View Full Version : Anamorphic back to 4x3
qwerr
6th December 2002, 07:13
I've been using the anamorphic setting virtually since day one when it was available - but on replacing my dead Philips dvd player with a new Philips dvd player - the new one doesn't recognise the anarmorphic tag encoding. I can "trick" the new player by inserting a dvd then it reads the following anamorphic svcds.
It's not entirely satisfactory as I had so many problems with the old Philips - that it wouldn't be surprising if the new one stops accepting the "trick".
(I know I shouldn't have bought a Philips again but I like the 5.1 multichannel output I can achieve.)
So if any one knows how i can re-tag the mpeg header tag on the svcds - or any other ideas or solutions - they would be greatly appreciated...:D
UltimateDBZ
6th December 2002, 07:22
Problem posts go in the Basic section.
xp_eric
6th December 2002, 12:45
yes you can : use DVDPatcher (kickme.to/dvdpatcher)
Use 4:3 for your 2.35:1 movies, the aspect result is exactly the same (just the anamorphic bit isn't set)
cheers,
:sly: Eric
markrb
6th December 2002, 17:03
Well there will be major issues. The video will still not have those black bars. If you are going to be playing these on a 4:3 TV they will become stretched and distorted if you can do it at all.
The only way to get the black bars back is to re-encode the video.
If you are going to be playing this on a widescreen TV then I do not know what will happen if you can infact remove the 16:9 tag from the mpeg video.
I have never seen or used the above mentioned program so I can't confirm or deny what it will do.
Mark
xp_eric
6th December 2002, 23:28
wel try this : encode a DVD / Divx in both 4:3 and anamorphic (after each other ;-) and look closely at the AviSynth script. You will see they are both EQUAL !!!! So black borders / strectching will be exacly the same on both a 4:3 and a widescreen TV. The ONLY advantage for the anamorphic bit is some DVD players / TV's / Software players adjust the ratio automatically...
cheers,
:sly: Eric
markrb
6th December 2002, 23:46
xp_eric yes you are correct the Avisynth files are the same.
What I was saying if you play a non anamorphic 16:9 video on a 4:3 TV it distorts becuase the DVD player will stretch the video to fit the screen as it thinks the video is 4:3. That same video played on a 16:9 WideScreen TV does not distort since the ouput TV is 16:9. Nowhere in the post does he say if it's going to be played on a widescreen TV or not.
Removing the 16:9 tag if possible will probably work on a widescreen TV, but will definately not work on a 4:3 TV. For it to work on a 4:3 TV you need to re-encode the video with the borders added.
Mark
xp_eric
7th December 2002, 00:06
or have a 4:3 set with a widescreen button which adds the borders (like all recent Philips set have). Even several DVD players can do this. Encoding like this has the advantage of "compatibility" on both 4:3 and widescreen sets...
cheers,
:sly: Eric
qwerr
7th December 2002, 01:11
thanks everybody for the replies - I have a philips widescreen tv - I dont plan to ever use a 4x3 tv set again.
Because I'm pretty slow with all things technical - I assume from your advice that I demux the burnt mpg's and reencode using dvdpatcher then remux and re-iauthor - OR can dvdpatcher do the reencode without me demuxing the video and audio streams??
Again - I'm extremely greatful for your help...:D :D
qwerr
7th December 2002, 01:33
- also without stretching a friendship - when using dvdpatcher - which option do i select
- Patch first header only OR..
- Patch entire file..
Again, many thanks ..:D :D
markrb
7th December 2002, 05:14
xp_eric that is one option no TV's have here in North America. I wish they did.
Mark
vBulletin® v3.8.5, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.