Log in

View Full Version : Dithered images look bad on my monitor - any idea why?


wonkey_monkey
16th June 2019, 16:29
I've been experimenting with ordered dithering, but I've run into a weird thing where my laptop screen exhibits banding when I view a dithered gradient image at 100%.

Here's an image:

https://i.imgur.com/fGXFZtj.png

If I zoom in higher than 100%, even as little as 105%, the banding (which is like thin brighter or darker stripes) disappears.

I can still see the effect when I ramp up the levels of the dithered image:

https://i.imgur.com/8WDOfHY.png

The banding shifts if I nudge the image around my screen a pixel at the time.

Does anyone know what's causing this? I'm pretty sure I've disabled all colour corrections and stuff, and there's no sharpening or anything, but it's still visible. It's a Dell E6520 laptop with an UltraSharp FHD screen.

huhn
16th June 2019, 16:48
win 10 1903?

wonkey_monkey
16th June 2019, 16:55
Windows 7. What's Windows is putting on the screen is fine, so if anything is being changed it's being done by the graphics drivers (complicating matters, it's an Nvidia Optimus system so it has Intel and Nvidia working together). Or it's some intrinsic limitation in the screen itself.

sneaker_ger
16th June 2019, 17:32
What software are you using to view the image?

wonkey_monkey
16th June 2019, 17:40
It's the same in any software. Firefox, VirtualDub2, Photoshop...

Asmodian
16th June 2019, 23:19
Is it pixel inversion (http://testufo.com/#test=inversion) or a similar issue?

poisondeathray
17th June 2019, 00:42
it's an Nvidia Optimus system so it has Intel and Nvidia working together

To help determine if that is contributing -
In the device manager, you can disable one, repeat the tests. Then enable the other, disable the 1st, repeat the tests

wonkey_monkey
17th June 2019, 17:32
I don't think you can ever really disable the Intel graphics, and the Nvidia only chips in when it's asked to.

In any case, after a bit of intensive research (Googling) I found out that apparently Intel on laptop screens is known for banding due to the way it dithers, and I found a nifty utility to allow you to control the dithering:

https://kawamoto.no-ip.org/henteko/myapp_en.html (search for "Dithering Settings for Intel Graphics")

Setting the dithering to "Spatio-Temporal 1 (better color)" (from the default of "Spatial (default)") almost completely fixes the problem, at the cost of some barely perceptible flickering.