Problems with Vobs from LOTR SEE

[Snakeisthestuff]

Hi, my problem is that i cant ripp these LOTR SEE DVDs! I tried Smartripper and i got everytime a corrupt Vob file with an error, that looks like an dropped keyframe, on the same place. Then i tried vstrip cause i heard, it ripps everything but i got also an corrupt vob file but the error was on a different place this time. so did someone experience the same problem as i???
i dont know what to do.
and yes my dvd-drive works fine - have done many dvd ripps and never got such a problem :( .

[jggimi]

This may be your trouble.

----------------------------------

Interactual reports a problem with FOTR:EE discs with specific reported DVD-ROM drives:

Samsung SD-616, commonly sold in Dell and HP desktop PC's
LG DRD8160B, commonly sold in Sony, Dell, or Compaq desktop PC's
LG DRN8080B, commonly sold in Compaq and HP laptop PC's

According to Interactual, it is a problem with DVD-ROM firmware, not with the DVD discs, which are compliant with the DVD Specification.

See http://www.theonering.net/perl/newsview/2/1037293699 for more information.

[Snakeisthestuff]

got it working now, seems to be an OS problem cause i tried it under win98 SE and got always an corrupt vob file, today i tried to ripp it with DVD-Decrypter under Win2k and it works, its maybe something aspi related or so...