dvd2one or dvdshrink for best quality?

[mrchri5]

dvdshrink is a great program. I especially like being able to crop the movie. But is it any better than dvd2one? I just did mr bean disc 2 with dvd2one and by viewing on my computer screen the output only looks slightly fuzzier than the original. with dvdshrink I would of needed 40% compression. Dvd2one also gets the size right everytime. So does anyone know for sure which is better quality? its hard for me to tell.

thanks

[mrbass]

Only way to know is to do it yourself and put yourself in the judges chair. Use PowerDVD and flip through the video frame by frame hit the 'T' key. And do keep in mind that dvdshrink 1.03 and 2.3 compression ratios cannot be compared.

[mrchri5]

it looks about the same to me. I guess if I can barely tell on the computer screen it shouldn't be noticeable even on my hdtv.

[Gang$ta]

I did a few movies using both..

I find that dvdone has a kind of pulsating in the background & fast
scenes..
with dvdshrink,using level 1 or 2,there is not..

[DMagic1]

I tried to compare these two app and couldnt see a difference but thats my eyes. Here is an interesting post comparing all the one click apps.

http://forum.digital-digest.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=21247