nalor
24th January 2016, 12:53
I thought it might be interesting for some users to see the differences between certain drives when it comes to Blu-ray ripping. Until now I've always bought used drives and never thought that the ripping speeds are varying that much between different drives.
I've used Nero DiscSpeed 7.0.200 to test the read speeds of the various drives - it's freely available on the internet (I downloaded it from heiseDownload (http://www.heise.de/download/nero-discspeed-1115677.html) because I trust Heise ).
A lot of Hitachi/LG drives can be speedpatched (riplock removed) with MediaCodeSpeedEdit (http://ala42.cdfreaks.com/MCSE/)
My new Asus BW-16D1HT is the fastest drive I've tested so far :)
(but it's BusEncryptionCapable :( )
And the Dune Smart BE is the slowest ... but to be fair, it's not really meant to be used as computer drive ;)
I've ordered the list with the fastest drives at the top - my new absolute favorite drive is the LiteOn iHBS212 because it's the fastest non-BEC drive I've found so far :) (and it's fast out of the box - no need to speedpatch the firmware as it's necessary for the HL-DT-ST drives)
Continued to buy drives to find a good external drive and my favourite in this category is the Asus SBC-06D1S-U - it's really fast and doesn't need an external power supply (it's USB powered) :D
Drives that aren't BusEncryptionCapable:
# VENDOR # PRODUCT-IDENTIF. # REV. # BEC # BLURAY-SL # BLURAY-DL # BLURAY-SL SPEEDPATCHED # BLURAY-DL SPEEDPATCHED #
| ATAPI | iHBS212 2 | HL05 | 0 | 3,37x- 7,98x / ~5,99x / ~16Min | 3,40x-8,10x / ~6,10x / ~32Min | (LiteON iHBS212-32 2 - Manufactured June 2010)
| ASUS | SBC-06D1S-U | A201 | 0 | 2,54x- 5,98x / ~4,49x / ~21Min | 2,55x-6,07x / ~4,57x / ~42Min | External USB Slim Drive - Manufactured December 2010
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CH08LS10 | 2.00 | 0 | 2,02x- 4,77x / ~3,58x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 3,39x- 8,02x / ~6,02x / ~16Min | 3,41x-8,14x / ~6,13x / ~32Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BD-RE BH10LS30 | 1.01 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,79x / ~3,60x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 4,26x-10,04x / ~7,54x / ~12Min | 3,41x-8,13x / ~5,33x / ~37Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CH10LS20 | 1.02 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,79x / ~3,60x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,86x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 4,26x-10,03x / ~7,54x / ~12Min | 3,41x-8,12x / ~5,33x / ~37Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CH10N | 1.03 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,79x / ~3,60x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,67x / ~53Min | 3,39x- 8,02x / ~6,02x / ~16Min | 2,54x-6,07x / ~4,57x / ~42Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW GGC-H20L | 1.03 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,76x / ~3,58x / ~26Min | 2,03x-4,83x / ~3,64x / ~53Min | 2,52x- 5,92x / ~4,45x / ~21Min | 2,54x-6,05x / ~4,55x / ~43Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CT30F | YT04 | 0 | 2,02x- 4,74x / ~3,57x / ~26Min | 2,03x-4,84x / ~3,65x / ~53Min |
