ripper? It's like using a screwdriver to drive nails.


maybe shrink 3.1 is better in keeping the standards? as far as i know the new version isn't so long out of beta yet. I used the above "movie-only-method" many times and didn't have a single problem. I can imagine, however, if you use shrink to strip just one extra and two warnings out, the possibility of srcewing up the structure is higher.

Rasta
28th August 2004, 22:11
Well since it seems like I've been documenting my problem I may as well post the last bit I've discovered ...

I used used DVD Decryptor to rip the entire DVD (The Truth About Charlie) and then used Doom9's guide for IfoEdit to remove the main movie only. I must admit I got a bit lucky in choosing the VOBID as I don't really have that technique down. After using the IfoEdit guide, I used DVD Rebuilder and it worked flawlessly. The chapters remained intact correctly, as well.

If nothing else it looks like I was right in that there was a problem in the the IFO file(s). Although this worked, if I had not gotten lucky choosing the VOBID this would have just been a wasted 5 hours. I still think there must be a workaround or something simpler to do to make this work, and I wouldn't even want to attempt for backing up any of my episodic DVDs. For some reason, I have this feeling that all the main movie VOBs for the movies I've done successfully with my DVD Shrink method had only one VOBID. It seems like Error 9 pops up when it attempts to use a VOBID other than 1, but this is just a neophyte's conjecture. Hopefully, this post is not all for naught.
*Rasta

Trahald
28th August 2004, 22:16
Originally posted by Rasta
...Anyway, ok if DVDRB is intended only to backup the full dvd, what does one do to backup the main movie, or just episodes in the case of an episodic DVD, and encode those with CCE to make them fit while retaining quality? It would seem that DVDRB would be great for this, and I guess mysteriously it does work fine on my Queer As Folk box set so far. To me it seems a lot of quality is lost in attempting to retain all those extras even if you "steal space," etc. Does anyone else only want to retain the main movie or in the case of an Episodic discs, the main episodes and make a simple menu for it? I guess I'm stubborn, I want to use DVDRB because it works so well at preserving quality, and it seems there should be some way to do this ... Oh well, if someone knows a workaround or a different way (not DVD2ONE or DVD Shrink) then please let me know, preferably using DVDRB.
*Rasta

There is nothing wrong with wanting to be able to only back up part of your dvd for qualities sake. Problem is trying to make a tool that the author intended for all video to be kept using it. I wish my car had a button to fly.. id get places alot faster. but i cant blame ford that thats not the case because they think cars are best on the ground. And i (note the 'I') cant demand/expect that they add it (suggest politely maybe) ;)

Rasta
28th August 2004, 22:50
Oh definitely. I'm not trying to demand anything, after all I haven't paid for it but I think its still great software. The problem is I think this can already be done with DVDRB but something weird is happening or whatver and just trying to get to bottom of it and maybe help other people as well. =)
*Rasta

SVCDPhreek
5th September 2004, 21:34
DVD-RB : .57a
AviSynth: 2.54
dvddecrypter: 2.3.0.1

i get this error during the prepare proccess the dvd i am trying to backup is Red Green :Suffed and Mounted 3 and 6 both give me the same error , when i look in the work directory the d2v files goto vts 10 ,but the dvd itself has 14 vts,
what i am trying to say is every time i have had dvd-rb try to backup any dvd with 11 or more vts's it gives me the Runtime error 9 subscript out of range.

am i doing something wrond? or is this a dvd-rb problem?

so far i read this whole thread and all who posted problems had older versions of dvd-rb , and the error happened in the rebuild proccess. mine happens in the prepare

Thanks to all who Help others
SvcdPhreek(dvdPhreekiest)

jdobbs
5th September 2004, 23:45
11 VTSs or 11 VOBs within a VTS? You should be able to have up to 99 VTSs (DVD standard) -- but can only have 10 VOBs (0 - 9) within each VTS.

