Welcome to Doom9's Forum, THE in-place to be for everyone interested in DVD conversion.

Before you start posting please read the forum rules. By posting to this forum you agree to abide by the rules.

 

Go Back   Doom9's Forum > Video Encoding > New and alternative video codecs
Register FAQ Calendar Today's Posts Search

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 16th July 2003, 19:26   #1  |  Link
Sagittaire
Testeur de codecs
 
Sagittaire's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: France
Posts: 2,484
[TEST] Visual, PSNR, SSIM, VQM tests with RV9, XviD ,DivX, WMV9 ...

Two Towers (Trailer 178 sec)

~~ PSNR, SSIM, VQM Test ~~


Code:
| Codec            | P-Process |  Settings  |  Size   |   PSNR  |   SSIM   |    VQM   |
|------------------|-----------|------------|---------|---------|----------|----------|
| Xvid Devapi4     |    No     |  570 kbps  | 640x272 | 40.7359 | 0.961267 | 0.855857 |
| Divx Kaukura     |    No     |  570 kbps  | 640x272 | 40.9452 | 0.963071 | 0.816827 |
| VMV9             |    No     |  570 kbps  | 640x272 | 41.0462 | 0.964233 | 0.810412 |
| RV9              |           |  570 kbps  | 640x272 | 41.2712 | 0.966207 | 0.809199 |
|------------------|-----------|------------|---------|---------|----------|----------|
| Xvid Devapi4     |    No     |  715 kbps  | 640x272 | 41.7980 | 0.968348 | 0.758332 |
| Divx Kaukura     |    No     |  715 kbps  | 640x272 | 41.8806 | 0.968601 | 0.742593 |
| VMV9             |    No     |  715 kbps  | 640x272 | 42.4004 | 0.970695 | 0.717179 |
| RV9              |           |  715 kbps  | 640x272 | 42.2920 | 0.971928 | 0.723943 |
|------------------|-----------|------------|---------|---------|----------|----------|
| Xvid Devapi4     |    No     |  950 kbps  | 640x272 | 43.0887 | 0.975330 | 0.655166 |
| Divx Kaukura     |    No     |  950 kbps  | 640x272 | 43.0920 | 0.974714 | 0.653429 |
| VMV9             |    No     |  950 kbps  | 640x272 | 43.5733 | 0.976320 | 0.640811 |
| RV9              |           |  950 kbps  | 640x272 | 42.9970 | 0.975566 | 0.656301 |
|------------------|-----------|------------|---------|---------|----------|----------|

Download and compare ... no comment is necessary ...



~~ Configurations codecs used ~~

WMV9
Adjustments: Maximum quality + Complex + 2 pass + Force Post Process Mode = 0


RV9 EHQ
Adjustments: EHQ 85 + MSL 60 sec + 2 pass


XviD Devapi4
Adjustments: Ultra high + h263 + vhq4 + chroma motion + bframe 1/150/75 + 2 pass


DivX Pro Kaukuru
Adjustments: Bframe + Slowest + Bitrate Modulation "Slow Movie" + 2 Pass


~~ Script AVS ~~

Encodage
Code:
source=Mpeg2Source("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\azerty.d2v")
source=Crop(source,24,88,-24,-72)
source=BicubicResize(source,640,272,0,0.6)
return source
Test PSNR
Code:
# --> Video Opening <--

source=AviSource("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\Encodage.avs")
source=ConvertToYV12(source)

video=AviSource("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\Kaukura-950.avi")
video=ConvertToYV12(video)

# --> PSNR analysis <--
CompareYV12(video,source,"","PSNR-Kaukura-950.txt")
Test SSIM
Code:
# --> Video Opening <--

source=AviSource("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\Encodage.avs")
source=ConvertToYV12(source)

video=AviSource("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\Kaukura-950.avi")
video=ConvertToYV12(video)

# --> PSNR analysis <--
return SSIM(source,video,"SSIM-Kaukura-950.txt")
Test VQM
Code:
# --> Video Opening <--

source=AviSource("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\Encodage.avs")
source=ConvertToYV12(source)

video=AviSource("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Les deux tours\Kaukura-950.avi")
video=ConvertToYV12(video)

# --> PSNR analysis <--
return VqmCalc(source,video,"VQM-Kaukura-950.txt")

Harry Potter II (Trailer 128 sec)

