Merge of RealAnime and Yatoshi Satsuki

[Sirber]

Hi

RealAnime and Yatoshi Satsuki GUI are merging into 1 unique GUI. The question is, which "skin" you would like to have "by default"?

1) RealAnime "tabbed UI"
http://www.webernic.com/sites/sirber/190_1.PNG

2) Yatoshi Satsuki "all-in-one window UI"
http://oldanimes.org/gui2.jpg

Note: This is not a feature comparison

About language, both UI will work in French and English

[Shinobu]

All is said ^^
Just chose and we will program

++

[h9903209]

more convenient is always better... laziness make me choose Yatoshi Satsuki ^_^

[Sirber]

Since you took time to vote, you're not that lazy so you could have voted RealAnime :p

[Shinobu]

so please vote ^^

++

[melvinvc]

I vote for Yatoshi. Thanks.

[Sirber]

Do you think the merge is evil or good?

[Soulhunter]

Originally posted by Sirber
Do you think the merge is evil or good?
"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing"

- Edmund Burke


Bye

[Sirber]

9vs4...

is there something wrong about my UI? :confused:

[Soulhunter]

I like Yatoshi's !!!

But RealAnime sounds better... :D


Anyhow I like the all-in-one idear... ;)

But tab-style is also nice !!!

Combination maybe ???


No, wait...

I also vote for Yatoshi Satsuki's !!!

Thats it... :p


Bye

[Sirber]

nah... I hate "all-in-one window" style, too much stuff, and Satsiky hates tabs. That's why we keep both :D. This vote is only to choose which "skin" will be loaded by default (both are avalible all the time and can be changed on the fly from a menu.

[b00zed]

What about a "which style would you prefer" question during the install process?

[Soulhunter]

Originally posted by Sirber
nah... I hate "all-in-one window" style, too much stuff, and Satsiky hates tabs. That's why we keep both :D. This vote is only to choose which "skin" will be loaded by default (both are avalible all the time and can be changed on the fly from a menu.
Then my vote goes to b00zed's idea !!!

Bye

[Sirber]

hum...

dunno if NSIS supports this. I could use the registry for that...

[plazz2000]

IMHO, YS just looks too complicated!

The window looks a bit cramped, sirber's tabbed interface is way better, I think.

All the great utils (GordianKnot, etc...) use tabbed interface, so I think RealAnime2 should too. :sly:

Just my two cents.

[Lagoon]

I really like the tabbed interface too :D

[Sirber]

cool! :cool:

just need 5 more votes :D

[h9903209]

Originally posted by b00zed
What about a "which style would you prefer" question during the install process?

best option!!!^O^

[Hiro2k]

One more vote your way Sirber!
I agree with you, tabs are better... hence Mozilla > IE

But boozed had the greatest idea yet. Choose it when you install. Would you like that as an option on the poll?

[karl_lillevold]

I like both, and as long as there is an easy way to switch between tabbed or non-tabbed, in the installer or otherwise, I will be happy. On a side-note, I love tabs in Mozilla and Opera, but in an encoding GUI, it is kind of nice to see all the settings at once.

EDIT: I should add that my most used GUI is called "Command Prompt". It has a nice 'arrow up' feature to recall the last command. I do however like to have both my Avisynth scripts and audience files auto-generated, keep an old copy of these around, and then edit a version, and run:

producer -i in.avs -lc e,d -ad testNEWfeature.rpad

However, it is not always easy... Sometimes I want anamorphic, sometimes a specific filesize, other times a bitrate, sometimes multi-channel audio, other times trans-coded to surround, sometimes no audio and later mux with source audio. GUIs are a great help!

[Latexxx]

They both suck. :D
Invent something new.

Edit: Voted for RealAnime.
Edit2: This was my 300th post!

[Sirber]

Like in Flash? :p

[b00zed]

I guess I should *probably* check out these two tools to see what the fuss is about... :D

[hoola]

I like having categories. So for me tabbed is better. I vote for realanime.

[Sirber]

Need 3 more votes!!! :D

RealAnime 2.00 (my part) is almost completed. Once it works #1, I will merge Satsuki part. Satsuki GUI will be a "skin" which will manipulate RealAnime "hidden" GUI, since all the existing code uses RealAnime GUI. RealAnime GUI will also update Satsuki GUI if Satsuki GUI is hidden. This can cause infinite loop if we are not carefull :D. The main goal of this fusion is to concentrate our efforts to make the "ultimate anime encoding tool" into one GUI. Also, note that RealAnime will get *all* Satsuki GUI functions, and vice versa (if possible).

Stay tuned for more boring news! :angry:

[edit]

oh!!! 12 vs 14! 2 more votes!!!!! :D

[mf]

Tabs are good. Though I might not like RV9 or RealAnime, tabs are good. :D XviD devs should learn from tabs. :p

[damrod]

i prefer (few) tabs

all in one is good but sometimes i'm lost in the ihm...so tabs!!