2COOL
6th September 2004, 04:13
Originally posted by jdobbs
11 VTSs or 11 VOBs within a VTS? You should be able to have up to 99 VTSs (DVD standard) -- but can only have 10 VOBs (0 - 9) within each VTS. Definitely out of specs and here's what I wrote on this matter. About filenames (http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?threadid=71071&highlight=filename+8.3)

jdobbs
6th September 2004, 18:36
I just found and corrected one instance that could cause an Error '9' -- if anyone reports getting a '9' at the very start of an encode, and it doesn't seem consistent across DVDs; this one was likely your problem. It will be posted as a part of v0.58.

JadedMan
8th September 2004, 19:23
The error 9 problems that Rasta has documented in this thread are verbatim the problems I have been experiencing. I also have been ripping the main movie only using DVDShrink 3.2.0.15 with no compression in the interests of preserving as much quality as possible. The error comes up during the rebuild phase at 99% complete. The latest movie I tried is Master & Commander. When I play back the resulting output, I also experience shifted chapter points, the same as Rasta has already documented.

Thank you Rasta for documenting this problem so well and for sharing a workaround, albeit as you point out, it's a rather involved process. I agree that the issue is potentially simple and could be an problem with the DVDShrink output. Let's hope that this problem will be fixed :) I still think that DVDRB is the tool of choice to make DVD backups :)

jptheripper
2nd November 2004, 17:34
Runtime 9 error since upgrading to v0.66
Winxp
File image loaded in FantomCD to virtual drive

Title - Taking lives Unrated R1 NTSC (no preprocessing)
dgdecode.dll
ccesp 2.67 5 pass
half d1 steal space on vob that errored

many successfull backups before

runtime error on rebuild


Title - Hidalgo R1 NTSC (remake preprocessing
dgdecode.dll
ccesp 2.67 5 pass
half d1 steal space on vob that errored



hope the issue is not back

Methanoid
3rd November 2004, 00:17
Just got my first error of any type using DVDRb

0.64 beta

On VTS_49 on a backup of B Movies (Brain from Planet Arous / Teenagers / Tom Corbett). Tried several times with and without Half D1 Extras. Only ever sets up the FLG and AVS files, no encoding done.

Hope this is fixed in the next public one. Can supply screen dump if needed

jptheripper
3rd November 2004, 16:13
3rd runtime 9 error, no preprocessing..

Dawn of the Dead r1 ntsc..

one of my settings must have gotten screwed up.

It is the last cell of the main movie vts that is crashing, 1 frame, yet cce 2.67 generates a 2560KB file. I remember this happening before, switching back to 2.50 helped i think.

I will try that again

grrr...

any ideas would be very appreciated

jdobbs
3rd November 2004, 17:35
Where is is happening (PREPARE, ENCODE, REBUILD)? Any details would be helpful.

jptheripper
3rd November 2004, 18:07
it is only happening in the rebuild. It is crashing on the single frame items. I had this problem a long time ago, switched to 2.5 on my other machine and it went away.

I am redoing the project with the same settings except switching to 2.5 and will let you know if there is any problems

jptheripper
3rd November 2004, 18:16
the problem seems to be the generation on the single frame cells. Seems as if 2.67 makes a 2.6mb m2v file out of these, and on the rebuild something goes wrong. I am baffled as to how a single frame can generate a file that big regardless of bitrate, i actually think its a problem in cce but unfortunately i have no idea how to explain it.

jdobbs
3rd November 2004, 20:20
Does the AVS file show only one frame?

jptheripper
3rd November 2004, 20:24
yes

well it was a trim (276000,276000) for example (made up numbers)

im reprocessing atm with 2.67 to get exact avs that generate the m2v

jdobbs
3rd November 2004, 20:46
Thanks.

jptheripper
3rd November 2004, 20:51
#------------------
# AVS File Created by DVD Rebuilder
# VOBID:02, CELLID:01
#------------------
LoadPlugin("C:\Program Files\AviSynth 2.5\plugins\DGDecode.dll")
mpeg2source("L:\DOD_OLD\D2VAVS\V01.D2V")
trim(157136,157136)
ConvertToYUY2(interlaced=true)
AudioDub(BlankClip())



is the one that produce the error..

it just hit me that maybe avisynth 2.5 and dgdecode.dll are not playing well together? Im using the june 07, 20004 dgdecode.dll, and wondering if i upgraded versions and decoders at the same time? hope i havent wasted your time

jptheripper
4th November 2004, 15:25
Identical avs generated for cce 2.50, however, rebuilt with 0 errors. I fear this is a problem with a difference between how 2.5 and 2.67 deal with single frames.

