PDA

View Full Version : Quicktime selectable subtitles - Almost cracked it! Help?


audiovizual
22nd March 2008, 16:54
Ok, Ive been fiddling with trying to get quicktime selectable subtitles, and Ive managed it! :)

The only thing is I get a shadow bar across the video underneath the sub and I cant figure out how to get rid of it. :mad:

Maybe someone will be able to give input with this?

Here how Im doing it:
Tools:
Quicktime Pro
Dumpster

So I create a timed text track in Notepad, then open it in QT and export it to a 3GPP movie.

I then open the 3GPP file Ive just created and do Select All > Copy.

I open my mp4 video file and go Edit > Add to Selection and Scale. This adds the 3GPP file into the video file. Under Movie Properties you can alter the position if you wish. Then save this as a self-contained movie. We now have the subs in place, but theyre not selectable.

To make them selectable we need Dumpster. This bit is slightly tricky, so only do it on test files at first.

Open the self-contained movie in Dumpster, and doubleclick on 'moov' Movie resource atom. Then doubleclick 'trak' Track atom. You will see 2 or 3 of these, you want the bottom one, since the subtitle track was the last one added to the file.

Now doubleclick 'mdia' Media atom, then 'hdlr' Handler reference atom. You will now see several settings, one of which is Component subtype. It will be set to 'text'. We need to change it to 'sbtl'.

Unfortunately, Dumpster works in hex, so we need to change the hex value. Click on Component subtype, and the hex value will appear in the bar at the bottom of the window.

Look for the last $ on this line, after this there will be an 8 digit number. Replace this number (not including the $) with: 7362746c Click apply, and you will see the 'text' setting change to 'sbtl'. Close Dumpster.

Reopen your movie in QT, and the subtitles will now be selectable, albeit with the shadow bar mentioned previously. This will also work in iTunes, but Im not sure about the Ipod, I dont have one to test with.

Hopefully there is somone on the forum perhaps is a bit more knowledgable about atoms etc who might be able to take this further to remove the shadow bar completely?

Cheers

b66pak
10th December 2008, 00:38
any progress in this matter?
_

thommyfilm
18th December 2008, 09:38
just try muxo on the mac:
http://forum.entropicgarden.com/

(click on "Download latest version...")

Nemesis7
29th December 2008, 23:08
I've struggled with this for a while as well, but the thing u need to do in QuickTime is to choose an alternate track for the subtitle, meaning if you select sub1, the alternate should be sub2, this will let you switch between the subs. Also see my post in the HandBrake forum (search for soft subtitles).

Hope this helps.

peterpan4711
10th January 2009, 11:43
Hi,

if you want to add soft subs into a mp4-file - for example into a movie that can be shown on an iphone/ipod I recommend the software "mp4te".

So far this is the only and first software that was able to add working soft-subs to my iphone movies.

The programs is quite fast - adding .srt-subs for a 2-hour-movie only took some minutes.

Besides: i have also tried to use "yamb" but it never worked.

p4te is a very new program and a bit buggy, nevertheless is works well.

Nemesis7
11th January 2009, 12:07
Yes I'm familiar with mp4te but it's very buggy and limited like you said. But as far as I remember mp4te doesn't support multiple selectable audio and subtitle tracks.