Log in

View Full Version : Make or break features


DragonHawk
13th February 2007, 10:27
AutoGK is truly an awesome piece of software. However, it would be twice as useful to me (and hopefully lots of other users) if it just had two more features:

1 - Add option to specify output video bitrate
2 - Add option under output resolution to match input resolution

At the moment I have to use a bitrate > size calculator to get the target size from the video length before I can convert. I tend to encode all video at the same bitrate, as size is not much of a concern when writing to DVDs. The "target quality" option isn't all that useful for storing videos to be watched, as it gives no guarantee of maximum bitrate (therefore there's a good chance the bitrate might spike too high for certain devices). That setting is meant for video that's to be edited and re-encoded before final production.

Those settings will also slightly speed up ripping, as no compressibility test will be required and the video does not need to be resized.

Another thing I picked up: When ripping in ifo mode and ripping, say, program chain 3 in the ifo, all the preceding PGCs are also ripped...

CWR03
13th February 2007, 11:01
As mentioned in the FAQ and on the AutoGK site, it has officially ceased development.

DragonHawk
13th February 2007, 12:03
Sorry, my bad!

If the sources were available, I would volunteer to add those options myself, as they would be really useful!

CWR03
13th February 2007, 20:59
As also mentioned, len0x does not plan to release the source code.

DragonHawk
14th February 2007, 09:41
That's why I said "If the sources were available"...

This is still an awesome app. Maybe some day I'll write my own; modeled after it...

CWR03
14th February 2007, 10:53
If you're technically able to write an app that takes your favorite parts of AutoGK and incorporates your "wish list," then it should be much less trouble for you to use a more advanced method of encoding, such as the full Gordian Knot or scripting for VirtualDub.

DragonHawk
14th February 2007, 11:20
True. I'm just keeping developing my own app on the list because I have not yet taken the time to look at all the automation that goes into AGK yet. Eventually I want to be able to rip a whole dvd with extra features and subtitles etc at the optimum settings (audio channel processing and decombing etc) with a single click (or close to it). I'll have to determine how many of the "smart" automation features of AGK can be done using scripts etc, or whether an all-inclusive app is best. All I need is time to investigate everything (haven't even had a proper close look at full GK yet...).