| SAMSUNG | DVDWBD SH-B083L | SB01 | 0 | 3,34x- 7,94x / ~5,96x / ~16Min | 1,75x-4,18x / ~3,15x / ~61Min |
| ATAPI | iHOS104 | WL0F | 0 | 1,69x- 3,99x / ~3,00x / ~31Min | 1,70x-4,05x / ~3,05x / ~64Min | (LiteON drive)
| PLEXTOR | BD-ROM PX-B120U | 1.11 | 0 | 1,69x- 3,96x / ~2,97x / ~31Min | 1,70x-4,04x / ~3,03x / ~64Min |
| Optiarc | BD ROM BC-5530H | 1.B0 | 0 | 2,52x- 5,95x / ~4,47x / ~21Min | 1,69x-4,03x / ~3,03x / ~64Min |
| Slimtype | BD E DL4ETS | QAB1 | 0 | my drive does not read SL discs| 1,28x-3,06x / ~2,30x / ~83Min | (Philips & LiteON slot-in drive)
| Slimtype | BD E DS4E1S | EA2B | 0 | 1,70x- 4,02x / ~3,02x / ~31Min | 2,05x-2,05x / ~2,05x / ~89Min | (Philips & LiteON drive)
| BDROM | BP-28 | J2yZ | 0 | 1,69x- 1,68x / ~1,69x / ~52Min | 1,69x-1,70x / ~1,69x /~108Min | (HDI Dune Smart BE)
Drives that are BusEncryptionCapable:
# VENDOR # PRODUCT-IDENTIF. # REV. # BEC # BLURAY-SL # BLURAY-DL # BLURAY-SL SPEEDPATCHED # BLURAY-DL SPEEDPATCHED #
| ASUS | BW-16D1HT | 3.00 | 1 | 5,05x-11,93x / ~8,96x / ~11Min | 3,39x-8,08x / ~6,08x / ~32Min | (UHD Friendly)
| ASUS | BW-16D1HT | 1.01 | 1 | 4,99x-11,73x / ~8,82x / ~11Min | 3,36x-8,01x / ~6,03x / ~32Min |
| ATAPI | iHBS112 2 | PL05 | 1 | 3,38x- 7,98x / ~5,99x / ~16Min | 3,40x-8,10x / ~6,10x / ~32Min | (LiteON iHBS112-115 2 - Manufactured January 2012)
| TEAC | BD-W26SS-B | 1.01 | 1 | 2,62x- 5,98x / ~4,51x / ~19Min | 2,63x-6,26x / ~4,71x / ~41Min | SlotIn Drive
| HL-DT-ST | DVDRWBD CA40N | A102 | 1 | 2,52x- 5,80x / ~4,37x / ~20Min | 2,54x-6,07x / ~4,57x / ~42Min | SlotIn Drive
| MATSHITA | BD-MLT UJ265 | 1.00 | 1 | 2,53x- 5,79x / ~4,38x / ~20Min | 2,55x-6,07x / ~4,56x / ~42Min | SlotIn Drive
| HL-DT-ST | BD-RE BH10LS38 | 1.03 | 1 | 2,03x- 4,77x / ~3,58x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 4,26x-9,99x / ~7,52x / ~13Min | 3,41x-8,13x / ~5,33x / ~37Min |
| ATAPI | iHES112 3 | ML05 | 1 | 5,01x-11,75x / ~8,83x / ~11Min | 2,54x-6,05x / ~4,56x / ~43Min | (LiteON drive)
| TSSTcorp | DVDWBD SH-B123L | SB04 | 1 | 2,57x- 6,08x / ~4,56x / ~20Min | 2,59x-6,18x / ~4,65x / ~42Min | (Samsung drive)
| ASUS | SBC-06D2X-U | D201 | 1 | 2,53x- 5,87x / ~4,48x / ~21Min | 2,55x-6,06x / ~4,56x / ~42Min | External USB Slim Drive
| PIONEER | BD-RW BDR-206D | 9.56 | 1 | 4,62x- 4,50x / ~4,53x / ~20Min | 3,35x-4,89x / ~4,20x / ~44Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BD-RE BP40NS20 | ML01 | 1 | 2,03x- 5,97x / ~4,48x / ~21Min | 2,55x-6,07x / ~3,29x / ~67Min | (LG Drive)
| TSSTcorp | DVDWBD SE-406AB | TS00 | 1 | 2,20x- 2,21x / ~2,21x / ~40Min | 2,20x-2,21x / ~2,21x / ~83Min | (Samsung drive)
| TSSTcorp | BDDVDW SE-506BB | TS01 | 1 | 2,20x- 2,21x / ~2,21x / ~40Min | 1,84x-2,21x / ~2,20x / ~83Min | (Samsung drive)
Would be great if other could test their drives as well to also get results of newer drives :)
I've used Nero DiscSpeed 7.0.200 to test the read speeds of the various drives - it's freely available on the internet (I downloaded it from heiseDownload (http://www.heise.de/download/nero-discspeed-1115677.html) because I trust Heise ).
