Log in

View Full Version : newbie to mkv - queries on splitters, xp, ordering


halsboss
12th January 2009, 05:31
I'm having a little difficulty coming to grips with concepts around mkv (eg "splitter") and hope for some assistance.

My PC has ffdshow, MediaPlayerClassic, Avisynth, and Nero7 (inlcuding Recode 2 which understands mp4), and plays MP4s, avis, etc fine. Couple of questions about MKV related matters, after reading the Matroska FAQ http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=54306 -

The Matroska FAQ mentions the need for an .MKV splitter. Is there a small test sample .MKV file which I can download to test things out ?

How do I open an .MKV in avisynth (assume PAL country) ?

If I need to install a .MKV splitter, is Haali the recommended one and do you consider it to be "safe" ?

Some topics seem to mention a concept something like "ordering" of Windows XP splitters, or something like that (merits?). Is that right ? How can that be done ?

Given I'm very happy with ffdshow etc how can I order the splitters/codecs or whatever, so that the haali splitter is "found" as a last resort only and the ffdshow codecs etc are still used even with a .MKV ? If I understand it, haali will open .mp4 too whereas I would like whatever I'm using now to continue to be used "in preference to" haali and haali is only ever invoked when nothing else will do the job.

Jeff Flowerday
12th January 2009, 07:11
When you install haali you have options to not have it handle ts/m2ts, mp4 etc. Disabling all the other option has it only do mkv files.

Haali is a splitter that take each elementary stream(video/audio/subtitles) in an mkv and feeds it to the appropriate directshow filter. So to answer you question, everything will operate as you have it currently configured via ffdshow be it mpeg2, h264 etc.

halsboss
12th January 2009, 08:31
Great ! Thanks.

Any pointers to short sample .mkv's to test things out ?

Jeff Flowerday
12th January 2009, 16:59
Create one using makemkv, it's dead simple.

setarip_old
12th January 2009, 19:51
@Jeff Flowerday

Hi! Create one using makemkv, it's dead simple.I believe you're mistaken, as "MakeMKV" can only process full DVDs, HD-DVDs, and BluRay discs.

Rather, I believe "halsboss" can use "MKVMerge" to create small MKV samples...

Jeff Flowerday
12th January 2009, 21:23
@Jeff Flowerday

Hi! I believe you're mistaken, as "MakeMKV" can only process full DVDs, HD-DVDs, and BluRay discs.


No I'm not mistaken, it's exactly what I meant. I just assumed he had a DVD kicking around and he wasn't just downloading his content.

You might be mistaken by assuming he has a source readily available to feed into mkvmerge.

halsboss
12th January 2009, 23:28
Thankyou for the advice, I can use both suggestions - DV sources, home made DVDs, TV captures for timeshifted viewing...

setarip_old
13th January 2009, 00:05
@Jeff Flowerday

The question by "halsboss" was:Any pointers to short sample .mkv's to test things out ?(BTW - I'm the person who first directed you to "Make MKV" ;>})