new DVD2AVI testing with R4R required

[len0x]

Can someone who uses R4R regulary test new version of DVD2AVI done by Donald Graft and tell me if it's working ok for project creation/demuxing:
http://neuron2.net/fixd2v/decodefix.html

thanks.

[slimz]

just tried dvd2avi-dg out with R4R ;
title is crouching tiger hidden dragon, demuxing 6 channel english track.
works fine, and the audio encoded properly in besweet to vorbis.
ill try out mpeg2dec3dg.dll in gknot now and post results.

[len0x]

Originally posted by slimz
ill try out mpeg2dec3dg.dll in gknot now and post results.

this should work fine. I was testing it for a while already. I was only afraid that new CLI of DVD2AVI may not work properly with R4R (nothing I could do about it :) )

[slimz]

less work for you :)
keep up the good work!

[Christos]

Tried the new DVD2AVIdg with r4r and I found one small bug. When I choose to demux track number 1 it demuxes track number 2 instead

[len0x]

Originally posted by Christos
Tried the new DVD2AVIdg with r4r and I found one small bug. When I choose to demux track number 1 it demuxes track number 2 instead

can you post the log file from R4R, so that I can see the command line DVD2AVI started with, please ?

[Christos]

can you post the log file from R4R, so that I can see the command line DVD2AVI started with, please ?

Sure... Sorry for not doing so before :)
Here it is:

10:50:42 ìì: BEGIN RIP "DVDVolume" - 9/26/2003 10:50:42 PM
10:50:42 ìì: robot4rip (0.4.0.1087) - WinXP (5.1.2600.2)
************************************************************
Title: DVDVolume
FileName_ISO: C:\DVD\ISO\DVDVolume.iso
FolderName_Vob: C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\
FolderName_Prj: C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\DVDVolume\
pgc: 0
angle: 0
redirect: off
active_ISO: False
active_pgc: True
active_indexing: True
active_audio: False
active_vobsub: True
active_chapters: False
active_finalize: False
rip_from_DVD: True
extractBitmaps: True
************************************************************
IfoInfo:
Path: D:\VIDEO_TS\
Name: VTS_01_0.IFO
ShortName: VTS_01
ChainsCount: 1
HasAngles: False
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_5.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_6.VOB
pgc 1: 20 chapters, 21 cells, 1 audio streams
VobSize: 6391683072
Anamorphic: False
*
Audio Stream 1
Demux: True
Language: English
NumChannels: 2
CodingModeName: AC3
Stream: 0x80
Encoder Setting: 1
*
Subtitle Stream 1
Demux: True
Language: Greek
************************************************************
PGC details:
Num: 1
ChainTime: 01:43:55:61
Angle: 0
CellCount: 21
Available Audio Streams: 1
Available Subtitle Streams: 1
************************************************************
10:50:42 ìì: Plugin "AuthDVD.dll" loaded - authenticating...
10:50:42 ìì: Warning: Authentication not successful, either no DVD has been found or the DVD is not encrypted
10:50:42 ìì: PGC Rip
10:50:42 ìì: Creating destination folder "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\"
10:50:42 ìì: Copying Ifo file
10:50:42 ìì: Using DVDDecrypter
10:50:42 ìì: Ripping with C:\Program Files\Gordian Knot\DVDDecrypter.exe /MODE IFO /SRC D: /DEST "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\" /VTS 1 /PGC 1 /OVERWRITE YES /START /CLOSE
10:59:43 ìì: Video: VTS_01_1.VOB
10:59:43 ìì: Video: VTS_01_2.VOB
10:59:43 ìì: Video: VTS_01_3.VOB
10:59:43 ìì: Video: VTS_01_4.VOB
10:59:43 ìì: Video: VTS_01_5.VOB
10:59:43 ìì: Video: VTS_01_6.VOB
10:59:43 ìì: Creating project folder "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\DVDVolume\"
10:59:43 ìì: dvd2avi
10:59:43 ìì: Demuxing track 1
10:59:43 ìì: Indexing with C:\Program Files\Gordian Knot\DVD2AVI 1.77.3dg\DVD2AVIdg.exe -ia=1 -FO=0 -Cs=2 -YR=1 -TN=1 -IF=[C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_1.VOB,C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_2.VOB,C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_3.VOB,C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_4.VOB,C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_5.VOB,C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_6.VOB] -CF=4 -DD=1 -MA=1 -DRC=0 -OF=[C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\DVDVolume\DVDVolume] -exit
11:01:57 ìì: "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\DVDVolume\DVDVOLUME.d2v" created
11:01:57 ìì: Error: Audiofile (Track 2) not found
11:01:57 ìì: Analyzing d2v-file...
11:01:57 ìì: Source is not NTSC
11:01:57 ìì: FrameRate: 25000
11:01:57 ìì: Subtitles
11:01:57 ìì: Saving parameter-file
11:01:57 ìì: . C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\DVDVolume\VTS_01_0.IFO
11:01:57 ìì: . C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\DVDVolume\DVDVolume
11:01:57 ìì: . 1
11:01:57 ìì: . 0
11:01:57 ìì: . 0 cc
11:01:57 ìì: . CLOSE
11:01:57 ìì: rundll32 C:\WINDOWS\System32\vobsub.dll ,Configure C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\DVDVolume\vobsub.param
11:03:47 ìì: Extracting subtitles finished
11:03:47 ìì: END RIP "DVDVolume" (0 hours, 13 minutes, 05 seconds)
11:03:47 ìì: Warning: Log shows 1 error message

