Should I rename the program?

[dvd2svcd]

I've been considering renaming dvd2svcd to something else. The next release will also support dvd output and I feel that the dvd2svcd name just isn't cutting it anymore. I have a few names in my mind but I'm unsure how the public would react to a name change.

[DDogg]

That is really a hard question and choice. DVD2SVCD has established strong brand awareness/branding. I wonder if a variant of the name like DVD2SVCDPlus or DVD2SVCDEX(tra) might serve the purpose. At least something along those lines to establish the expanded functions, but still retain the branding. In effect it is really DVD2Anything, but that name does not quite have a ring to it.

[stax76]

I think you should rename it to catchy name (like Kopycat or Ucopia), don't use something like x2x

[homerjay]

ive voted dont change the name on the same basis as ddog but if you were going to change it dont use any of those options listed maybe just dvd2 as in dvd squared or fromdvd

[Holomatrix]

I kinda like Ucopia but you probably should keep to some inline variant due to the masses knowing it as DVD2SVCD

[spuddog]

I agree with DDogg And homerjay not to change, but it is your program, we just enjoy the results

[WorldBook]

I voted for Ucopia. Though I think just "D2S" would also be cool.

[r6d2]

I second DDogg's reasons but also like the DVD2 name (with 2 as a superscript, like Alien 3 ;)). It encloses the idea of power, of versatility (it is not constrained to an output format), and also recalls bidimensionality.

My next point is completely off topic but I will bring it here. Make it shareware! Earn some well deserved money! :p

Even though you use plenty of third parties tools and code, the value of your tool is not the easy downloading of all extras. (They might even be packaged separately if that is a concern.)

The value of your tool is the automation of a really difficult, cumbersome and error-prone task. And you've done it quite well.

Donateware also works, and gives the users to pay according to their abilities. But since it is not mandatory, most will just not pay for something they can get for free.

At least a small donation should be needed to keep the software running after you've become acquainted of it usefulness.

That's my 2 cents (much less than deserved ;))

[ammck55]

I'm with Ddogg, DVD2SVCD has a huge following and is highly recognizable, and I also really like r6d2's idea of a superscript. Maybe a combination of the two. Have fun!

[baker]

i have reffered a lot of people in the past to use dvd2svcd for making vcds and they all reply back"but I wanna make vcds!!"

I am afriad although we all and know love "dvd2svcd" a name change is needed!

Baker

[Byteshark]

Maybe Even DVDResample ? or ReDODVD :confused:

[DDogg]

As a aside comment, Ucopia reminds me of UCopulatory which might get a lot of attention, but not reflect the products functions very well :)

If the name had to be changed to more properly reflect the use then Dvd² might be ok. I seem to remember a discussion about that name a couple of years ago. However, note the superscript looks kinda sucky unless it is bigger - Dvd². Sorta along the line Byteshark mentioned, I also thought DVDRecoder might work but then a lot of brand awareness gets tossed out the window and I would not be surprised if somebody was already using that name.

[KpeX]

Originally posted by DDogg
As a aside comment, Ucopia reminds me of UCopulatory which might get a lot of attention, but not reflect the products functions very well :)


Hehe. DVD2SVCD is a talented coder, maybe we should make this a feature request ;)

Back on topic, DVD2 with a superscript 2 would be an effective and simple name, that'd be my choice.

[telemike]

D2S Transcoder
D2SXformer

btw-

I finally sent DVD2SVCD some development cash. I do belive in supporting my favorite software buds.

[DDogg]

I finally sent DVD2SVCD some development cash. I do belive in supporting my favorite software buds. Way to go, telemike!!

[dvd2svcd]

I am seriously considering DVD2GO unless anybody can think of a reason not to. Speak now or forever hold your peace.

[homerjay]

were a fair few search engine results for that including
http://www.halfbakery.com/idea/DVD2go
although noone has a direct www..... for it

[dvd2svcd]

dvd2go = 49 pages on google, so the name has huge potential.

Besides, I haven't decided 100% yet. It's not a decision I want to rush into.

[telemike]

DVD2GO

I like that! :D

[MrX]

I think:
1.) don't change (DVD2SVCD)
2.) DVD2GO

[jorel]

@ dvd2svcd

i did my vote but i'm curious:
if you change the name of this (great) program to another one,
your username will change too?

ps:
thanks for the new version!
:)

[sehh]

I voted NOT to change the name.

I agree that it may not reflect the current (new) features, but the current name has (to me) the following advantanges:

1) Established name (like saying, "since 1900's")

2) Known to many people as dvd2svcd already.

3) A new name does not mean success. It may confuse people.

4) dvd2svcd holds a kind of 'respect', older and newer users
are familiar with it. A new name looses all that.

5) even though dvd2svcd does not reflect the new features, it
does show that the application has been around for a LONG time,
which COUNTS a lot these days.

Just my humble opinion :p

[Holomatrix]

Originally posted by telemike

I finally sent DVD2SVCD some development cash. I do belive in supporting my favorite software buds.

Hey I did to :) thanks to Paypal. Way easy :)

Did you just add DVD2GO? I didn't notice that before.

[ammck55]

"Sir, would you like that here, or to go?"

