Difference between RipIt4Me/PgcEdit and AnyDVD or any other tools

[manoflogan]

Hi To All,

What is the difference between all the tools in terms of quality/speed or any other parameters? Which software would the users suggest?

Thanks,

[CWR03]

Quality of output? No difference, since it's not doing any re-encoding. Speed? Entirely dependent on how it interacts with your system. Suggest? Whichever works, or fits the intended purpose, or suits the particular protection scheme of the disk.

[blutach]

Not quite right CWR03, since quality of output in this case also includes IFO files and some rippers take all the tiny ARccOS cells out, etc.

Another thread here is suggesting RipIt4Me (http://www.ripit4me.org/) and the plugin are both very compliant, closely followed by AnyDVD.

But, we should do our own experiments and give feedback :)

Regards