[len0x]

From what I can see audio track was not demuxed at all (error message might be wrong). It tried to demux track number 1, but since new option -OM (output method) was probably set to 0 which means "No demuxing" - nothing was demuxed...
Can you confirm - was there _any_ audio tracks after R4R was done working?

P.S. I'll ask TheWEF to change that (now that I know what exactly to be done).

[Christos]

No there were no tracks after this rip but I think thats simply because there was not a 2nd audio stream (track number 2) on the DVD I used.
I did another rip to test this on a Friends DVD which had 2 audo streams and although I checked the "1.English" audio track checkbox I got the 2nd one (french) on my HD. (FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B AC3 T02 2_0ch 192Kbps DELAY -72ms.ac3)
And strangely the log file is prety much the same...


8:19:35 ??: BEGIN RIP "FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B" - 9/28/2003 8:19:35 PM
8:19:35 ??: robot4rip (0.4.0.1087) - WinXP (5.1.2600.2)
************************************************************
Title: FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B
FileName_ISO: C:\DVD\ISO\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B.iso
FolderName_Vob: C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\
FolderName_Prj: C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\
pgc: 0
angle: 0
redirect: off
active_ISO: False
active_pgc: True
active_indexing: True
active_audio: False
active_vobsub: False
active_chapters: False
active_finalize: False
rip_from_DVD: True
extractBitmaps: True
************************************************************
IfoInfo:
Path: D:\VIDEO_TS\
Name: VTS_01_0.IFO
ShortName: VTS_01
ChainsCount: 7
HasAngles: False
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_1.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_2.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_3.VOB
D:\VIDEO_TS\VTS_01_4.VOB
pgc 1: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 2 audio streams
pgc 2: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 2 audio streams
pgc 3: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 2 audio streams
pgc 4: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 0 audio streams
pgc 5: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 2 audio streams
pgc 6: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 2 audio streams
pgc 7: 1 chapters, 1 cells, 2 audio streams
VobSize: 4178708480
Anamorphic: False
*
Audio Stream 1
Demux: True
Language: English
NumChannels: 2
CodingModeName: AC3
Stream: 0x80
Encoder Setting: 1
*
Audio Stream 2
Demux: False
Language: Fran?ais
NumChannels: 2
CodingModeName: AC3
Stream: 0x81
Encoder Setting: 1
*
Subtitle Stream 1
Demux: False
Language: English
*
Subtitle Stream 2
Demux: False
Language: Fran?ais
*
Subtitle Stream 3
Demux: False
Language: Suomi
*
Subtitle Stream 4
Demux: False
Language: Dansk
*
Subtitle Stream 5
Demux: False
Language: Svenska
*
Subtitle Stream 6
Demux: False
Language: Norsk
*
Subtitle Stream 7
Demux: False
Language: Nederlands
*
Subtitle Stream 8
Demux: False
Language: Islenska
*
Subtitle Stream 9
Demux: False
Language: English
************************************************************
PGC details:
Num: 1
ChainTime: 00:21:17:40
Angle: 0
CellCount: 1
Available Audio Streams: 1 2
Available Subtitle Streams: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
************************************************************
8:19:35 ??: Plugin "AuthDVD.dll" loaded - authenticating...
8:19:35 ??: Drive D: authenticated
8:19:35 ??: PGC Rip
8:19:35 ??: Creating destination folder "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\"
8:19:35 ??: Copying Ifo file
8:19:35 ??: Using DVDDecrypter
8:19:35 ??: Ripping with C:\Program Files\Gordian Knot\DVDDecrypter.exe /MODE IFO /SRC D: /DEST "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\" /VTS 1 /PGC 1 /OVERWRITE YES /START /CLOSE
8:21:45 ??: Video: VTS_01_1.VOB
8:21:45 ??: Creating project folder "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\"
8:21:45 ??: dvd2avi
8:21:45 ??: Demuxing track 1
8:21:45 ??: Indexing with C:\Program Files\Gordian Knot\DVD2AVI 1.77.3dg\DVD2AVIdg.exe -ia=1 -FO=0 -Cs=2 -YR=1 -TN=1 -IF=[C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Rips\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\VTS_01_1.VOB] -CF=4 -DD=1 -MA=1 -DRC=0 -OF=[C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B] -exit
8:22:21 ??: "C:\Documents and Settings\Christos\My Documents\My DVD\Projects\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B\9\FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B.d2v" created
8:22:22 ??: Error: Audiofile (Track 2) not found
8:22:22 ??: Analyzing d2v-file...
8:22:22 ??: Source is not NTSC
8:22:22 ??: FrameRate: 25000
8:22:22 ??: END RIP "FRIENDS_SERIES6_D3B" (0 hours, 02 minutes, 47 seconds)
8:22:22 ??: Warning: Log shows 1 error message

