View Full Version : Why there is no 60FPS DECODER?
DanilaZabiaka
15th March 2020, 16:25
Hey. As we know, modern video files are not just a pictures, they contains vector information
Using mvtools/svp/uplavnyalka which work with pictures we can get 60 whatever fps
But what about 60fps codecs? What changes if codec process video in 60fps? It should be possible...
DanilaZabiaka
15th March 2020, 16:29
There is big problem with syncranization rate, films has 23.976fps or 24 whatever, display has 60fps, it's not possible to divide 60/24 without dots
As I know MadVR or reclock does something with it, but what? Makes video faster or wtf is this? Movies on PC looks laggy
Corporatoins dont allow set custom rate for displays and players cant change out of box refresh rate like 48hz
When I tried on my tv 'true cinema' ( i dont have this now) when there is 24hz out of box, it was laggy too
wtf is this
Tadanobu
16th March 2020, 14:37
Codec and framerate are two different things. You can use a specific codec with anyframe rate. Either divx at 240 fps or av1 at 5 fps, you decide.
There reason why 60 fps is not widely used for movies is because of aesthetic, not technical matter. 60 fps movie looks very unnatural for real life content, but it's smoother in video games.
Stereodude
16th March 2020, 15:15
Go watch the UHD/"4k" blu-ray of Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk and get back to us.
QBhd
16th March 2020, 22:59
Or Gemini Man
QB
DanilaZabiaka
18th March 2020, 13:06
Modern video is not container with static images/audio
Its vectors. Even if this is 5 fps you can interpolate it using math to 25 150 whatever fps on decoder side
huhn
18th March 2020, 13:25
videos are static image the existence of motion vectors doesn't mean the image is vector far from it.
and why stuff like motion interpolation isn't default or done at decoding... not everyone is born blind.
Stereodude
18th March 2020, 14:16
Modern video is not container with static images/audio
Its vectors. Even if this is 5 fps you can interpolate it using math to 25 150 whatever fps on decoder side
Then write a codec that allows for that. :cool:
Scope
18th March 2020, 15:26
Motion Based Video Frame Interpolation
https://youtu.be/XykElxfgsrk
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 11:16
>Motion Based Video Frame Interpolation
-_- yeah, motion interpolation of already decoded video exists. But it need to analyze and search vectors again
Its more glitchy and needs more resources. Interpolation of source code of h264 video for example should give better results that do not so many operations and gives best result
Video inside looks like 'this hand in 1st state, it moves to 2nd state'
Video interpolation analyze video before. It get raw image, then catch hand. Oh man, this is hand, there is 1st state, there is 2nd state of one object, I insert something inside 2 frame
Decoder interpolation could works with source. It do not need to analyze vectors, it works with them
videoh
19th March 2020, 12:24
An encoder may or may not use motion estimation to code a given block, therefore the set of vectors is likely not a complete set and is thus not usable for your idea.
nevcairiel
19th March 2020, 13:46
And even if it has vectors, they may not reflect natural movement. Video codecs use motion vectors that result in the best compression result, not necessarily those that reflect natural movement of the objects in the scene.
People have tried using motion vectors from the video for interpolation, and its never been that great.
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 14:11
>People have tried using motion vectors from the video for interpolation, and its never been that great.
Hmm
I made Uplavnyalka for motion interpolation https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=180655 it using svp/mvtools2
Why is this not possible to use mvools2 algorithm of drawing frames in video, but using data from video? It should be possible, imho
SVP analyze motion, but why do you need analyze of vectors if technically you can use vectors on decoder side. Technically its more easy and should give less miskates artefacts
nevcairiel
19th March 2020, 14:48
Technically its more easy and should give less miskates artefacts
If you ignore any single argument given just above, sure!
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 15:07
>People have tried using motion vectors from the video for interpolation, and its never been that great.
Example?