;-) sirber

[SeeMoreDigital]

It might help a bit if you uploaded some images of each applications GUI's...

Just a thought!

Cheers

[Sirber]

:search:

There are screens in RealAnime and Satsiky thread ;)

[SeeMoreDigital]

I actually like both!

Why don't you have a 'startup' welcome screen that can direct you to each GUI.

That said, Sirbers layout offers greater flexibility for future upgrades!

Hey Sirber. Now that RealMedia can create AAC audio streams. Can you add an MP4 output tab to your GUI ;)


He, He

[Sirber]

Matroska support is through a producer plugin, not an external binary. If someone write a MP4 output plugin I don't mind :)

[Sirber]

18vs18 :D

[RedDwarf69]

I never used neither of them :p But yes, Yatoshi Satsuki seems too complicated....although a no so dark background would give it a easier look ;)

[Kaiousama]

mine is the 20th vote for RealAnime, tabbed interface is cleaner than the all-in-one solution (even though it needs an additive ocx control in vb).

@Shinobu : do you are involved also in SurrealUI developement? i'm searching a voulenterous programmer for an anime-related project, please pm me if you're interested.

@siber: which ocx controls are actually needed by RealAnime?

[Sirber]

IIRC, I use DirectX7, CommonDialog and MS Controls #1 SP4. They are all included with RealAnime, so no need to seek them elsewhere.

about Surreal UI, Shinobu is already in the team, but as always, time is missing :( What is your project about?

[Kaiousama]

Originally posted by Sirber
IIRC, I use DirectX7, CommonDialog and MS Controls #1 SP4. They are all included with RealAnime, so no need to seek them elsewhere.

Maybe you can make your installer lighter using commondialogs api calling instead of the ocx control, i've done the same for my application and it works very well.
You can find some ready to use classes over the net, otherwise i can send them directly to your email, please let me know.

OT :

Originally posted by Sirber
about Surreal UI, Shinobu is already in the team, but as always, time is missing :( What is your project about?

It is a subtitling application expecially designed for anime, i've seen you and shinobu are good otakus so maybe you are interested to develope a project like this, in addiction the actual application is coded in vb so you have already experiences to spend.

[Shinobu]

I'm a total otaku for more thant 15 years, all i do is for manga or anime ^^ but sorry for your project i'll not have time before a lonnnng time

++

[Kaiousama]

no worries for my project, it'll grown in some way; keep up with the marvellous work you're doing for producer GUIs no matter which will be the winning interface they're both good because aimed to different user types ;)

[Sirber]

Bah... this vote is only to know which interface to use by default, both will be avalible at any time, even while encoding. COuld you give us (me) more infos about the project? "subtitling app" is kinda too short :D

[b00zed]

I just had another thought:

How about just having the GUI it runs with controlled by a command line argument? The installer could for example (if possible) place two shortcuts, each with their respective argument, in the start menu folder, and the user just runs the one they want from there. This way you wouldn't have to commit to a choice during the installation process, and you wouldn't have to go fiddling with settings inside the program itself if you wanted to change the GUI, just run the other shortcut...

[Sirber]

There will be no choice in installation, I'm too lazy. About shortcut, it will be bad since I want the user to be able to change UI while running it. TO change it will super easy, I added a menu "Mode" so changing is 1 click (or 2).

How RealAnime works now:

RealAnime --> avisynth/producer wrapper --> producer

How "merged app" will work:

Satsuki --> RealAnime --> avisynth/producer wrapper --> producer
<--

[Shinobu]

T_T i need 6 votes to egal realanime (that'll not be a big mess cause the 2 gui'll exist.... )

++

[Soulhunter]

Originally posted by Sirber
There will be no choice in installation, I'm too lazy. Hey, read my quote from Page-No.1 again... :D :D :D

Bye

[Sirber]

Originally posted by Soulhunter
"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing"

- Edmund Burke


Bye So having an option in installation is Evil? :D

[damrod]

for creating mp4 there's a thread bout that


you create your ra10 then with mkvtools you mux in mkv then demux in...aac or redirect to mp4 wrapper

i have the cmdline somewhere...

i think i will add it as a possibility in my matroska panel :-))

[Sirber]

go ahead :)

I'm focusing on my new "Job manager" :D

[damrod]

job manager??

to save a job list or to save, for each file, a jobfile?? (like in rmfactory?)

btw i update and re-upload the files of realbatch on my website

some mods/debug :-)

[Sirber]

all info about it in in the RealAnime thread.

[h9903209]

@damrod
I want to try your realbatch, but never succeed...
miss VB6FR.DLL first, after d/l it and figure out need to put in system32, then popup a box about tabctl32.ocx, not in English, don't understand... maybe it's better to make a install which includes all needed file?

[Sirber]

That's why I included all the DLLs :D