Doom9's Forum - View Single Post - [TEST] Rv9, Divx 51, H.264 R-D Plots

Sagittaire · 25th October 2003, 11:46

For Video
I make Test with RV9 EHQ, WMV9, DivX 5.10 and XviD Devapi with PSNR, SSIM and VQM. XviD and DivX are iso-compliant but not RV9 and WMV9. The best codecs are in order:

For animates
RV9 EHQ crushes everyone
WMV9
DivX 5.10
XviD Devapi4

For movies:
RV9 EHQ is the best
WMV9
DivX 5.10 Slowest 3 pass
XviD Devapi4

For Audio
The advanced audio codec are very similar for quality exepted MP3. but I make test with audio and for me the best codec are in order:

He-AAC 64~96
Vorbis 64~96
MP3Pro 64~96
RA8 Cook 64~96
WMV9 64~96
MP3 VBR 80~128 (with musicmatch jukebox encoder)

For Container
The best solution for container are:

1) RV9 EHQ / RA8 Cook / MKV

2) XviD Devapi4 / AAC / MP4
Menus integrated with Language and Sub selection but necessary envivio Plugin

3) WMV9 / WMA9 / MKV

4) DivX 5.10 / MP3 VBR / AVI
best hardware and software compatibility

25th October 2003, 11:46	#17 \| Link
Sagittaire Testeur de codecs Join Date: May 2003 Location: France Posts: 2,484	For Video I make Test with RV9 EHQ, WMV9, DivX 5.10 and XviD Devapi with PSNR, SSIM and VQM. XviD and DivX are iso-compliant but not RV9 and WMV9. The best codecs are in order: For animates RV9 EHQ crushes everyone WMV9 DivX 5.10 XviD Devapi4 For movies: RV9 EHQ is the best WMV9 DivX 5.10 Slowest 3 pass XviD Devapi4 For Audio The advanced audio codec are very similar for quality exepted MP3. but I make test with audio and for me the best codec are in order: He-AAC 64~96 Vorbis 64~96 MP3Pro 64~96 RA8 Cook 64~96 WMV9 64~96 MP3 VBR 80~128 (with musicmatch jukebox encoder) For Container The best solution for container are: 1) RV9 EHQ / RA8 Cook / MKV 2) XviD Devapi4 / AAC / MP4 Menus integrated with Language and Sub selection but necessary envivio Plugin 3) WMV9 / WMA9 / MKV 4) DivX 5.10 / MP3 VBR / AVI best hardware and software compatibility __________________ Le Sagittaire ... ;-) 1- Ateme AVC or x264 2- VP7 or RV10 only for anime 3- XviD, DivX or WMV9 Last edited by Sagittaire; 25th October 2003 at 11:49.