Log in

View Full Version : Comodo Internet Security settings for DVD-RB


akageekster
25th November 2010, 20:11
Hi ppl;

It seems Comodo Internet Security (CIS) has finally outdone themselves with their security settings causing DVD-RB to stop working altogether! :rolleyes:

It wasn't always so, since I was able to use DVD-RB previously without any problems. Then all of a sudden DVD-RB stopped working and no error message given!! :mad:

After a quick search here in the forums, I came across this post, DVD Rebuilder not working anymore? (http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=157137), which in turn referenced the thread Problem with DVD Rebuilder (http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=157546), pointing to CIS as being responsible, specifically Defense+. I can only surmise this sudden annoyance is a result of a recent CIS auto update.

The recommended solution was to turn off the proactive Defense+. However, that might be a bit much for some of you. After mucking about in the options, I discovered how to allow DVD-RB to work without completely disabling Defense+ thru the Execution Control Settings tab of the Defense+ Settings dialog box.

Now to the procedure:

Double-click on the Comodo icon in the system tray of the taskbar.
At the top of the newly opened dialog box, click on the Defense+ tab, then in the Tasks area, click on Defense+ Settings
In this next dialog box, under the General Settings tab you can permanently deactivate Defense+ by checking the box next to the "Deactivate the Defense+ permanently (Requires a system restart)" line, then click on the [OK] button. From here, you will get the standard dialog box asking if you want to restart Windows at this time. If so, click [Yes], and you're done.
If you want to keep Defense+ on, go on to the next tab titled "Execution Control Settings".
Now this is where it gets tricky. Simply moving the "Image Execution Control Level" slider to Disabled will not work. In the lower right corner click on the button labeled [Exclusions].
Now we reach the point where we can fine tune which apps to be excluded from Defense+ interference. In the Exclusions dialog, click on the [Add] button on the right and a little submenu will pop up.
If you just want to exclude DVD-RB, highlight and click on the "Browse..." line in the submenu, and in the left window of the pop up dialog find the DVD-RB program folder, drag it across to the right window and click on the [Apply] button. Then click on the [Apply] button in the Exclusions dialog box, click [OK] in the Defense+ Settings dialog box and close the Comodo box. That's it! We're done. The settings are immediate, so no reboot is necessary.


NOTE: In the last step, instead of a single app to exclude, you can choose to exclude certain types of files (executables, system files, etc.) by highlighting the first line in the submenu labeled "File Groups" and choosing among the list in the next pop up submenu.

Personally, I ended up disabling Defense+ completely, but for the more paranoid among us, you can now select any apps Defense+ doesn't play nice with. :p

HTH,
---AKAgeekster


PS: BTW, Jerry, thanks for a great piece of software. :thanks:

jdobbs
25th November 2010, 22:01
Good information... thanks. :goodpost:

akageekster
26th November 2010, 03:32
You're welcome. Glad to be of some help. :)

And before I forget, I'm running version 5 of CIS (specifically version 5.0.162636.1135), in case anyone might be having a problem with the directions...

steptoe
26th November 2010, 19:02
This was the biggest reason I binned Comodo, otherwise it did everything I asked from free virus software

It was just too damned paranoid and blocked everything 'it' though was dodgy and trying to get it to play nice with DVD-RB was horrendous

I though AVG was bad but Comodo was even worse, pity really as otherwise it did everything I was looking for

jdobbs
26th November 2010, 21:16
This was the biggest reason I binned Comodo, otherwise it did everything I asked from free virus software

It was just too damned paranoid and blocked everything 'it' though was dodgy and trying to get it to play nice with DVD-RB was horrendous

I though AVG was bad but Comodo was even worse, pity really as otherwise it did everything I was looking for What's really bad about these anti-virus programs is that they don't even give you a warning telling you they are blocking something from executing... they just leave you guessing why it won't run.

In my humble opinion when something causes your computer to stop working like it's supposed to -- it is a virus, not an "anti-virus".

Stormcrow
26th November 2010, 23:54
What's really bad about these anti-virus programs is that they don't even give you a warning telling you they are blocking something from executing... they just leave you guessing why it won't run.

In my humble opinion when something causes your computer to stop working like it's supposed to -- it is a virus, not an "anti-virus".

Indeed.

I've come to the conclusion that the risks/downsides of AV software outweighs the positives, and I now run naked. Have done for years now.

The cure is now worse than the disease.

I have a hardware firewall, and I let window's own host-based firewall run too. I keep the machines updated.

I don't allow random code to run on my machine, and I don't go to dodgy p0rn sites. There is a risk that legit websites may become infected and spew out zero-day exploits to my machines. If these are true zero-day exploits, then I doubt AV software will pick it up any quicker than the OS patches.

--
SC

akageekster
27th November 2010, 05:04
I have a hardware firewall, and I let window's own host-based firewall run too. I keep the machines updated.



My router just quit working not too long ago, so I don't have a hardware firewall anymore, until I get it replaced :rolleyes:

As for the windows firewall, let's just say I don't have much faith in it since Uncle Billy is still running the show at M$........Nuff said, before I mount that soapbox ;)...........besides, running 2 firewalls can sometimes create a bottleneck, since the packets are being filtered twice.

Once I replace my router, I'll remove CIS and just dl and install their AV solo. With the anti-malware disabled, I'm just running an integrated AV/firewall. Like you, SC, I don't frequent those dodgy sites, and if I feel the need to check for suspicious activity, I can always use Spybot or something similar...:p

In the meantime, anyone who was having probs can now apply a fix that should keep them from pulling their hair out by the roots in frustration.....:cool: