Log in

View Full Version : dvd2one vs InstantCopy vs dvd95copy Quality


Pages : 1 [2]

MackemX
6th April 2003, 22:35
you still don't get it do you :confused:

people have different setups and different values of quality and this will affect their opinions greatly and that's why you get differences of opinion when it comes to quality comparisions

I used W,X,Y,Z as a joke against what mpucoder had asked :D, cos if you do have a good eye for quality and the means to view it, you will seen the difference and you would have known what W,X,Y,Z were supposed to be and a few people did. The problems begin when people may not have seen the same order if I had named names and they would have been in disagreement and that's how the flame wars start :)

People have been asked to hold back their opinions because some people get offended when their judgement is disputed. The guy who is disputing it is probably seeing a different picture because of his means of viewing and eye for quality so that's why I always quote my sig when someone asks about quality comparisons

basically if someone can't see the difference from these two examples and make up their own mind then any program will do for them so what's the harm in that by letting people make up their own minds?

you noticed a difference so why shouldn't the next guy?, but that doesn't mean he will put them in the same order as you but he will choose what's he thinks is the best quality as long as the comparision is fair which I believe these two were

mpucoder
6th April 2003, 22:55
Originally posted by Richk50
People come here to learn and get opinions from others who have the same interests.
Not according to our leader, whose opinion I value greatly. People come here for facts without the clutter and chatter found in other forums. We have several rules to enhance this, including "do not ask what is best". I endorse that rule, although I did not create it, and I am entrusted to uphold it.
We have moderators to weed out those who have nothing constructive to say.
That would be me, among others.

We kept this thread open to further a fair comparison of the products, and with the warning to all to avoid arguments. I think the thread has served its purpose, and is now headed the wrong way. If any new releases or products come out a new series of screenshots would be in order. This thread, though, is now closed.