how does the quality compare? [Archive]

View Full Version : how does the quality compare?

c.pugwash

24th February 2003, 21:30

I normaly encoded using cce 2.5,and the quality is excellent (3pass).
But what is the quality like with dvd2one and instantcopy, is it as good or better? will it keep the 6 channel sound? which one is the best?

jdobbs

24th February 2003, 21:34

The sound remains untouched. The quality doesn't touch CCE, but is is better than most encoders.

c.pugwash

24th February 2003, 22:07

thanks for the reply, what sort of quality are we talking about, rempeg quality or worse.

mrbass

24th February 2003, 22:14

Do your own test...take you less than 2 or 3 hours. I'm still doing 4 pass CCE for SVCDs till I get a dvd burner.

c.pugwash

24th February 2003, 22:18

I can't do a test yet, I don't have the programs.

Joeman

24th February 2003, 22:29

you might want to take a look here......

http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=46630

mrbass

24th February 2003, 22:52

15 day fully functional demo..only 15MB download

c.pugwash

25th February 2003, 16:28

thanks but I have managed to get the full version.

hakko504

25th February 2003, 16:57

Originally posted by c.pugwash
thanks but I have managed to get the full version. You mean bought I hope. Piracy is not welcome here.

c.pugwash

25th February 2003, 17:04

Of course, I buy everything.com

jdobbs

27th February 2003, 01:39

thanks for the reply, what sort of quality are we talking about, rempeg quality or worse.

Just for those who read the thread and were wondering... The quality is much, much better than ReMPEG2 at a given bitrate (from either IC or DVD2one).

xmenxmen

27th February 2003, 22:31

Which is better.

CCE, then IC then DVD2One, the REMPEG.

Speed wise

DVD2One (15-30 min) CCE, (1 pass here, about realtime), IC (realtime or sometimes close to it) then REMPEG (anyone still awake)

Ease of Use.

IC, DVD2One, REMPEG, CCE

Overall
IC or DVD2One (will not even start)