OGG file too small? Nandub crashes when trying to mux

[mustaneekeri]

I decied to try ogg sound in my rip and i folloved the OggMachine guide and there were no problems exept the resulting .OGG file is only ~23Megs. I used ~126Kbps br and the movie is 2:06 long so it should be bigger? Also when i try to mux it in the .AVI, Nandub crashes.
Any suggestions?

[MaTTeR]

Originally posted by mustaneekeri
~23Megs. I used ~126Kbps br and the movie is 2:06 long so it should be bigger? Also when i try to mux it in the .AVI, Nandub crashes.
Any suggestions?

CBR, ABR or VBR? You left a letter out:)

Why are you using NanDunb to try and mux Vorbis? GraphEdit needs to be used via the guides.

[mustaneekeri]

Thers no VBR/ABR/CBR option in OggMachine 0.16, ill guess its VBR.
Why can't i use NanDub, thers a Ogg/Vorbis audio option in audio menu just for that purpose? And its much easier than GraphEdit? Still, whers the Ogg-Graphedit guide i will take a look at it?

[elgan123]

Hi,

If I had to guess, I would say your ogg file has been corrupted somehow. A 2 hour ogg at 126 kbps should come out over 100MB. 23MB is way too small. Can you play the ogg file (ie in winamp)?

elgan123

[dblmask]

the ogg option in nadub is ALPHA!!! never get a decent development (acording to doom9), you have to multiplex the files with GraphEdit ... follow the guides

[DSPguru]

why won't you post your logfile of the ogg encoding process ?

[mustaneekeri]

Ya, the ogg file was somehow corrupted and i could not play it with winamp. I tryed to make it directly out of .WAV that azid made.
I now encoded it with OggMachine directly out of AC3 and ended up with working .ogg (100Mb+) file that i can play with winamp.

I now have a different problem however.
I muxed the .ogg stream and DivX 5 pro stream to .ogm file with GraphEdit and the audio is out of sync. Now i read from some other thread, that this is a know problem with .ogg and DivX 5. Any working solutions to this yet?

[MaTTeR]

Did you have the delay set in OggMachine?

Why would Divx 5 and Ogg not work together? I don't use Divx so I can't confirm that issue. You might also change the extension from OGG, OGM or whatever it is to AVI.

[mustaneekeri]

Yes the delay was set in OggMachine, and allready tried to rename the extension to .avi, tried WiMP and BSPlayer (Only plays when file is .ogm)
Here is the link to that ogg sync thread with DivX 5: http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=19420

Im now re-encoding the movie with all the new DivX 5 features turned off, to see if that makes any difference.
btw. thanks for ur help so far...