Log in

View Full Version : Uncompressed VOB Viewing


Dexter411
6th May 2006, 15:19
Hi guys,

So here's my dilemma: I've backed up most of my DVD library onto a massive hard drive for use in a media center in the living room. My initial thought was, "Okay, the DVD player has these files as 6gig files and my drives total to about 2 terabytes, so that's fine," but ripping mpeg streams into "Uncompressed AVI" balloons them up to 70 GB files and, while playing the VOB files straight looks great in VLC, the time codes always have the movies being much shorter than they actually are (e.g. a Monty Python DVD is an hour and a half long, but the progress bar in the program shows it being 50 minutes long, even though the entire thing is there). Also, I want to avoid using any DivX or Xvid compression because certain artifacts (like what looks like interlacing in a progressive video stream) take away from the quality I want.

So is there any easy way to convert mpeg streams to AVIs while retaining the sub-10gig filesize or a way to fix the VOBs so that the time displayed in VLC is actually how long the file is? To reiterate, I've played back the entire VOBs and they are the full 2 hour movies even if they show up as being 1:20:00 long.

Sincerely,
Dexter

CWR03
6th May 2006, 18:36
1) You could rip the disks in .ISO mode and still view them with VLC, or mount them with a virtual drive and play them with your preferred software DVD player.

2) You could encode them with DivX or XviD with a high enough bitrate that you won't have artifacts and double your capacity.

The only time I've had a problem with the timestamp not fitting the file properly was when I had ripped it in File mode with DVD Decrypter - if you're only ripping the video content and omitting the extras, you might try .IFO mode.

Dexter411
6th May 2006, 19:59
So I've tried testing with other players and it seems the timestamping issue is VLC specific. Anyone know of a fix?

setarip_old
7th May 2006, 00:56
Hi!

Does this time stamp issue with VLC impact your ability to playback in any way?

Dexter411
7th May 2006, 03:08
Well the video plays, but the time is way off making it nearly impossible to navigate. Am I the only one having this issue? I've since reproduced it with a few more VOBs...

manono
7th May 2006, 06:46
I don't understand. Why are you playing vobs? Why aren't you playing the DVDs? Didn't you rip the IFOs/BUPs to the hard drive at the same time you got the vobs?

http://www.doom9.org/mpg/hd-playback.htm