Possible CoreAAC bug

[wiak]

@betaboy
i have something your CoreAAC devs can work with
this is a Norwegian DVB-T Test, its h264+he-aac (µber rare)
http://nwgat.net/ts/
to get that working with CoreAAC, the only decoder that works i have found so far is winamp on that aac file
bear @ http://forums.dvbowners.com/index.php?showtopic=5635
is working on a splitter that splitts the audio out of ts

if am not mistaking CoreAAC and Winamp is using FAAC2, but the way Winamp has it implented works better

http://forums.afterdawn.com/thread_view.cfm/518584
http://forums.winamp.com/showthread.php?s=&postid=2195297
http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index.php?showtopic=53694&hl=norway
http://www.dvbviewer.info/forum/index.php?showtopic=17644&hl=Norway

its only 4 months left :rolleyes:
:thanks:

[Sirber]

@wiak

This s CoreAVC thread. ;)

[Inventive Software]

Yeah, but there's no harm in giving them a challenge they can actually work on! :D

[wiak]

@wiak

This s CoreAVC thread. ;)
but still CoreAAC and CoreAVC is in the same standard if am not to hot in my head her that is 27.5c :p

[Sirber]

CoreAAC goes in it's own thread ;)
Also, AAC has nothing to do with AVC. One is audio codec, the other video codec. The difference is oblivious.
You should use ffdshow for audio decoding, or MPC directly. Both have libfaad2 and works perfectly.

[wiak]

CoreAAC goes in it's own thread ;)
Also, AAC has nothing to do with AVC. One is audio codec, the other video codec. The difference is oblivious.
You should use ffdshow for audio decoding, or MPC directly. Both have libfaad2 and works perfectly.
have you tryd the aac file?
no directshow filter work, only winamp :/

[Sirber]

your .aac is not complient:
Audio isn't MPEG-2/4 AAC with ADTS
Error importing NTV 722000 03-28 22-06-42 MPA PID 280.aac: BitStream Not Compliant
testing the .ts.
[edit]

nope.
internal AAC decoder in MPC gives no sound, and ffdshow doesn't even kick in.
haali splitter detects no audio in the .ts

your source has no audio or is broken.

[wiak]

your .aac is not complient:
Audio isn't MPEG-2/4 AAC with ADTS
Error importing NTV 722000 03-28 22-06-42 MPA PID 280.aac: BitStream Not Compliant
testing the .ts.
[edit]

nope.
internal AAC decoder in MPC gives no sound, and ffdshow doesn't even kick in.
haali splitter detects no audio in the .ts

your source has no audio or is broken.
there is many he-aac audio tracks in the TS
its just that there is no decoder that can decode it right and no splitter that spits out the he-aac tracks as a pin :confused:

[KoD]

So, how is this a CoreAAC bug in the end ? If the splitter doesn't expose the stream, how is a decoder supposed to decode it ?

Do you have fun throwing stones in the dark? Maybe someone will get hit and cry ?

[ChronoCross]

Nothing not even a wimper in showtime. Internal splitters in MPC don't show anything.