A lot of Hitachi/LG drives can be speedpatched (riplock removed) with MediaCodeSpeedEdit (http://ala42.cdfreaks.com/MCSE/)
My new Asus BW-16D1HT is the fastest drive I've tested so far :)
(but it's BusEncryptionCapable :( )
And the Dune Smart BE is the slowest ... but to be fair, it's not really meant to be used as computer drive ;)
I've ordered the list with the fastest drives at the top - my new absolute favorite drive is the LiteOn iHBS212 because it's the fastest non-BEC drive I've found so far :) (and it's fast out of the box - no need to speedpatch the firmware as it's necessary for the HL-DT-ST drives)
Continued to buy drives to find a good external drive and my favourite in this category is the Asus SBC-06D1S-U - it's really fast and doesn't need an external power supply (it's USB powered) :D
Drives that aren't BusEncryptionCapable:
# VENDOR # PRODUCT-IDENTIF. # REV. # BEC # BLURAY-SL # BLURAY-DL # BLURAY-SL SPEEDPATCHED # BLURAY-DL SPEEDPATCHED #
| ATAPI | iHBS212 2 | HL05 | 0 | 3,37x- 7,98x / ~5,99x / ~16Min | 3,40x-8,10x / ~6,10x / ~32Min | (LiteON iHBS212-32 2 - Manufactured June 2010)
| ASUS | SBC-06D1S-U | A201 | 0 | 2,54x- 5,98x / ~4,49x / ~21Min | 2,55x-6,07x / ~4,57x / ~42Min | External USB Slim Drive - Manufactured December 2010
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CH08LS10 | 2.00 | 0 | 2,02x- 4,77x / ~3,58x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 3,39x- 8,02x / ~6,02x / ~16Min | 3,41x-8,14x / ~6,13x / ~32Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BD-RE BH10LS30 | 1.01 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,79x / ~3,60x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 4,26x-10,04x / ~7,54x / ~12Min | 3,41x-8,13x / ~5,33x / ~37Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CH10LS20 | 1.02 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,79x / ~3,60x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,86x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 4,26x-10,03x / ~7,54x / ~12Min | 3,41x-8,12x / ~5,33x / ~37Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CH10N | 1.03 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,79x / ~3,60x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,67x / ~53Min | 3,39x- 8,02x / ~6,02x / ~16Min | 2,54x-6,07x / ~4,57x / ~42Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW GGC-H20L | 1.03 | 0 | 2,03x- 4,76x / ~3,58x / ~26Min | 2,03x-4,83x / ~3,64x / ~53Min | 2,52x- 5,92x / ~4,45x / ~21Min | 2,54x-6,05x / ~4,55x / ~43Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BDDVDRW CT30F | YT04 | 0 | 2,02x- 4,74x / ~3,57x / ~26Min | 2,03x-4,84x / ~3,65x / ~53Min |
| SAMSUNG | DVDWBD SH-B083L | SB01 | 0 | 3,34x- 7,94x / ~5,96x / ~16Min | 1,75x-4,18x / ~3,15x / ~61Min |
