Audio prob. ripping As Good As It Gets

[vtqanh]

I encoded the audio using Graphedit.
The audio and the video were synch perfectly, except for one problem: the commentary tracks were included in the movie, too (and those tracked spreads throughout the movie!).
Any help will be appreciated. Thanks in advance

[chi]

pretty simple, you extracted the wrong audio-stream from your vobs...
eg 0x80 is english
0x81 is german
0x82 is english with comments

[vtqanh]

Where do I find those settings (0x80, 0x81...)? (I'm new to DVD ripping)

[Doom9]

during the ripping process smartripper or vstrip will give you a stream listing, first stream = 0x80, 2nd stream = 0x81, etc

[vtqanh]

Now the problem is I don't have the DVD with me anymore. Is there anyway to do anything with those ripped .vob to get the correct stream?

[ChristianHJW]

Yes, use DVD2AVI, open the VOBs, either select an audio stream or use 'demux all audio'. DVD2AVI will now extract all the available AC3 streams from your VOB's ( can be up to 8, normally 2 - 5 ) and name them all according to tag number, delay, etc. .

Now you can play them all in very normal Mediaplayer ( given you have filters for AC3 installed, coming with every DVD player software like WinDVD, etc. ) and find out the correct track for you ....

Then feed this AC3 into latest BeSweet and BeSweet GUI and make a high quality Lame VBR or ABR MP3 from it. This can be muxed to your video using Nandub RC2.

[vtqanh]

I figured it out last night. i was using Mpeg-2 Splitter before. I changed to Ligos, and got the right stream. (Because with Mpeg-2 splitter, I got only one choice for audio stream; and too bad that only stream is the one with commetary tracks)
Thanks for all ur help.