DoItFast4U crashes when demuxing a Stargate DVD

[DarkFear_DK]

Hello Peeps,

I am trying to make a backup of my Stargate DVD's, however, when I am trying to demux the DVD, it crashes after trying to demux the subtitles 3 times in a row (each time it extracts the same VOB files again using dvddecrypter).

I'll include my DIF4U log at the end of this message.

I know for a fact, that the DVD is a duplicate VOB id DVD, but DIF4U should be able to handle this, right?

I have successfully backuped up many of my other DVD's using the same method as I'm using with Stargate (Scenarist NT & the big 3 @ doom9.org).

I hope someone have an idea as to what this might be caused by.

Thanks in advance

-- DarkFear_DK



----------------------------------------------------------------------



(03:03:39) Welcome to DoItFast4U! v.1.4.0.0 - By Eyes`Only
---
(03:03:39) Avisynth Version Detected= 2.5.4.0
(03:03:39) Checking AVS Scripts...
(03:03:39) OS Kernel = NT (good!)
---
(03:03:39) Checking for CDROM/DVDROMS... Found Drives= E: F: G: H: I: J:
(03:03:39) Used Right Click on Folder: D:\DVDTEMP
(03:03:39) Checking for Angles in VTS 01...
(03:03:39) Program_Chain_Information_Table_Offset--4096
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--112 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 1 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--426 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 2 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--716 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 3 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--1078 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 4 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--1432 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 5 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--1794 Number of Cells= 5
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 6 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--2302 Number of Cells= 5
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 7 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--2706 Number of Cells= 6
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 8 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--3138 Number of Cells= 5
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 9 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--3542 Number of Cells= 5
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 10 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--4074 Number of Cells= 5
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 11 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--4606 Number of Cells= 6
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 12 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--5166 Number of Cells= 5
(03:03:39) VTS 1 PGC 13 Minutes= 43
(03:03:39) Checking for Angles in VTS 02...
(03:03:39) Program_Chain_Information_Table_Offset--4096
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--16 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 2 PGC 1 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) Checking for Angles in VTS 03...
(03:03:39) Program_Chain_Information_Table_Offset--4096
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--48 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 3 PGC 1 Minutes= 0
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--346 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 3 PGC 2 Minutes= 1
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--644 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 3 PGC 3 Minutes= 1
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--942 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 3 PGC 4 Minutes= 1
(03:03:39) VTS_PGCI_Start_Byte--1240 Number of Cells= 1
(03:03:39) VTS 3 PGC 5 Minutes= 1
---
(03:03:39) Checking for updates...
(03:03:40) Version 1.4.0 is latest <--No new Final versions found.
---
---
(03:03:40) Install Directory = C:\Programmer\DoItFast4U
(03:03:40) Current Directory = D:\DVDTEMP
(03:03:40) Checking For Duplicate VobIDs...
(03:03:40) Checking For Duplicate VobIDs...
(03:03:40) In VTS 1, PGC 6 is in PGC 10. Unchecking PGC 6
(03:03:40) In VTS 1, PGC 7 is in PGC 11. Unchecking PGC 7
(03:03:40) In VTS 1, PGC 8 is in PGC 12. Unchecking PGC 8
(03:03:40) In VTS 1, PGC 9 is in PGC 13. Unchecking PGC 9
(03:03:40) Duplicate VobID Checking Complete.
(03:03:40) Duplicate VobID Checking Complete.
(03:03:40) PGCs with Duplicate VobIDs were unchecked and logged to notes file. (Possible manual use of Scenarist required)
(03:03:40) Automatically selected 1 as largest VTS.
(03:05:38) Opening NuMenu4U!
(03:05:38) C:\Programmer\NuMenu4U\NuMenu4U.exe /start /path="D:\DVDTEMP" /threshold=25 /drive=E /passes=5 /avebitrate=1800 /swap /deinterlace /cceo /ccev /close
(03:06:34) Continuing with DoItFast4U! Demux.
---
(03:06:34) Current Dir= D:\DVDTEMP
(03:06:34) DVD Drive= E:
(03:06:34) Autocreating Directory
(03:06:34) DVD Drive= E:
---
(03:06:34) DVDDEC Version 3.2.1.0 Location= C:\Programmer\DVD Decrypter
---
(03:06:34) Newer version of DVDDec detected (3.2.1.0)
(03:06:34) Split Mode= cellid VobID_Demux=0 CellID_Demux=1
(03:06:34) Demuxing VobID (FIRST PASS) using DVD Decrypter 3.2.1.0
(03:06:34) Using DVD Decrypter to Demux VTS 01 PGC 01 ANGLE 01
(03:21:47) Finished Processing VTS 01 PGC 01 ANGLE 01
---
(03:21:47) Analyzing Video...
(03:21:47) Total Odd / Even = 1 / 0 = Odd/Top/A dominant and 0.00% progressive

