A problem with OggMux 0.8.5 see attachments

[kxy]

Has both OggDS--0.9.9.1 and SubTitDS installed.

I made a srt with subripper 1.00b, when I click on mux, nothing would go, it would stay at zero percent. If I check the Paging file Usage, it would increase steady. I let it go around up to 400mb, then I killed the process. <See Att: bad>

I then use subresync(dvobsub) to re-create this subtitle. Again use oggMux, this time it would go, but subtitle is off sync, and also miss some subtitle(the subtitle is there in the srt file, just dind't disply on the movie). <See att: off sync>

So I use subresync again, this time with unicode out put, the oggMux would able to mux the movie, no error reported. But when I open the file, there is no subtitle option. <see att: nonexistense.srt>

Note: Even tho the content of all three files are the same, but they all have different file sizes.

I have tested this problem with 3 different subtitles, so it is not just this one.

[Koepi]

You're sure you hadn't VobSub installed at any time?

It's btw. no problem with OggMux 0.8.5....

Koepi

[kxy]

No Koepi,

dvob sub is not installed. Have you checked the header files of the 3 identical srt files?

The one that doesn't have subtitle showing is missing the subtitle 65535 to subtitle in thru graphedit.

[Koepi]

...so it (the .srt) is broken? Well....

Nothing left to say (only that none of your attachments are validated by the moderators of this forum and thus don't show up here...)

[ookzDVD]

@Koepi,

Hello,
btw, is there a way to know the "exact" frame where OggMux cut
while enabling the cutting feature.

What I'm doing now is demux it to the AVI and open the AVI from VirtualDub.

Thank you.

[kxy]

Koepi,

So you didn't get to look at the file yet? Can any MOD please enable the attatchment, it has being 2 days.

What I am saying is, even if the header of the srt is messed up, should it have some error message, instead of hanging there, or in the 3rd case, muxed but without having the subtitle shows up in the end.

[Koepi]

I can't check a srt for errors - the DirectShow filter should do that. If it doesn't return an error code, I assume the operation went fine.

Sorry for the bad news.

Regards,
Koepi

[Belgabor]

I had a look at the subs, the content is not the same (on hex level at least)

the 'bad' one is just that, bad. it has malformed line ends (#13#13#10, correct for windows is #13#10). the out-of-sync one has the correct ones. I didnt look at the unicode one, but I'd guess the subparser or muxer simply doesnt support it.

What I'd say is, your subs are simply out of sync, you gotta resync them and look for the right line ends (#13#10, or 0D 0A in hex)

Cheers
Belgabor

P.S: the OGG Sub-System seems to be quite picky on the file format, as already posted in another thread, unix like lineends (only #10) dont work either.

[kxy]

Great job looking at the hex, Belgabor. This what I meant, a better support system. But according to Koepi if it doesn't return an error code, he assume the operation is fine.