I will check the ecl's now.

jptheripper
4th November 2004, 15:36
From ecl files.. first is working ecl for cce 2.50

[item]
title=V01002100002001
aud_out=0
vaf_file=L:\DAWN OF THE DEAD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.vaf
aud_file=L:\DAWN OF THE DEAD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.mpa
file_focused=0
packet_size=2048
width=720
height=480
frame_rate_idx=1
cbr_brate=6000
vbr_brate_avg=393
vbr_brate_min=0
vbr_brate_max=6688
seq_endcode=1
dvd=0
half_width=0
half_height=0
lum_level=0
aspect_ratio=3
gop_m=3
gop_nm=4
gop_hdr=12
seq_hdr=1
all_closed_gop=0
fix_gop_length=0
samples_per_sec=44100
stereo=2
brate_idx=7
crc=1
progressive=0
alternate_scan=1
intra_dc_prec=2
encode_mode=0
vmode=1
fast_mode=0
quality_prec=37
timecode=0x0000000
vid_file0=L:\DAWN OF THE DEAD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.m2v
vid_file1=L:\DAWN OF THE DEAD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.m2v
vid_out=1
vaf_out=1
opv_q_factor=20
opv_brate_min=0
opv_brate_max=6688
vbr_bias=10
vbr_pass=4
use_filter=0
filter_val=6
non_linear=1
top_first=0
mpeg1=0
mpeg1_cps=1

[file]
name=L:\DAWN OF THE DEAD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.avs
frame_first=0
frame_last=1
encode_first=0
encode_last=1

jptheripper
4th November 2004, 15:37
And this is the one from cce 2.67 that causes the runtime 9 subscript error on rebuild

[item]
title=V01002100002001
aud_out=0
vaf_file=L:\DOD_OLD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.vaf
aud_file=L:\DOD_OLD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.mpa
file_focused=0
packet_size=2048
width=720
height=480
frame_rate_idx=1
cbr_brate=6000
vbr_brate_avg=393
vbr_brate_min=0
vbr_brate_max=6688
seq_endcode=1
dvd=0
half_width=0
half_height=0
lum_level=0
aspect_ratio=3
gop_m=3
gop_nm=4
gop_hdr=12
seq_hdr=1
all_closed_gop=0
fix_gop_length=0
samples_per_sec=44100
stereo=2
brate_idx=7
crc=1
progressive=0
alternate_scan=1
intra_dc_prec=2
aud_mode=0
tc_ref_frm=0
drop_frame=0
fix_vbv_delay=0
letter_box=0
pulldown_detect=0
offset_line=0
create_new_vaf=1
credits_tweak=0
credits_start=0x00000
credits_brate=1000
h_filter=0
h_filter_idx=8
dither=0
dither_max=8
qmat_idx=0
quality_prec=24
timecode=0x0000000
video_type=1
vid_file0=L:\DOD_OLD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.m2v
vid_file1=L:\DOD_OLD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.m2v
vid_out=1
vaf_out=1
opv_q_factor=20
opv_brate_min=0
opv_brate_max=6688
vbr_bias=10
vbr_pass=4
use_filter=0
filter_val=6
non_linear=1
top_first=0
mpeg1=0
mpeg1_cps=1

[file]
name=L:\DOD_OLD\D2VAVS\V01002100002001.avs
frame_first=0
frame_last=1
encode_first=0
encode_last=1

Methanoid
4th November 2004, 22:11
Originally posted by jdobbs
Where is is happening (PREPARE, ENCODE, REBUILD)? Any details would be helpful.

I was using One Click but tried separate to identify WHERE it goes wrong and its on the PREPARE stage. It gets to VTS_49 and then barfs with Runtime 9. The display shows:

VTS_49: 544,559 sectors.
--Scanning and writing .D2V file
--Processed 44,496 frames
--Building .AVS and .ECL files
-Reduction level for DVD-5: 60.0%
-Overall Bitrate: 2842Kbps
-Space for Video: 3,753,374KB

Are you sure its not overflowing on 49 VTS's!! :sly:

Its got me stumped.. I LOVE this s/w and use it regularly now.