(03:21:47) Flag found at position 110
(03:21:47) Diagnose Field Order = 1
(03:21:47) Analyzing Video... Header Flag= "Progressive/TFF" Analysis= "Interlaced/TFF"
(03:21:47) Inverting Field Order for Filename
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_001_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 001, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) M2V flagged as no-cce because it didn't meet the Encoding Threshold
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V001C001-no-cce.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:47) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_002_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 002, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) M2V flagged as no-cce because it didn't meet the Encoding Threshold
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V002C001-no-cce.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:47) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_003_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 003, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) M2V flagged as no-cce because it didn't meet the Encoding Threshold
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V003C001-no-cce.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:47) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_004_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 004, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) M2V flagged as no-cce because it didn't meet the Encoding Threshold
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V004C001-no-cce.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:47) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_005_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 005, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V005C001.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:47) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_006_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 006, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V006C001.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:47) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:47) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_006_CELLID_002_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:47) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 006, cel= 002 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:47) Rename to= VTS__01_V006C002.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:47) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:47) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:47) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_006_CELLID_003_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 006, cel= 003 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V006C003.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_006_CELLID_004_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 006, cel= 004 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V006C004.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_007_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 007, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V007C001.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_008_CELLID_001_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 008, cel= 001 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V008C001.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_008_CELLID_002_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 008, cel= 002 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V008C002.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_008_CELLID_003_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 008, cel= 003 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V008C003.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...



Many lines like these above deleted...



(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_012_CELLID_004_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:21:48) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 012, cel= 004 darloc= 16~9
(03:21:48) Rename to= VTS__01_V012C004.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:21:48) Substreams = 0 4
(03:21:48) VTS 1 PGC 1 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:21:48) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 1
(03:21:48) Vobsubbing PGC 1 Angle 1
(03:21:48) Demuxing VobID (FIRST PASS) using DVD Decrypter 3.2.1.0
(03:21:48) Using DVD Decrypter to Demux VTS 01 PGC 02 ANGLE 01

... 2. extracting and demux-try deleted...

(03:51:35) !No files demuxed from this pass...
(03:51:35) File to rename= VTS_01_VOBID_012_CELLID_004_1 - 0xE0 - Video.M2V
(03:51:35) vid= 0, pgc= , ang= 1, vob= 012, cel= 004 darloc= 16~9
(03:51:35) Rename to= VTS__01_V012C004.P.16~9_1.M2V
(03:51:35) Substreams = 0 4
(03:51:35) VTS 1 PGC 3 (0 mins) didn't meet Threshold (1 mins) requirement. Skipping subs...
(03:51:35) renerr= 183 vobid= 0 sub= 1 y= 3


This is the end of the log.

[Trahald]

it looks like you are demuxing by cellid? why are you doing that? you may want to use a newer version of dif4u for that, the newer ones handle subs much better. but really, since stargate is a regular multi pgc, pgc demux is just fine

i have done the stargate dvds with no problems. i did them by pgc and scenaid made a perfect script. compiled no problems and final dvd navigates and plays in dvd player 100%

[Chubmeister]

I have just started backing up my stargate sg1 series 7 using DOIF4U 1.4.7 (donate to receive!) and it does demux by vobid and encodes perfectly well, that is all but the subs! They start about 4 secs too early! on all the episodes. They remain 4 secs out for the duration of each episode, the chapter points are correct. I've done the fist two disks, both had the subtitle problem.

I have read about the 'dummy cell' possibility but haven't explored that yet - any likelihood this will be looked into?

see also this thread...

http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?threadid=72210

[StifflerStealth]

Originally posted by Chubmeister
I have just started backing up my stargate sg1 series 7 using DOIF4U 1.4.7 (donate to receive!) and it does demux by vobid and encodes perfectly well, that is all but the subs! They start about 4 secs too early! on all the episodes. They remain 4 secs out for the duration of each episode, the chapter points are correct. I've done the fist two disks, both had the subtitle problem.

I have read about the 'dummy cell' possibility but haven't explored that yet - any likelihood this will be looked into?

see also this thread...

http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?threadid=72210

Funny you should link to that post. Those disc were the Stargate SG-1 R1 discs. The solution to the subs being off is to manually load the subs. ScenAid and ReAuthorist screw it up for some reason. Now all my subs are in sync. Perhaps I should post that solution.


