Chapters, who is right?

[Scoobydeux]

OK, I am pondering again. I use ChaptXtract on Spiderman, then I use IFOUpdate to get a different chapter list, and I get two lists of chapters that are between 13 and 21 ms off of eachother, a difference that MIGHT cause an I frame to be created 1 frame off...

Which is more accurate?

Second question, when a film is mixed (FILM & NTSC) does IFOUpdate take that into consideration when you save the "CCE Forced Film" chapter file? If not, and it assumes a constant framerate, would that not throw it off?:confused:

If anyone is wise to this, please let me know...

[slk001]

Which is more accurate? Don't be so anal about your precision. Since your frames are occurring every ~42mS (FILM rate), either one seems more accurate than it needs.

Are you using this info to set CCE I-frame insertion points? If so, then either one will do.

Bitrate is not important. Chapters are set by time.

[Scoobydeux]

Sorry, I fixed the message, I meant to say it assumes a constant FRAMErate, not bitrate.....

Scoobydeux