Turtleggjp
11th February 2009, 21:43
I posted this question a while back in the MPC-HC thread:
Does anyone else experience blurring at the bottom of the video (last 8 lines or so) when accelerating H.264 or VC-1 videos with ATI cards? The problem does not show up on most Blu Ray videos, because most have black bars at the top and bottom. The ones that do have full frame video have this problem. Playing the discs in PowerDVD does not show the problem, however using PowerDVD's DXVA filter in MPC does show the problem, so I don't think MPC HC's DXVA implementation is to blame. I also have the problem with my x264 encodes of TV shows I have recorded, since they are mostly full frame (1920x1080). I had this problem with my Radeon 3450, and was happy to see that a GeForce 8500 did not have this problem (this card won't bitstream VC-1 though). I recently upgraded to a Radeon 4650, hoping that this issue had been fixed (on ATI's side) and dreaming of one day getting a receiver with HDMI audio capability. To my surprise, this blurring issue still remains! Needless to say I was not happy, and am currently awaiting a new GeForce 9400 Motherboard hoping that Nvidia will continue to work better.
I am using Windows XP SP2, and the System default renderer. I tried other renderers, and the problem seems to go away if I use VMR9, but I get bad tearing when I use that one. Anyone else experiencing this? Thanks.
Matt
I was told that the last line was being repeated 8 times to bring the image up to a mod 16 resolution (1920x1080 -> 1920x1088), and that it should be up to the renderer to crop off these excess lines. I never got an answer about how to do this, but it didn't really matter, because I had moved on to my GeForce 9400 motherboard and did not experience this problem anymore. However, I recently built a new system for someone that used a Radeon 4830 card (for gaming), and during my testing of it, the blurring issue was still there. So is there a way to solve this problem? As I said before, the blurring seems to go away when using VMR9, but even on this higher end system (Core2 Duo E8500, Radeon 4830) playback is very choppy when I switch to that renderer. It would be nice to resolve that issue as well, since the choppy playback issue with VMR9 also occurs with my GeForce 9400 setup, and I may someday want to play videos with subtitles using VMR9 Renderless. Thanks!
Matt
Does anyone else experience blurring at the bottom of the video (last 8 lines or so) when accelerating H.264 or VC-1 videos with ATI cards? The problem does not show up on most Blu Ray videos, because most have black bars at the top and bottom. The ones that do have full frame video have this problem. Playing the discs in PowerDVD does not show the problem, however using PowerDVD's DXVA filter in MPC does show the problem, so I don't think MPC HC's DXVA implementation is to blame. I also have the problem with my x264 encodes of TV shows I have recorded, since they are mostly full frame (1920x1080). I had this problem with my Radeon 3450, and was happy to see that a GeForce 8500 did not have this problem (this card won't bitstream VC-1 though). I recently upgraded to a Radeon 4650, hoping that this issue had been fixed (on ATI's side) and dreaming of one day getting a receiver with HDMI audio capability. To my surprise, this blurring issue still remains! Needless to say I was not happy, and am currently awaiting a new GeForce 9400 Motherboard hoping that Nvidia will continue to work better.
I am using Windows XP SP2, and the System default renderer. I tried other renderers, and the problem seems to go away if I use VMR9, but I get bad tearing when I use that one. Anyone else experiencing this? Thanks.
Matt
I was told that the last line was being repeated 8 times to bring the image up to a mod 16 resolution (1920x1080 -> 1920x1088), and that it should be up to the renderer to crop off these excess lines. I never got an answer about how to do this, but it didn't really matter, because I had moved on to my GeForce 9400 motherboard and did not experience this problem anymore. However, I recently built a new system for someone that used a Radeon 4830 card (for gaming), and during my testing of it, the blurring issue was still there. So is there a way to solve this problem? As I said before, the blurring seems to go away when using VMR9, but even on this higher end system (Core2 Duo E8500, Radeon 4830) playback is very choppy when I switch to that renderer. It would be nice to resolve that issue as well, since the choppy playback issue with VMR9 also occurs with my GeForce 9400 setup, and I may someday want to play videos with subtitles using VMR9 Renderless. Thanks!
Matt