@DarkFear_DK: Which Stargate are you refeering to? The movie or series? I have successfully backed up the movie, both discs, using demux by PGC. They really have nothing special about them. You can also back up the Series by PGC as well, just manually load the subs, if you keep them.

Stiff

[D3s7]

Would you by chance using Scenarist 3?

[Chubmeister]

I use Scenarist 2.7

Ha, typical, I've just binned the last rip and have it demuxing by cellid as we speak.

Always used to reauthor manually until the likes of RA and Scenaid, never crossed my mind to import the subs manually, will try it and let you know.

[DarkFear_DK]

Originally posted by Trahald
it looks like you are demuxing by cellid? why are you doing that?

Based on http://www.doom9.org/mpg/vobidornot.htm (this page) . I may have misinterpreted the page, but from what I can understand, I need to demux using cell-ids? :-/

you may want to use a newer version of dif4u for that, the newer ones handle subs much better. but really, since stargate is a regular multi pgc, pgc demux is just fine

Okay I'll try that :)

Thanks for all your help.

[DarkFear_DK]

Originally posted by StifflerStealth

@DarkFear_DK: Which Stargate are you refeering to? The movie or series? I have successfully backed up the movie, both discs, using demux by PGC. They really have nothing special about them. You can also back up the Series by PGC as well, just manually load the subs, if you keep them.

Stiff

Haha, sorry for not mentioning it. I am talking about the Stargate Series (all of season 5 PAL R2).

I will just try to demux using VOBID's.

Can anyone tell me the most significant differences when demuxing using VOBID's or Cell-ID's?

(I am still new to this more advanced type of DVD backup) :)

Hope I don't annoy you guys too much :rolleyes:

[StifflerStealth]

Originally posted by Chubmeister
I use Scenarist 2.7

Ha, typical, I've just binned the last rip and have it demuxing by cellid as we speak.

Always used to reauthor manually until the likes of RA and Scenaid, never crossed my mind to import the subs manually, will try it and let you know.

Why are you demuxing by cellid?

Originally posted by DarkFear_DX
Based on http://www.doom9.org/mpg/vobidornot.htm . I may have misinterpreted the page, but from what I can understand, I need to demux using cell-ids? :-/

you may want to use a newer version of dif4u for that, the newer ones handle subs much better. but really, since stargate is a regular multi pgc, pgc demux is just fine
You only need to demux by PGC. I used DIF4U v1.4.0 for the movie and v1.4.0, v1.4.6, and v1.4.7 for episodes, ScenAid, and Scenarist 2.7. It worked fine. The Movie you do not need to manually import the subs.

Stiff

[StifflerStealth]

Originally posted by DarkFear_DK
Haha, sorry for not mentioning it. I am talking about the Stargate Series (all of season 5 PAL R2).

I will just try to demux using VOBID's.

Can anyone tell me the most significant differences when demuxing using VOBID's or Cell-ID's?

(I am still new to this more advanced type of DVD backup) :)

Hope I don't annoy you guys too much :rolleyes:

Do the PAL discs have something crazy going on that the NTSC disc don't? Maybe if you posted part of the VTS1 IFO file we might be able to help you more. I am assuming that all the episodes are in VTS1 just like the NTSC versions. On the NTSC version we have something like:

VTS 1
PGC 1 --> Episode 1
PGC 2 --> Episode 2
...
VTS 2 - Extras
VTS 3 - Promotional spots

Stiff

[Chubmeister]

Originally posted by StifflerStealth
Why are you demuxing by cellid?
As my subs were off, and from your other thread, I thought I might investigate the 'dummy cell' theory.

I also mentioned, incorrectly, that I used a vobid demux (apologies Darkfear_DK if that threw you). Trahald and Stiff are correct, it is just a regular pgc demux (with a few duplicates pgcs deselected, presumably for directors comments).

Didn't have time to finish project, so don't know if subs work yet, will post results tonight.

[Chubmeister]

Ahhh, the subs are still off by the same amount with manual import!

They start about 4secs too early and are out by the same amount throughout the episode, audio is in sync.

Any suggestions?

[StifflerStealth]

Can't you move the subtitles block over four seconds? The subtitle file might have the wrong time. I've always demuxed by PGC, and the subtitles work out fine after I manually import them. Yes, you loose the hidden cells in the back if there are any, but the disc works fine.

Stiff