Anyway, its something very wrong with video. Bad levels - you cant change levels from video player and get very dark/bright image, no 'noise' - compressing video without restoration makes video unnatural. TIME BAD, you must always see it. No sync with display out of box, regular driver does not support it
These 'technologies' are awful and people dont care about it, coders wtf are they do.
I fix something which I can in my PotPlayer build https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=180652 , ported SVP but nobody cares about it, ffmpeg kodi whatever party just think about how to code better, not result. With this phylosofy I'm not suprised that they cant code well
Groucho2004
19th March 2020, 16:08
I fix something which I can in my PotPlayer build https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=180652 , ported SVP but nobody cares about it, ffmpeg kodi whatever party just think about how to code better, not result. With this phylosofy I'm not suprised that they cant code well
It's rare to come across an utterly deluded person such as yourself. I have looked at your potplayer build and the disaster starts with the installer. It's partly Russian, partly English and your ridiculous vaping face not just stares at me during install but it's also on the desktop icon. WTF??
Once installed, whatever this is supposed to be, it's atrocious and unusable - at least for me - since it's all Russian.
I think you're just a kid in desperate need of approval and you should stop insulting the developers on this forum.
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 16:48
-_- I created 'normal' build before, but it s not garantee of popularity, so I can just have a fun, no? Firstly I create it for myself, but have some questions about levels, why video are so compressed without 'noisy' surfaces, why does it need time bar, etc
Its not for popularity, its just discussion. If even me could fix some bugs of video, what corporations/coders do? Its possible to use shaders for debanding, add noise for tasty and it could be available for any people and player, but I dont see this
You actually could change language to English like in normal player
videoh
19th March 2020, 18:22
add noise for tasty
Technically your utterances are rendered in English, but they appear as gobbledygook to a native English speaker. Are you using an online translator or are you just clueless?
Danila had an idea, and because it's Danila, it must be correct. ;)
Insults in, insults out.
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 18:35
>Danila had an idea, and because it's Danila, it must be correct.
Not its not necessary to be correct, its just like chat in whatsapp why not?
I can make mistake of couse, but as I know in real life surfaces not filled with regular color, on old CRT analog technologies too, but with compression they are
Bigger resolution - more unnatural colors, not? Compression artefacts? May be you can disprove this and explain why? Or irc/telegram channel about video and why is it so bad?
videoh
19th March 2020, 19:36
I Saw a Peacock, with a fiery tail,
I saw a Blazing Comet, drop down hail,
I saw a Cloud, with Ivy circled round,
I saw a sturdy Oak, creep on the ground,
I saw a Pismire, swallow up a Whale,
I saw a raging Sea, brim full of Ale,
I saw a Venice Glass, Sixteen foot deep,
I saw a well, full of mens tears that weep,
I saw their eyes, all in a flame of fire,
I saw a House, as big as the Moon and higher,
I saw the Sun, even in the midst of night,
I saw the man, that saw this wondrous sight.
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 19:43
https://sun7-6.userapi.com/c857520/v857520034/1aa3c5/fFaUql14j7w.jpg
StainlessS
19th March 2020, 19:53
I Saw a Peacock, with a fiery tail,
I saw a Blazing Comet, drop down hail,
I saw a Cloud, with Ivy circled round,
I saw a sturdy Oak, creep on the ground,
I saw a Pismire, swallow up a Whale,
I saw a raging Sea, brim full of Ale,
I saw a Venice Glass, Sixteen foot deep,
I saw a well, full of mens tears that weep,
I saw their eyes, all in a flame of fire,
I saw a House, as big as the Moon and higher,
I saw the Sun, even in the midst of night,
I saw the man, that saw this wondrous sight.
I dont know if that is poetry, or what, but I like it.
And, whats with this crazy ruski type whotsit, is he for real, I mean, really for real, really ???
EDIT: Kinda like a cross between Katie, and somebody else that I cant quite put my finger on.
