Log in

View Full Version : Huge reliablity difference between +R and -R's when burning via USB?


Codesmith
14th September 2006, 02:59
Some time ago I moved my NEC 3520 burner to a USB 2.0 Enclosure. I use Nero Version 6.6.1.4

My Ritek x8 DVD+Rs continue to work great, prefect results 99-100 out of 100 times with each disc being tested using by creating a Nero CD/DVD speed transfer graph. Other +R & +RW works fine as well.

Also zero problems burning +R at 8x via USB while testing the previously burnt DVD in an internal burner, something I can't do if both drives are internal.

Unfortunately when I try to burn -R's I am getting a 50-75% failure rate on Legacy 8x DVD-R media which worked OK in the past.

I do a bit better if I don't test one DVD as I burn another but the yields are still too low for me to keep using these discs.

I am guessing that because of the USB connection the burning process is being interrupted in a way that +R media can recover from but -R cannot.

Then again maybe its the media I am using that is to blame, and its a coincidence that I didn't get any bad ones before going external.

Not a big deal as I have media that gets the job done.

I am just curious if anyone else has noticed similar differences between +R and -R or between individual brands, when burning via a USB 2.0 enclosure.