MenuEdit changer are uneffective on standalone player

[liquidator87]

Here is my problem: when I use MenuEdit to change some parts of the dvd menu, they are correctly recognized and applied if I read the dvd with my computer, but when I insert the same dvd in the standalone player, these disappear and the menu returns as it was in the original dvd. An example: in the menu there's a button with the command "Jump to title 1" and I change it in "Jump to title 2", in the computer the command is executed correctly (the second one), but in the standalone player is still executed the first. Is this a program problem, or am I forgetting something?

[Video Dude]

Menus are in two groups.

16x9 is usually Group 1.
4:3 Pan & Scan is usually Group 2.

Most likely, you are just editing Group 1 in MenuEdit. Your TV might be using Group 2.

In MenuEdit, you have to edit each group separately. This is a pain since you have to do every thing twice. I believe the free version of MenuEdit is restricted for advanced menus. This could also be your problem.

I would suggest using the menu editor built into PGCEdit, rather than the older MenuEdit. PGCEdit will automatically change both groups. It will even make a backup in case you make a mistake. PGCEdit is also more powerful in that it allows you to cut and paste commands and even trace the button commands.

[r0lZ]

The free version of MenuEdit can only edit group 1. You have to pay, or use PgcEdit to edit both groups.

@Video Dude: Thanks for the ad! ;)

[liquidator87]

Thanks, I'll try the PgcEdit menu editor (I didn't know PgcEdit had one)...
Edit: you were right, I modified the group 2 and the dvd is now ok! thanks so much :)