EDIT: Can I recommend that Katie join into this conversation, at which point I would like to sit back and just watch and appreciate the discussion.
videoh
19th March 2020, 19:56
SS, did you see the hidden structure in there? It's far from nonsense.
Stay safe, bro.
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 19:59
https://sun9-3.userapi.com/c857332/v857332394/ae839/Nh4p5PJhZnE.jpg
Andouille
19th March 2020, 20:03
Kinda like a cross between Katie, and somebody else that I cant quite put my finger on.
hogtop is a good candidate
https://forum.doom9.org/member.php?u=159553
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 20:11
https://sun9-31.userapi.com/c856524/v856524139/12947e/uhax2UixUhM.jpg
StainlessS
19th March 2020, 20:20
SS, did you see the hidden structure in there? It's far from nonsense.
I saw the last line, if that is what is referred to. [way too artsy fartsy for me to get it though].
Anyways, I is now going into lock-down mode, getting way to dangerous for us ol' timers here in the big smoke.
EDIT: Not "Goin' dark", just yet though.
microchip8
19th March 2020, 20:23
@Danila
Shave off that neckbeard. Maybe you'll get wiser
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 20:45
im to lazy
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 20:50
mne pohuj
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 21:07
i think that corporations and modern developers make wtf hdr ultra hd 8k now they can do good things when they fall
Groucho2004
19th March 2020, 22:39
I dont know if that is poetry, or what, but I like it.http://www.potw.org/archive/potw193.html
Groucho2004
19th March 2020, 23:08
@Danila
Shave off that neckbeard. Maybe you'll get wiserJudging by the pictures he posted, it'll take a lot more than that. I recommend a complete body wax including that region where the sun don't shine followed by a thorough bumhole bleaching.
DanilaZabiaka
19th March 2020, 23:22
Syka blyad
Groucho2004
19th March 2020, 23:46
Syka blyadTranslation (https://translate.google.co.uk/#view=home&op=translate&sl=auto&tl=en&text=Syka%20blyad)
If you post these kind of pictures you're setting yourself up for public ridicule. Grow up.
videoh
20th March 2020, 00:02
http://www.potw.org/archive/potw193.html You forgot the spoiler alert. :eek:
Danila thinks very highly of himself.
DanilaZabiaka
20th March 2020, 00:08
What wrong to use your own face if you have it and joke? Who told you that its bad?
Why this is VIDEO forum but people cant use their own faces emotion?
Why people use pictures/memes/stickers huikers/emoji/masks/filters but cant use their faces using internet im forums social network etc?
https://sun9-44.userapi.com/c857428/v857428974/1af9c7/s6MgRreMN5Y.jpg
DanilaZabiaka
20th March 2020, 00:14
I dont care about how funny it is, it does not mean that im stupid. people who cant use their faces emotion are stupid and they r not people in traditional way, just some text like bots
Groucho2004
20th March 2020, 00:27
You forgot the spoiler alert. :eek:Sorry.
Groucho2004
20th March 2020, 00:34
Why this is VIDEO forum but people cant use their own faces emotion?Firstly, some people are aware of their shortcomings (which you clearly are not) and sensibly do not inflict visual cruelty onto others.
Secondly, you're wasting bandwidth.
DanilaZabiaka
20th March 2020, 00:45
Haha when face became shortcomings and why it should care people?
Modern girls faces and behaviour are shortcomings if they take fileter fotos naked in instagram its okay, if men its not okay wtf are you talking about
modern internet allows video chats, our 'facebook' vkontakte allow people stream, make video comment, anydoby can create video answer under post and its normal
Groucho2004
20th March 2020, 01:17
I guess it's time to close this thread.
DanilaZabiaka
20th March 2020, 02:00
i think its time to became human you dont have fun thread joke wtf lol
if you can joke it does not mean that you can discuss 'serious' things and you can use simple language to discus 'great' things, emotions, stickers, photos, etc
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.