BIzzare error with ImgTool/Scenarist???

[Rombaldi]

OK.. here's the steps

1- create VIDEO_TS folder with Scenarist
2- burn VIDEO_TS folder with Prassi PrimoDVD (packed with the drive)

Disc plays perfectly in WinDVD, perfectly in DVD Player

3- make ISO with ImgTools (both the the current and previous build)
4- mount ISO with DaemonTools, plays perfectly in WinDVD
5- unmount, burn ISO with DVDDecrypter

Disc plays perfectly in WinDVD
Disc CRASHES when selecting any item from the menu when played in DVD Player!

"the plot thickens"

6- BEFORE MAKING ISO, run the ORIGINAL CREATED VIDEO_TS thru IFOEdit and do a Get_VTS Sectors... it DOES correct several errors (???).
7- make ISO with IMGTools (again using both versions)
8- mount ISO with DaemonTools, plays perfectly in WinDVD
9- unmount, burn ISP with DVDDecrypter

Disc plays perfectly in WinDVD, PERFECTLY IN DVD PLAYER

WTF????

NOTE 1: if I run IFOEdit/GET_VTS sectors on the BURNED DISC from step 2, it want's to correct the SAME ERRORS that I found in step 6 (??)

NOTE 2: pulling an ISO made back in the beginning from the disc burned with Prassi and then burning the ISO back (both operations) with DVDDecrypter makes a proper playable disc)

Would I be amiss in pointing the fickle finger of fate at ImgTools as the problem, or does anyone have any thoughts on what the heck is happening????

[coona]

I do not use Ifoedit for correcting sectors. Once I have original DVD5 movie. I ripped it wit DVD Decrypter, get VTS sector in ifoedit and got navigation error in standalone. Without correction it played flawlessly :confused:.

And another story - I did backup one of my movies, performed IfoUpdate and just to be sure I tried Ifoedit. It corrected a lot of sector and after burn my compilation didn´t work in standalone. I thought my fault and did it again with the same result. So I used only correction from IfoUpdate and everything worked fine.

my 2 cents :).

[Rombaldi]

Well.. similar but different...

1) IF I make the VIDEO_TS and burn it untouched.. it will play fine
2) IF I use IMGtools to make the ISO and burn it.. it will crash
3) IF I use IFOEdit to 'correct' the VIDEO_TS and then imgtools to burn it, it will play fine
5) IF I use IFOEdit to 'correct' the VIDEO_TS and burn directly it will play ok
6) IF I take the disc from 1) and make a DVDDecrypter ISO from it and burn, it will play ok
7) IF I take the disc from 1) and rip it in file mode and make an ISO with IMGtools it will play ok