~~ PSNR, SSIM, VQM Test ~~


Code:
| Codec         | P-Process | Settings |  Size   |   PSNR  |   SSIM   |    VQM   |
|---------------|-----------|----------|---------|---------|----------|----------|
| DivX SBC      |    No     | 570 kbps | 576*240 | 44.5105 | 0.969443 | 0.745271 |
| Xvid Devapi4  |    No     | 570 kbps | 576*240 | 44.8596 | 0.972988 | 0.696618 |
| Divx Manihi   |    No     | 570 kbps | 576*240 | 44.9865 | 0.971749 | 0.685860 |
| VMV9          |    No     | 570 kbps | 576*240 | 45.1909 | 0.974026 | 0.671028 |
| RV9           |           | 570 kbps | 576*240 | 45.4853 | 0.975972 | 0.672990 |
|---------------|-----------|----------|---------|---------|----------|----------|
| DivX SBC      |    No     | 715 kbps | 640x272 | 45.0649 | 0.971749 | 0.705900 |
| Xvid Devapi4  |    No     | 715 kbps | 640x272 | 45.5277 | 0.975403 | 0.651688 |
| Divx Manihi   |    No     | 715 kbps | 640x272 | 45.6118 | 0.975643 | 0.644280 |
| VMV9          |    No     | 715 kbps | 640x272 | 45.7738 | 0.976034 | 0.630541 |
| RV9           |           | 715 kbps | 640x272 | 45.9816 | 0.977080 | 0.644326 |
|---------------|-----------|----------|---------|---------|----------|----------|
| DivX SBC      |    No     | 950 kbps | 720x288 | 45.5201 | 0.975122 | 0.641671 |
| Xvid Devapi4  |    No     | 950 kbps | 720x288 | 46.0449 | 0.978425 | 0.594206 |
| Divx Manihi   |    No     | 950 kbps | 720x288 | 46.1166 | 0.978254 | 0.591982 |
| VMV9          |    No     | 950 kbps | 720x288 | 46.2447 | 0.978799 | 0.584267 |
| RV9           |           | 950 kbps | 720x288 | 46.4354 | 0.978577 | 0.623178 |
|---------------|-----------|----------|---------|---------|----------|----------|



~~ Configurations codecs used ~~

WMV9
Adjustments: Maximum quality + Complex + 2 pass


RV9 EHQ
Adjustments: EHQ 85 + MSL 60 sec + 2 pass


XviD Devapi4
Adjustments: Ultra high + h263 + vhq4 + chroma motion + bframe 1/150/75 + 2 pass


DivX Pro Manihi
Adjustments: Bframe + Slowest + Bitrate Modulation "Slow Movie" + 2 Pass

DivX3 SBC ffvfw
Adjustments: SADT + chroma motion + 3 Pass



~~ Script AVS ~~

Encodage
Code:
source=Mpeg2Source("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Harry Potter\azerty.d2v")
source=Crop(source,18,76,-18,-76)
source=BicubicResize(source,640,272,0,0.6)
source=Convolution3D(source,0,3,4,3,4,3,0)
source=ConvertToYUY2(source)
return source
Test PSNR
Code:
# --> Video Opening <--

source=Mpeg2Source("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Harry Potter\azerty.d2v")
source=Crop(source,18,76,-18,-76)
source=BicubicResize(source,640,272,0,0.6)
source=Convolution3D(source,0,3,4,3,4,3,0)
source=ConvertToYUY2(source)

video=AviSource("D:\...\Kauehi.avi")
video=ConvertToYUY2(video)

# --> PSNR analysis <--
Compare(video,source,"","Kauehi.log")
Test PSNR XviD
Code:
# --> Video Opening <--

source=Mpeg2Source("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Harry Potter\azerty.d2v")
source=Crop(source,18,76,-18,-76)
source=BicubicResize(source,640,272,0,0.6)
source=Convolution3D(source,0,3,4,3,4,3,0)
source=ConvertToYUY2(source)

video=AviSource("D:\...\XviD.avi")
video=Trim(video,1,0)
video=ConvertToYUY2(video)

# --> PSNR analysis <--
Compare(video,source,"","XviD.log")
Test PSNR RV9
Code:
# --> Video Opening <--

source=Mpeg2Source("D:\Mes dossiers\B.A\Harry Potter\azerty.d2v")
source=Crop(source,18,76,-18,-76)
source=BicubicResize(source,640,272,0,0.6)
source=Convolution3D(source,0,3,4,3,4,3,0)
source=DeleteFrame(source,0)
source=ConvertToYUY2(source)

video=DirectShowSource("D:\...\RV9.rmvb",fps=25)
video=ConvertToYUY2(video)

# --> PSNR analysis <--
Compare(video,source,"","test.log")
__________________
Le Sagittaire ... ;-)

1- Ateme AVC or x264
2- VP7 or RV10 only for anime
3- XviD, DivX or WMV9

Last edited by Sagittaire; 10th September 2004 at 19:51.
Sagittaire is offline   Reply With Quote
 


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 22:02.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.