It gonna make me crazy !!!

[totoro]

I'm gonna be crazy with this problem: When I try to mix my ac3 file (extracted with DVD2AVI) with my video/avi file (made whith Gordian/Nandub), I got a desync. My ac3 file is a couple of seconds shorter than my video file ! But the source is the same (a 500 Mo vob file )!!!
I know that with a lot of work, I could strech the audio, but I don't understand why the audio is shorter than the video, while they come from the same vob file !!!
Thanx for your help (and forgive my bad english)

[MaTTeR]

You didn't mention if you were using your audio interleave while muxing.

[Doom9]

and you know what's making me crazy? people who don't follow forum rule 2.. use a subject that tells us what your post is about please.

[totoro]

Doom9 > I'm sincerely sorry about the wrong title of my topic. I've read a while ago, and i didn't remenber the title rule when I wrote it ... Sorry

MaTTeR > I tried all the sttings (inclding the audio interleave while muxing) I've found on many serious guides (including the doom9 's one) and I got the same shorter audio file bug. I tried to rip it with flask, and it failed (said that my settings were incorrect) : maybe the vob file is corrupted ?

[MaTTeR]

totoro,
If your using Flash to encode your video then that's most likely your problem. Flask always gave me sync problems way back when I used it. I think it stretched the video thus causing your sync problems. I suggest you take a look at using Gknot if you want perfect rips:)

Dont let the interface scare you, it's not that bad. Just read the nice guide on Doom9's site and give it a shot.

[totoro]

MaTTeR > As I said in my 1st post, I tried all the ways to encode my video : Gordian / Nandub -> Divx3/SBC ; Grodian / VDub -> Divx4 ; Flask -> Divx 4.
I tried also to simply extract the audio file from the vob : I extracted it with DVD2AVI, and a demux software. I get both ac3 and wav files.
And in all the cases, the audio file is shorter than the video file.
I would say finaly that I'm NOT a newbie ripper, I made several movies with all the existong methods.
In fact, I don't understand why I can't properly extract an audio file that match whith the video...

[xzquala]

what is the delay value that smart ripper gives you?

[MaTTeR]

I guess the last thing I would try is stream processing with SR 2.41 and memux the audio stream to an extra file. If that doesn't work, try use the movie mode in SR. I didn't mean to treat you as a newbie, you only had 6 posts though so I assumed you were new;)

[totoro]

I finaly found out a compromise !
I ripped the vob shit with that old good Flask !
Don't laugh at it ! It is the only way I found after dozens of tries wtih all the newest methods ! And the result is pretty good (I admit that's the video of the animated menu I'm going to make for my MicroDVD movie, so the 1-pass low-motion divx3.11 quality is good enough :p)
Thanks for your help guys :)

@Doom9 : sorry again if I bored you with my topic. Your job in our pretty world is so good for us. Keep on going man, you're really the best ;) (and you should activate the research feature of your vbb forum, it could prevent from always posting the same boring question ;) )