PUO_plugin of PgcEdit (shown as not removed after process)

[jinjin_jp]

Recently I know angle change PUO is not removed by DVDFabHDDDecrypter and AnyDVD as feature.
I usually backups only main movie with all angles.
So I remove angle change PUO, because I want to change angle without menu.

This time I removed angle change PUO by PUO_plugin of PgcEdit, and succeeded.
I think strange that it shows this PUO(VOB) is remaining even after remove and become possible to change angle.
http://img11.imageshack.us/img11/4760/puo.th.jpg (http://img11.imageshack.us/my.php?image=puo.jpg)
Why is it?

Regards.

(Add) I confirmed about what ripped by DVDDecrypter before.
It shows that this PUO(VOB) is remaining even though removed and possible to change angle.

[Wombler]

Yes, the ripping software does that by default to avoid the issue of the angle icon being displayed throughout the entire film on certain DVD players.

If you removed it though with PgcEdit it should stay removed so it could possibly be a bug.

Are you certain you saved the changes in PgcEdit before reopening?


Wombler

[jinjin_jp]

Are you certain you saved the changes in PgcEdit before reopening?
Yes, I saved when changing both IFO and VOB.

Regards.

[blutach]

You'll need to untick that PUO in the Selectively Clear VOB PUOs and that should get rid of it. Next time you call the function, the 2 defaults (GoUp and Angle Change) will still be ticked (but they should already be removed from the VOBs). The function does not read the VOBs until you press OK, so it has no way of knowing whether they are present or not.

So having somthing ticked (in this case) simply means not changing its state - read the explanation at the top.

Regards

[r0lZ]

Blu is right. The PUO editor usually shows you the state of each PUO. But for the VOBs, it's impossible, as PgcEdit doesn't check them in the VOB files before displaying the dialog (as doing so could take much time) and furthermore, a PUO value can change in the different cells of the VOB (and even in the different VOBUs of each cell!) Therefore, in the PUO plugin, the checkboxes have a different meaning. If you leave a PUO ticked, that means that PgcEdit will NOT modify it. If you clear a checkbox, the PUO will be cleared in the whole VOB file.

[jinjin_jp]

@blutach and r0lZ

Thanks for the reply and explanation.
I can understand.
(I can't know there remains PUO of VOB, but I can remove it by untick and press OK.)

Regards.