| ATAPI | iHOS104 | WL0F | 0 | 1,69x- 3,99x / ~3,00x / ~31Min | 1,70x-4,05x / ~3,05x / ~64Min | (LiteON drive)
| PLEXTOR | BD-ROM PX-B120U | 1.11 | 0 | 1,69x- 3,96x / ~2,97x / ~31Min | 1,70x-4,04x / ~3,03x / ~64Min |
| Optiarc | BD ROM BC-5530H | 1.B0 | 0 | 2,52x- 5,95x / ~4,47x / ~21Min | 1,69x-4,03x / ~3,03x / ~64Min |
| Slimtype | BD E DL4ETS | QAB1 | 0 | my drive does not read SL discs| 1,28x-3,06x / ~2,30x / ~83Min | (Philips & LiteON slot-in drive)
| Slimtype | BD E DS4E1S | EA2B | 0 | 1,70x- 4,02x / ~3,02x / ~31Min | 2,05x-2,05x / ~2,05x / ~89Min | (Philips & LiteON drive)
| BDROM | BP-28 | J2yZ | 0 | 1,69x- 1,68x / ~1,69x / ~52Min | 1,69x-1,70x / ~1,69x /~108Min | (HDI Dune Smart BE)
Drives that are BusEncryptionCapable:
# VENDOR # PRODUCT-IDENTIF. # REV. # BEC # BLURAY-SL # BLURAY-DL # BLURAY-SL SPEEDPATCHED # BLURAY-DL SPEEDPATCHED #
| ASUS | BW-16D1HT | 3.00 | 1 | 5,05x-11,93x / ~8,96x / ~11Min | 3,39x-8,08x / ~6,08x / ~32Min | (UHD Friendly)
| ASUS | BW-16D1HT | 1.01 | 1 | 4,99x-11,73x / ~8,82x / ~11Min | 3,36x-8,01x / ~6,03x / ~32Min |
| ATAPI | iHBS112 2 | PL05 | 1 | 3,38x- 7,98x / ~5,99x / ~16Min | 3,40x-8,10x / ~6,10x / ~32Min | (LiteON iHBS112-115 2 - Manufactured January 2012)
| TEAC | BD-W26SS-B | 1.01 | 1 | 2,62x- 5,98x / ~4,51x / ~19Min | 2,63x-6,26x / ~4,71x / ~41Min | SlotIn Drive
| HL-DT-ST | DVDRWBD CA40N | A102 | 1 | 2,52x- 5,80x / ~4,37x / ~20Min | 2,54x-6,07x / ~4,57x / ~42Min | SlotIn Drive
| MATSHITA | BD-MLT UJ265 | 1.00 | 1 | 2,53x- 5,79x / ~4,38x / ~20Min | 2,55x-6,07x / ~4,56x / ~42Min | SlotIn Drive
| HL-DT-ST | BD-RE BH10LS38 | 1.03 | 1 | 2,03x- 4,77x / ~3,58x / ~26Min | 2,04x-4,87x / ~3,66x / ~53Min | 4,26x-9,99x / ~7,52x / ~13Min | 3,41x-8,13x / ~5,33x / ~37Min |
| ATAPI | iHES112 3 | ML05 | 1 | 5,01x-11,75x / ~8,83x / ~11Min | 2,54x-6,05x / ~4,56x / ~43Min | (LiteON drive)
| TSSTcorp | DVDWBD SH-B123L | SB04 | 1 | 2,57x- 6,08x / ~4,56x / ~20Min | 2,59x-6,18x / ~4,65x / ~42Min | (Samsung drive)
| ASUS | SBC-06D2X-U | D201 | 1 | 2,53x- 5,87x / ~4,48x / ~21Min | 2,55x-6,06x / ~4,56x / ~42Min | External USB Slim Drive
| PIONEER | BD-RW BDR-206D | 9.56 | 1 | 4,62x- 4,50x / ~4,53x / ~20Min | 3,35x-4,89x / ~4,20x / ~44Min |
| HL-DT-ST | BD-RE BP40NS20 | ML01 | 1 | 2,03x- 5,97x / ~4,48x / ~21Min | 2,55x-6,07x / ~3,29x / ~67Min | (LG Drive)
| TSSTcorp | DVDWBD SE-406AB | TS00 | 1 | 2,20x- 2,21x / ~2,21x / ~40Min | 2,20x-2,21x / ~2,21x / ~83Min | (Samsung drive)
| TSSTcorp | BDDVDW SE-506BB | TS01 | 1 | 2,20x- 2,21x / ~2,21x / ~40Min | 1,84x-2,21x / ~2,20x / ~83Min | (Samsung drive)
Would be great if other could test their drives as well to also get results of newer drives :)