Log in

View Full Version : Gordian Knot uses a different IEEE-1180 to DGIndex?


Skywalkerjen
30th December 2005, 18:07
Hi there

DGIndex 1.4.6b2
Gordian Knot 0.35.0

I process the vob using DGIndex and the iDCT Algorithm: IEEE-1180
When I load the .d2v into Gordian Knot I use the advanced Save .avs dialogue.

I then use Gordian Knot to create the .avs file and one option is to change the iDCT used. If I set the idct to 0 then the .d2v value is used - the IEEE-1180 that I specified in DGIndex.

However, if I chose option 4: 64bit IEEE-1180 Reference that Gordian Knot specifies I get a different file - checked with an md5 checksum.

Which one is correct? The DGIndex IEEE-1180 or the Gordian Knot IEEE-1180?

I tested this further and found the following:

DGIndex and Gordian Knot produce exactly the same file when either is set to 32-bitMMX or Skal SSE MMX and any video length.

DGIndex and Gordian Knot produce exactly the same file when both are set to IEEE-1180 Reference but only when the video length is small (around 50 frames).

Thanks for any help

Guest
8th January 2006, 16:56
Sorry I cannot help with (A)GK. Please try the A(GK) forum.