Gifski vs. Shutter Encoder

[jay123210599]

Which one of these two make higher quality gifs, Gifski or Shutter Encoder?

Test files 2

ge.gif (made by Shutter Encoder): https://www.mediafire.com/view/2gz2bjvt6jria08/ge.gif/file
file.gif (made by Gifski): https://www.mediafire.com/view/r3sqsvn0332d62f/file.gif/file

Test Files 2

mtput.gif (made by Shutter Encoder): https://www.mediafire.com/view/6mf95b61zlgjzmv/mtput.gif/file
anim.gif (made by Gifski): https://www.mediafire.com/view/jaymvl604rtsqbe/anim.gif/file

[Z2697]

Ah yes, tits

[jay123210599]

Ah yes, tits

What do you think?

Test files 3

tw.gif (made by Shutter Encoder): https://www.mediafire.com/view/jsctmwcti4kp8pl/tw.gif/file
test.gif (made by Gifski): https://www.mediafire.com/view/r9gcm6mf8n947m1/test.gif/file

[Z2697]

They are your "image", ask yourself

I have to put quotes on the word "image" because... ew

[jay123210599]

They are your "image", ask yourself

I have to put quotes on the word "image" because... ew

Can you help me with this, at least?

https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=186337

[GeoffreyA]

Which one of these two make higher quality gifs, Gifski or Shutter Encoder?

Test files 2

ge.gif (made by Shutter Encoder): https://www.mediafire.com/view/2gz2bjvt6jria08/ge.gif/file
file.gif (made by Gifski): https://www.mediafire.com/view/r3sqsvn0332d62f/file.gif/file

Test Files 2

mtput.gif (made by Shutter Encoder): https://www.mediafire.com/view/6mf95b61zlgjzmv/mtput.gif/file
anim.gif (made by Gifski): https://www.mediafire.com/view/jaymvl604rtsqbe/anim.gif/file

file > ge (File is smoother and lacks dithering graininess.)
mtput > anim (Colours seem more accurate. Anim has a greenish tint, along with quantisation noise in the door and buxom lady's bits.)
test > tw (Only marginally better than tw. Less dithering grain.)


Can you help me with this, at least?

https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=186337

I tried your command in mkvpropedit and it worked. See if your file has another track as 1, perhaps audio.

[jay123210599]

file > ge (File is smoother and lacks dithering graininess.)
mtput > anim (Colours seem more accurate. Anim has a greenish tint, along with quantisation noise in the door and buxom lady's bits.)
test > tw (Only marginally better than tw. Less dithering grain.)



I tried your command in mkvpropedit and it worked. See if your file has another track as 1, perhaps audio.

All right, I remade anim.gif but this time I set the quality to 100. Compare it to mtput to see if it's still beter than anim.

https://www.mediafire.com/view/xo4ao71gw0ebbf4/animV2.gif/file

[Z2697]

at least the file is a lot smaller

[jay123210599]

at least the file is a lot smaller

But the result?

[GeoffreyA]

All right, I remade anim.gif but this time I set the quality to 100. Compare it to mtput to see if it's still beter than anim.

https://www.mediafire.com/view/xo4ao71gw0ebbf4/animV2.gif/file

Hard to say, but I think animv2 is slightly better than mtput. On the curves, there seems to be less banding; around lines, less quantisation noise. My screen is dusty, though.

In the future, please warn people when the content contains mild nudity. Some may not wish to view such material but may unwittingly do so. And if one opens it at work, it can be a problem. It can even cause problems in a marriage or relationship. On a philosophical note, there shouldn't be a double standard between the male and female chest, but society, in most cultures, has decided that one is nudity and the other isn't, and words won't change that.

[jay123210599]

Hard to say, but I think animv2 is slightly better than mtput. On the curves, there seems to be less banding; around lines, less quantisation noise. My screen is dusty, though.

In the future, please warn people when the content contains mild nudity. Some may not wish to view such material but may unwittingly do so. And if one opens it at work, it can be a problem. It can even cause problems in a marriage or relationship. On a philosophical note, there shouldn't be a double standard between the male and female chest, but society, in most cultures, has decided that one is nudity and the other isn't, and words won't change that.

All right, I'm sorry. I also made from SFW (Safe For Work) gifs to test and see if which ones have the better quality.

Test files from Shutter Encoder:

test1.gif: https://www.mediafire.com/view/ezubvhmw79dhl8b/test1.gif/file
test2.gif: https://www.mediafire.com/view/q02tuwbauf66m07/test2.gif/file
test3.gif: https://www.mediafire.com/view/x1ct2l0xfj0zgfv/test3.gif/file

Test files from Gifski:

1,gif: https://www.mediafire.com/view/52k3g9bgek5qr0m/1.gif/file
2.gif: https://www.mediafire.com/view/23nffv9tzpry2gl/2.gif/file
3.gif: https://www.mediafire.com/view/cjz8isuwe2qgxrk/3.gif/file