Ripped PCM-Sound sounds defective

[dominik]

I've got two DVDs with PCM-Sound (Eric Clapton - 24 nights, Simply Red - live in London). When I rip and demux the sound with DVDDecrypter or I copy a VOB file from the DVD to my HardDisk demux it with Vobrator the PCM-Sound sounds like THIS (http://magic.dominik.li/blablabla/problem.mp3). What am I doing wrong?

[dominik]

Here another example (http://magic.dominik.li/blablabla/problem2.mp3) of the bad sound i get.

[dani82]

you should have search the forum for old threads about pcm files; oh well.

http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=52342

[dominik]

Did you listen to the two mp3s?? I think you don't, because else you would know that pcm-files aren't such a strange thing for me than for the guys discussing @ your link, who have difficulties to differ between DTS and PCM. I'm sorry, but your admonition to search the forum before posting anything together with your useless link insults me.:mad:

[dominik]

I've just found a solution for the problem: If I open the VOBs with DVD2AVI and save the project, the PCM-sound gets saved in a wav-file which sounds perfect.

[dani82]

if you ret that post correctly (which you probably didn't), you would have notice that they gave tips on how to extract the audio via dvd2avi, the samething you did (i guess), and how to load a pcm into a sound-editting program.

don't bother replying, you solved your problem.

[dominik]

With DVD2AVI it sounds like it should sound. But If you load the PCM-File produced by VOBrator in CoolEdit exactly in the way like the people descriped it at your link, which probably should be the right way and is the way i've gone before my posting here, it sounds like the two mp3s. In exactly the same way it sound when you demux it directly from the DVD with DVDDecrypter. The people @"lpcm question please clear me up...??" don't say anything about a problem with the Sound which you can solve with DVD2AVI. Somebody says just, that he think, the guy who is talking about PCM truely means DTS :rolleyes: which you can demux with DVD2AVI.