Unofficial Haali Media Splitter bug tracker - Page 7

clsid · 23rd June 2013, 16:59

It is version 1.13.138.14, which was already posted here in April.

A warning for anyone that uses it, the uninstaller is a bit broken and may fail to unregister the x64 components. So you may need to do some manual cleanup in the registry afterwards. Dunno if older versions had the same bug.

Octo-puss · 24th June 2013, 10:39

Hm, new features are nice, but only one bugfix mentioned. I am afraid... (or maybe not since I long ago switched to LAV :P)

Djfe · 27th August 2014, 23:17

is it correct that haali.su/mkv seems to be down?

my browser only shows timeout

a bug I found:
The Haali Media Splitter crashes on ATSC Transportstreams with a Video-PID below 30
DVB forbids the usage of Video-PIDS below 30 but ATSC doesn't

sample file:
http://www.file-upload.net/download-...cutted.ts.html

clsid · 28th August 2014, 16:06

Does not crash here with 1.13.138.14.
http://www.divx-digest.com/software/..._splitter.html

Djfe · 28th August 2014, 22:44

I should be more clear about what I mean by crash:
I use the TS Doctor, which uses Haali as a Splitter for it's cutting preview window

If I use LAV as a Splitter it doesn't crash, but with Haali it crashes

The developer of the TSD says that this is caused by the Haali Splitter because of the issue mentioned above and not by the TSD itself

clsid · 29th August 2014, 01:58

Haali has been inactive for a long time, so I don't think there is much chance of a fix. Jeeb has a copy of the source code I think, so he might be of some help.

Is there anything specific that TSD does differently compared to a normal player? Because I would have expected it to crash for normal playback as well if the cause is as you describe.

Thunderbolt8 · 29th August 2014, 04:35

would be nice if jeeb could take over improving the splitter.

Djfe · 29th August 2014, 19:51

Would also be nice if Haali and LAV could be joined/merged, because LAV is in active development and maybe nevcairiel could use some of the code of the Haali Splitter to improve his and make a better one

(at least for the Splitter part)

clsid · 30th August 2014, 01:46

That is not going to happen.

If there is something that Haali can do that LAV can't then you should submit a feature request (or bug report). The only thing I can think of right now is the ability to switch Programs in a MPEG-TS files, which is already on the LAV Filters (long term) ToDo list. In general LAV is already way ahead of Haali in terms of functionality and stability.

Djfe · 30th August 2014, 22:27

One thing I'm missing:
LAV is more for playback than Haali

Haali is way more precise if it comes to reading out exact timecodes/frame-types etc.
all this is needed by editor like the TSD which allows you to cut your records

at least this is what Cypheros said about it

nevcairiel · 31st August 2014, 09:01

DirectShow is a terrible platform for cutting, its not designed for that purpose, and any tool trying to use it for that is flawed by design.

But like I mentioned before, anyone is welcome to provide patches for a feature they care about. Thats really how open source works. I'm not paid by anyone to work on anything specific, I work on what I care about, and what I want in the future of my project. And considering I don't see DirectShow even as a viable framework for editing, you can imagine how much I care about such improvements myself. Just asking for stuff isn't going to make it magically appear, unless someone wants to work on it.

Djfe · 31st August 2014, 17:24

Of course and I really appreciate your work on open source filters/splitter

and of course directshow isn't perfect but it would cost a lot of money for the licenses to write something on your own (since Cypheros software is commercial)

23rd June 2013, 16:59	#121 \| Link
clsid ***** Join Date: Feb 2005 Posts: 5,647	It is version 1.13.138.14, which was already posted here in April. A warning for anyone that uses it, the uninstaller is a bit broken and may fail to unregister the x64 components. So you may need to do some manual cleanup in the registry afterwards. Dunno if older versions had the same bug. __________________ MPC-HC 2.2.1

27th August 2014, 23:17	#123 \| Link
Djfe Registered User Join Date: May 2014 Posts: 24	is it correct that haali.su/mkv seems to be down? my browser only shows timeout a bug I found: The Haali Media Splitter crashes on ATSC Transportstreams with a Video-PID below 30 DVB forbids the usage of Video-PIDS below 30 but ATSC doesn't sample file: http://www.file-upload.net/download-...cutted.ts.html Last edited by Djfe; 28th August 2014 at 01:01.