"Hmmm, I think I'll take my....DVD2GO!"

It's got a nice, catchy ring to it. Once again, you've outdone everyone else! :D

[r6d2]

Originally posted by ammck55
It's got a nice, catchy ring to it. Once again, you've outdone everyone else! :D
Couldn't agree more. :cool:

[Barker]

I was liking the DVD2SVCD+, however the DVD2GO is unique, and a great presentation of what the program does, so my vote goes to that!

Regards,
Barker

[baker]

dvd2go is a great name.

Baker

[The eDealer]

DVD2SVCD is good established for the use for SVCDs.
If the name is changed, DVD2go is the best alternative.
Then the name speaks for itself.

[markrb]

DDOGG is right in that the name has a huge known following, but it isn't really accurate anymore. Now that VCD and DVD's can be made it goes way beyond the SVCD.

If you do change the name then may I suggest for awhile adding in formerly or developed from DVD2SVCD put in the Docs or in the description for a while until it develops a brand name of it's own.

I like DVD2GO and maybe DVD2+. Basically dropping the SVCD and adding either the GO or a + after.

In either case way to go on not only this release, but all the work you have done over the years.

Mark

[mrbass]

dvdbutler, dvdvalet, or adivad?

ok dvd2go sounds good..looks like that's gonna be it. BTW, just promise you won't type d2g ..I'm mean come on only six letters dvd2go.

[dvd2svcd]

I also have a catch phrase:

"Yet another DVD2go"


Cheers,
d2g :D

[TerraForce1]

Hi,

If your main reason is to adjust the name so it properly outlines the programs functions than I would say stick to DVD2SVCD. Because for example if I want to encode an AVI to VCD, the current name of the program already doesn't represents this functionality. My advise to you is to change the name in the main program window like you do now. For example when I want to make a VCD out of an AVI file I get the string "AVI2VCD" in the top of my main DVD2SVCD program window.

So if your main reason is to change the name so it properly outlines the programs functions than I would say why? because the current name really doesnt properly outlines the programs functionalities.

TerraForce1

[sandchar99]

Not to confuse matters but..........

Go with a dual name/dual brand!

1) "DVD2SVCD" when performing that function

2) "DVD2DVD" (or whatever) replacing "DVD2SVCD" on the Program Title Bar when someone changes the output function on the Misc. Tab.

3) Desktop and Quick launch icons would be labelled "DVD2SVCD" or "DVD2DVD" depending on what the installer set the program up to do primarily at the time of install.

Thus your program name would be whatever people were using it for. It would be developing a new name brand awareness while at the same time retaining the old. Hence DVD2SVCD/DVD2DVD...

As long as oldtimers (like me) are still making SVCDs, I would still be calling it DVD2SVCD.

Thanks again.

[Luper_PT]

I started to read the forum before I saw the options, and I realised x2x... after that I vote 4 x2x :) 4 sure.

Another thing... time 2 donate @DVD2SVCD, I will do it now. DVD2SVCD must continue doing the great work he is doing. Only hopping external subs 4 sun.

Bad English... sorry :)

[ralphthedog]

Seems a shame to give up a well known and respected brandname like DVD2SVCD.

Maybe DVD2SVCD should just get a + on the end to signal the formal adding of another output format?

X2X makes me think of a lame movie sequel starring Vin Diesel!

[jbr]

Multinational companies spend millions on "Brand Awareness" , Macdonalds,Rolls Royce,Microsoft,etc.If you have a good reputation for good software (DVD2SVCD has this )then you need to exploit its hard won good name with perhaps just the addition of a "Plus" or "Gold Edition"
Only products which have failed in the market tend to be re-launched with a "new" name.DVD2SVCD does not deserve this indignity.

Regards

Jbr

[tylo]

My suggestion: dvd2silver

- Keeps the first five letters (otherwise I must rename my plugin too) :sly:
- Most CDRs and DVDRs are "silver" coated.
- We can still use the short name "D2S" which is well established.

btw: Please don't consider making D2S shareware.
I don't want to make free plugins for a shareware product. :(
-------------------------
D2S plugins: http://home.no.net/tylo/

[dvd2svcd]

Originally posted by tylo
btw: Please don't consider making D2S shareware.
I don't want to make free plugins for a shareware product. :(
-------------------------
D2S plugins: http://home.no.net/tylo/ Don't worry, that was never my intention.

[mrbass]

I like DVD2DVD. Well true most still make SVCDs with DVD2SVCD but in 1 year or 2 years from now I don't believe that'll be the primary case. I think it'll mostly be DVD2DVD with a little AVI2DVD or PVA2DVD. So if DVD2SVCD has had the name for 3 years and even though it did other things it described it's MAIN functionality. So what's wrong with renaming it DVD2SVCD --> DVD2DVD describing it's future functionality for years to come.

P.S. they don't call me Nostradamus for nothing.

[The eDealer]

Hi mrbass,

whats about that:

DVD2DVD\
AVI2DVD- go2DVD :D
PVA2DVD/

[winxi]

What about DaViD2GO(liath)?

[telemike]

DVD2GO has a catchy ring to it.

DVD2SVCD is a littly lengthy but established.

DVD2GO!!!!!!!!!!!