henryho_hk
26th May 2011, 17:35
Just did a DSSIM [=SSIM/(1-SSIM)] comparison using a 6-minute 720x480 clip over {compressibility 15,20,...95} x {I-Quant range 3-4 & 2-31} x {VAQ on/off} x {-metric 0 & 1} x {QPel on/off} x {H263 MPEG J1CD STLR ST2S STHR 6OF9} x {VHQ 1 & 4}, with my own XviD 1.3.1 and xvid_encraw compiles. Two-pass encodes are performed. Since the clip has a short duration, I accept the final bitrate being 94%-103% of the target bitrate.
I am amazed by the results:
[STLR + I2~31 + VHQ1 + NoQPel + Metric1 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (20.44) for compressibility 15.
[STLR + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric1 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (26.76) for compressibility 20.
[J1CD + I3~4 + VHQ4 + QPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (33.04) for compressibility 25.
[MPEG + I3~4 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (39.47) for compressibility 30.
[STLR + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (44.20) for compressibility 35.
[H263 + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric1 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (49.02, 53.57, 58.50, 62.50, 66.08) for compressibility 40-60.
[H263 + I2~31 + VHQ4 + QPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (71.16) for compressibility 65.
[H263 + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (75.40, 78.87, 82.06, 85.02, 87.87, 90.71) for compressibility 70-95.
6of9 fails in the high bitrate range, and VAQ fails in the low bitrate range. It seems DSSIM also favors "blurred" settings.
----
Sorry, DSSIM should be 1/(1-SSIM). Hence, please add 1 to the above values.
I am amazed by the results:
[STLR + I2~31 + VHQ1 + NoQPel + Metric1 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (20.44) for compressibility 15.
[STLR + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric1 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (26.76) for compressibility 20.
[J1CD + I3~4 + VHQ4 + QPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (33.04) for compressibility 25.
[MPEG + I3~4 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (39.47) for compressibility 30.
[STLR + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (44.20) for compressibility 35.
[H263 + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric1 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (49.02, 53.57, 58.50, 62.50, 66.08) for compressibility 40-60.
[H263 + I2~31 + VHQ4 + QPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (71.16) for compressibility 65.
[H263 + I2~31 + VHQ4 + NoQPel + Metric0 + NoVAQ] has the highest DSSIM (75.40, 78.87, 82.06, 85.02, 87.87, 90.71) for compressibility 70-95.
6of9 fails in the high bitrate range, and VAQ fails in the low bitrate range. It seems DSSIM also favors "blurred" settings.
----
Sorry, DSSIM should be 1/(1-SSIM). Hence, please add 1 to the above values.