28th August 2014, 16:06	#124 \| Link
clsid ***** Join Date: Feb 2005 Posts: 5,647	Does not crash here with 1.13.138.14. http://www.divx-digest.com/software/..._splitter.html __________________ MPC-HC 2.2.1

29th August 2014, 01:58	#126 \| Link
clsid ***** Join Date: Feb 2005 Posts: 5,647	Haali has been inactive for a long time, so I don't think there is much chance of a fix. Jeeb has a copy of the source code I think, so he might be of some help. Is there anything specific that TSD does differently compared to a normal player? Because I would have expected it to crash for normal playback as well if the cause is as you describe. __________________ MPC-HC 2.2.1

29th August 2014, 04:35	#127 \| Link
Thunderbolt8 Registered User Join Date: Sep 2006 Posts: 2,197	would be nice if jeeb could take over improving the splitter. __________________ Laptop Lenovo Legion 5 17IMH05: i5-10300H, 16 GB Ram, NVIDIA GTX 1650 Ti (+ Intel UHD 630), Windows 10 x64, madVR (x64), MPC-HC (x64), LAV Filter (x64), XySubfilter (x64) (K-lite codec pack)

24th June 2013, 10:39	#122 \| Link
Octo-puss Registered User Join Date: Jan 2008 Posts: 571	Hm, new features are nice, but only one bugfix mentioned. I am afraid... (or maybe not since I long ago switched to LAV :P)

28th August 2014, 22:44	#125 \| Link
Djfe Registered User Join Date: May 2014 Posts: 24	I should be more clear about what I mean by crash: I use the TS Doctor, which uses Haali as a Splitter for it's cutting preview window If I use LAV as a Splitter it doesn't crash, but with Haali it crashes The developer of the TSD says that this is caused by the Haali Splitter because of the issue mentioned above and not by the TSD itself

29th August 2014, 19:51	#128 \| Link
Djfe Registered User Join Date: May 2014 Posts: 24	Would also be nice if Haali and LAV could be joined/merged, because LAV is in active development and maybe nevcairiel could use some of the code of the Haali Splitter to improve his and make a better one (at least for the Splitter part)

30th August 2014, 01:46	#129 \| Link
clsid ***** Join Date: Feb 2005 Posts: 5,647	That is not going to happen. If there is something that Haali can do that LAV can't then you should submit a feature request (or bug report). The only thing I can think of right now is the ability to switch Programs in a MPEG-TS files, which is already on the LAV Filters (long term) ToDo list. In general LAV is already way ahead of Haali in terms of functionality and stability. __________________ MPC-HC 2.2.1

30th August 2014, 22:27	#130 \| Link
Djfe Registered User Join Date: May 2014 Posts: 24	One thing I'm missing: LAV is more for playback than Haali Haali is way more precise if it comes to reading out exact timecodes/frame-types etc. all this is needed by editor like the TSD which allows you to cut your records at least this is what Cypheros said about it

31st August 2014, 09:01	#131 \| Link
nevcairiel Registered Developer Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Hamburg/Germany Posts: 10,347	DirectShow is a terrible platform for cutting, its not designed for that purpose, and any tool trying to use it for that is flawed by design. But like I mentioned before, anyone is welcome to provide patches for a feature they care about. Thats really how open source works. I'm not paid by anyone to work on anything specific, I work on what I care about, and what I want in the future of my project. And considering I don't see DirectShow even as a viable framework for editing, you can imagine how much I care about such improvements myself. Just asking for stuff isn't going to make it magically appear, unless someone wants to work on it. __________________ LAV Filters - open source ffmpeg based media splitter and decoders Last edited by nevcairiel; 31st August 2014 at 09:05.

31st August 2014, 17:24	#132 \| Link
Djfe Registered User Join Date: May 2014 Posts: 24	Of course and I really appreciate your work on open source filters/splitter and of course directshow isn't perfect but it would cost a lot of money for the licenses to write something on your own (since Cypheros software is commercial)