Toranaga
13th December 2004, 18:22
I am getting a CCE crash at the last encode and then "Subscript out of range" when rebuilding. Movie is LOTR Return of the King EE. I have ripped to movie only and am using 0.68. Anything to be done?

jkcheng122
22nd December 2004, 16:06
seems ppl are still runnin into this error, it is happening on every disc i've tried on now. even reinstalling didnt work.

jkcheng122
23rd December 2004, 02:06
Originally posted by JadedMan
The error 9 problems that Rasta has documented in this thread are verbatim the problems I have been experiencing. I also have been ripping the main movie only using DVDShrink 3.2.0.15 with no compression in the interests of preserving as much quality as possible. The error comes up during the rebuild phase at 99% complete. The latest movie I tried is Master & Commander. When I play back the resulting output, I also experience shifted chapter points, the same as Rasta has already documented.

Thank you Rasta for documenting this problem so well and for sharing a workaround, albeit as you point out, it's a rather involved process. I agree that the issue is potentially simple and could be an problem with the DVDShrink output. Let's hope that this problem will be fixed :) I still think that DVDRB is the tool of choice to make DVD backups :)

shouldnt be a problem with dvdshrink, b/c i used clonedvd2 and recode2 to preprocess and the same error came up. i then tried no preprocessing and still the same problem occurs. by same problem i meant what u described (rebuild fail at 99% and chapter shifts). i'm using cce 2.67, that half and half thing is disabled. i'm gonna have to give 2.66 a try, if that dont work then try 2.50.

this error thing could very well be an issue to cce 2.67 being incompatible with dvd-rb since jptheripper had the same disc work with no error when he switched to 2.50.

jptheripper
23rd December 2004, 02:26
yeah

likely you vts 49 is a low bitrate vbr (sub 400) but odd that it is crashing in the prepare phase.

jdobbs
23rd December 2004, 02:30
Let's nail this down... because this thread seems to be all over the place...


1. When does this error occur?
2. Is it always related to single frames?
3. Does using 2.50 always fix it?
4. Is there an NTSC movie that ALWAYS causes it?

Please don't answer with "always" or "every disc" -- as that only convinces me you have some other problem and I won't respond. I can't come to your house to debug this.

Note: Contrary to conspiracy theories -- DVD-RB was not seen meandering around the grassy knoll just before the Kennedy assassination. DVD-RB was questioned and judged as "coincidentally present" by the Warren Commission.

jkcheng122
23rd December 2004, 04:37
Originally posted by jdobbs
Let's nail this down... because this thread seems to be all over the place...


1. When does this error occur?
2. Is it always related to single frames?
3. Does using 2.50 always fix it?
4. Is there an NTSC movie that ALWAYS causes it?



1. most of the time at the end of the rebuild phase, sometimes at the very beginning right after copying unaltered files.

2. i dunno how to answer this one.

3. have not tried 2.50, will post here with results. i will likely attempt this overnight.

4. i have 3 movies that all came up with the same error repeatedly

Trahald
23rd December 2004, 06:50
Originally posted by jkcheng122
4. i have 3 movies that all came up with the same error repeatedly I think he was looking for specific DVD titles.. and what region they are (hopefully R1 ntsc so he can try to duplicate).

Toranaga
23rd December 2004, 15:50
LoL I just ran three different discs through without problems. I will try to find a specific NTSC film that gives me problems (the movies I had problems with was PAL).

jkcheng122
24th December 2004, 03:07
switching to cce 2.66 worked, so the issue is definitely (well, let's say 99% to stay away from that "always" word) between cce 2.67 and dvd-rb.

Toranaga
24th December 2004, 09:22
Originally posted by jkcheng122
switching to cce 2.66 worked, so the issue is definitely (well, let's say 99% to stay away from that "always" word) between cce 2.67 and dvd-rb.
Really! This is great if we can get this cleared up. I will keep running 2.67 until I run into an error and then try and older version of CCE.