[len0x]

OK, I want you ro try 2 things (before I inform Neuron2 about the problem):

1) Check if DVD2AVI itself is able to demux first and second track manually: i.e. select Track 1 and then Track 2. And make sure that you used option Audio -> Method -> Demux

2) try doing that from command line by adding -OM=1 and then choosing between -TN=1 and -TN=2 (track 1 and two) to see if it works from command line...
(you have full command line in your log)

10x

[Christos]

I did what u asked and here's what I got...

1)Manual demux with DVD2AVIdg works fine for both tracks. (I did it first for track1 and then for track2 with option Audio -> Method -> Demux as u asked, not "demux all tracks")

2)From the commadline however demuxing is buggy.
* Using commandline from r4r log adding -OM=1 and leaving -TN=1 dumuxes 2nd track again.
* Using commandline from r4r log adding -OM=1 and changing to -TN=2 no track is demuxed
** Using commandline from r4r log adding -OM=1 and changing to -TN=0(yes zero) 2nd track is demuxed!!!

I hope this helps :)

[neuron2]

Silly me! :rolleyes:

I've fixed this problem in beta 17. I failed to decrement the Track_Flag variable by one after parsing it. Sorry for the inconvenience and thank you for pointing it out.

http://neuron2.net/fixd2v/decodefix.html

[Christos]

:) :) :)
I tried the new beta. Everything OK now.
Thank you both for the fast response, and for the GREAT tools you are giving us...

Cheers

[neuron2]

@Christos

Nothing would be possible without the efforts of those such as yourself. First, without users what is the point? But more importantly, you provide really valuable testing feedback that keeps the developer guys honest. Thanks once again. I can't find the smilie I want for you, but it is the bowing down one. :D

[TheWEF]

r4r updated and sent to len0x for testing.

wef.

[len0x]

ppl can grab r4r 0.5 for testing here:

http://members.fortunecity.com/len0x/robot4rip.0.5.Setup.zip

(will be available only a few days)

[len0x]

And plz report if new R4R is working for you, btw.

[Angelus]

I just used r4r 0.5 with the latest dvd2avi from neuron2 to do "2 fast 2 furious" and everything worked fine. Thanks again for your great programs!

[Christos]

I did several rips over the past few days and everething went A OK. :) Thank you all (neuron2, TheWEF, len0x) once again...

Cheers

[Angelus]

I don't know if this is robot4rip related or dvd2avi related but every time I use robot4rip and it opens up dvd2avi and created a .d2v file, it list the ac3 file as having a delay. But when I open up the VOB files with the same version of dvd2avi and do it manually, the delay comes back as zero. This is the second time I've had this happen since upgrading to robot4rip .5

Thanks

[len0x]

indeed there was a problem with cli processing in new dvd2avi which was fixed in the latest release - rc3. go get at usual place

http://neuron2.net/fixd2v/decodefix.html

everybody who's using new version of dvd2avi within r4r should upgrade asap. sorry for not mentioning it here.