IFOEDIT and The Sopranos

[wanderance]

I know this has been discussed before, but it seems there isn't a definitive answer on this.

I am attempting to split The Sopranos DVD's, keeping all the menus, extra features, etc.

There are 2 problems I have run into (this is on Season 3 specifically). If I attempt to split using the "Split to 2 dvd-r's" check box, everything ends up in the "disc 1" directory, and it is far too large. If I attempt to do it manually, by stripping vob's, the first disc is fine. As soon as I attempt to strip the vob's for the second disc (i.e. leave out vob id 1) IFOEdit reports an error. "VOB cotains no NAV UNITS" The only way I can correct this error is to select VOB ID1, but then it won't fit on 1 disc.

I have attempted to follow guides posted on this forum and on doom9. Is there something I am missing, or can it even be done?

[wanderance]

Just as an update I did some more experimenting and got it to work, somewhat.

It plays fine in the IFOEDIT player and PowerDVD. But Primo won't burn it, and if I force it to burn, my stand alone plays the intro, but craps out before getting to the menu.

Any ideas?

[Dre]

The error message about "VOB cotains no NAV UNITS" is a bug in version 0.94 of IfoEdit. It's supposed to be fixed in the next version. For now, you'll need to use an older version of IfoEdit.

[wanderance]

The error message about "VOB cotains no NAV UNITS" is a bug in version 0.94 of IfoEdit. It's supposed to be fixed in the next version.

Thanks, that solves my first problem...but...onto my second problem.

I am figuring there must be somethign I am overlooking, as the IFO player *seems* to play it (it crashes a lot). I know it isn't just my stand alone, as PrimoDVD will ensure the DVD is up to snuff before it burns it, and it gives me an error.

I wonder if I should try an older version first?